Thankfully, there is no elimination this week, so those couples who didn’t do so hot tonight at least have one more chance to redeem themselves and hopefully avoid next week’s elimination. But just for fun, I’m going to rank anyway, as if there were an elimination tomorrow night – just to see how these couples stack up
ONWARD!
2.) Ralph & Karina – I hearby retract my previous statement that Ralph was “awkward” and “might not get very far” – this was my favorite performance of the night! Ralph must sleep in a hyperbaric chamber or something, because he looks almost untouched by time – and he’s retained that boyish charm that made him so loveable in the Karate Kid movies. I have to give Karina props, too – she really seems to have a knack for foxtrots (remember the potentially disastrous “Boom Boom Pow” that she managed to make really cool last season?), and this was no exception – loved the classy, traditional feel of it. Man, Ralph can really move – he was jumping, kicking, extending, and twirling with incredible ease – I felt like I was watching an old Fred Astaire & Ginger Rogers movie. He was clean, crisp, & cool. Ralph also seems to have the same self-deprecating sense of humor that Kirstie does, which seems to appeal to the masses – he doesn’t take himself too seriously, and isn’t afraid to have fun out on the floor. Now that Ralph has caught everyone’s eye, I think his fanbase will grow exponentially – as long as he & Karina can keep up the momentum they started this week.
3.) Hines & Kym – I was expecting Hines to wow me after watching his rehearsal footage, and the man did not let me down

This was fun, cool, and a nice first “taste” of what Hines is capable of. I like that he’s not afraid to really move (like Romeo), and he can really work the crowd. However, he does seem like he might have a bit of the same problem that Warren had initially – he tends to be a bit clunky when he places his feet, and may struggle with more refined foot movements. But luckily for him, Kym has dealt with this before, and will get him on the right path for continued success. I thought this was a bit underscored – I would have given it at least a point higher. But I’m sure the Steeler Nation will pick up any slack in scores with their power voting
4.) Chelsea & Mark – This was a bit odd for me (and apparently Heidi & a few others who I was discussing the show with on Twitter), because at times this routine felt a bit more like something Derek would have choreographed; then Mark would inject some of his signature “spazz” into it and ruin it. I really liked the parts of it that felt fluid – mainly the parts where they actually stayed in hold – but there was wayyyy too much open work for my tastes, and it seemed…jerky. Chelsea seems like she has great potential – she actually seemed to keep up with Mark’s energy and not look totally ridiculous – but she does seem a bit wobbly, especially on her turns. However, she has a great smile and a sunny disposition, which I think will carry these two far…at least to the quarter-finals. Overall, I’d say it was pleasant, but not fantastic; and I think Mark needs to either reign it in a bit or Chelsea needs to step it up a bit so they don’t look so lopsided energy-wise.
5.) Kendra & Louis – I’m afraid these two were the biggest letdown of the evening for me – with all of the talking Louis’ been doing about Kendra being a “frontrunner”, I was expecting major moves to be busted in their routine…and unfortunately, it was just more…bust. Kendra seems to have inherited Wobbly Model syndrome, as she seemed to waver through every turn, and it actually made me a bit nervous – at one point, it looked like Louis might have almost dropped her. And I agree with whatever judge said that Kendra does everything with a bent knee – she should have a look at Kirstie, who in my opinion almost NAILED the characteristic bending & straightening action of the knees in the cha-cha…and while she’s at it, Kendra can also learn how to be “sassy” and not have it look forced & uncomfortable. And maybe it’s just me, but these two came across as the one of the least likeable couples tonight – a couple of things Kendra said just came across as a bit coarse to me, and I am already sick of Louis talking about how great Kendra is & how he deserves the MBT. Tonight, I feel like Louis took a shovel, dug a small hole, and then handed the shovel to Kendra and let her dig them into an even bigger hole. Oy vey…I hope these two can clean up both their dancing & their personalities!
6.) Ray & Anna – I hearby declare “Ray” the acceptable abbreviation of Sugar Ray’s name here at PureDWTS

I got a bit worried watching their package, when I saw how seriously Ray is taking this competition – made me worry that he might have a hard time enjoying himself. But I got such joy watching him ham it up out there during his foxtrot! It started off a bit slow & stiff, but as the music played on I think he loosened up & started to have fun. Looks like Ray’s got some major issues while in dance hold, though – very stiff. He seemed to fare much better with the open work. Hopefully he’ll be able to cut loose & have fun with the jive next week. My main worry about these two is that Ray is going to get so “in his own head” in each dance that it’s going to make him forget to also HAVE FUN. But it looks like he & Anna are very well-matched, so hopefully she’ll loosen him up.
7.) Romeo & Chelsie – Ok, I think we can all admit that Romeo is nowhere near as bad as his dad

That said – he still has LOTS of room for improvement. He seems way too apprehensive about cutting loose & “looking silly”, which is something he’s going to need to get over – FAST – if he wants to stick around this season. I really think that might be the one thing that’s hindering him…I saw shades of great dancing in his cha-cha tonight, as if he may have forgotten for a split second to “be cool”, and then he’d catch himself and go back to being “walls up, too cool for school” Romeo. He seems like he does have moves…somewhere underneath all that bravado. As for Chelsie – honey, maybe you’ve been spending too much time with Mark, because you’re starting to dance around your partners more & more. Make HIM dance to YOU
8.) Chris & Cheryl – I’m gonna give these two a slight benefit of the doubt tonight, because I think they may have gotten stuck with the crappiest song of the night for their cha-cha…too many awkward rhythm changes. That said – I really wanted to like these two, but this was lackluster. I can see what direction Cheryl was trying to go with it – playing on the edgy “rock star” persona Chris has – but it just felt kind of awkward & tacky to me. Chris, god love him, seems to really be trying – I’m just not sure he’s succeeding. He’s a bit “stompy”, as he tends to pound his feet into every move, rather than placing them – but the poor guy is a huge bundle of muscle. I’d also like to see him really “pick up” his posture & present his chest more, because dude has a nice chest…and I like nice chests. I’m hoping he can clean up & refine some of his movements a bit more for next week, when he has a ballroom dance. I think there are less-skilled dancers with less-popular pros and fewer fans that will likely go before him, which will hopefully keep him around long enough to improve.
9.) Petra & Dmitry – Let me start of by saying this: Petra is a SAINT. Someone who just seems so thankful to be alive, and wants to share that joy with others in any way she can. I think that’s an attitude we call can aspire to. I just wish that joy translated into great dancing, because this was…well, okay to marginal. The poor girl is just so tall & lanky, with limbs that go on forever, and she seems to struggle with where to put them – makes me very, very worried for her jive next week. She also seemed to get off-time a bit, which resulted in some telltale shuffling on Dmitry’s part to compensate. The choreography was pretty, but wasted too much time at the beginning and end for me – I would rather Dmitry use that time to do some sort of trick with Petra, instead of just walking around with a jacket. And unfortunatley, this song was pretty, but sleepy; the overall result was a pretty-but-sleepy dance. I’d like to see her improve, because tall, willowy ladies like her are STUNNING when they can really nail a dance – so let’s hope this performance and next week’s are enough to keep her around.
10.) Wendy & Tony – These two are just one big enigma for me. One minute, Wendy seems to be having fun and being goofy; the next, she’s somber & in tears. And it’s only the first week! Her cha-cha kind of felt the same way for me – she started off looking like she was ready to have fun & cut loose, and then she’s making these tiny, timid little movements the whole time. If Wendy is known for injecting major attitude into everything she does, then I’m sorry, but there must have been an imposter out on the floor tonight. Tony was a total non-event in this dance for me - I forgot he was even there. I’d say these two are probably the most awkward pairing, as neither one seems to mesh very well with the other – and I feel like neither is 100% invested in the show this season, and it shows. I’m tentatively putting these two as safe, because I think Wendy’s alleged “huge fanbase” (we’ll see about that) might rally to keep her around if she sucks again next week. But she could be interchangeable with…
11.) Mike & Lacey - FACT: DWTS viewers have, historically, not really been huge fans of comedians (think Penn Jillette, David Allen Grier, Jeff Ross, Ashley Hamilton, etc.). FACT: They also don’t seem to like celebs who don’t seem to be taking the competition seriously. I think Mike may have violated both of those rules tonight by putting off the “I’m a funny perv who doesn’t really care about how I do on the show” vibe. I thought the guy was hilarious (and I will save my detailed opinion for the cheesecake

), but some less laid-back viewers could just take it as Mike being an ass. And this foxtrot didn’t do he or Lacey any favors - there are no words. It was just…”special”. And an all-around hot mess. I would say this dance could be the final nail in the coffin for these two, but something tells me that if Lacey can pull out a decent jive (and Wendy can be timid & tearful another week), then they may get a “get out of jail free” pass. But I’m skeptical, considering that people are still saying “Mike WHO?”
Woohoo! My first rankings of the regular season are donesky – so what do you guys think? Who are the front-runners, who’s in the middle of the pack, and who’s bringing up the rear? Let’s hear it! And stay tuned for some cheesecake later in the week…Heidi & I are already preheating the oven…;-)
Wow, what a night and it didn’t disappoint. It felt like there was a hole without Derek, but, you could still feel his spirit strongly in the house. Ok, my thoughts;
Chelsea and Mark – I loved how light, airy, and refreshing she was….a great improvement from watching Bristol with Mark. She was a little messy and she needs to work on her lines. But, she was beautiful. I loved her dress. 7
Wendy and Tony – One of my followers at twitter (@lokilokiloki) said Wendy needs to lose the “divatude” and he was right. She was more concerned about her nails than she was her dancing. I hate to say it but, she is the “Bristol” of this Season as far as dancing ability. However, she is more likable. I hope she can loosen up and not let the pressure get to her because there is an entertainer waiting to bloom on the dancefloor which could be super fun and she needs to capitalize on it. 3
Kym and Hines – Wow, I was so impressed with his footwork (much like Kirstie). He may be a big guy, but, that is not going to hang him up in the least. I loved that SMILE! He was having fun and relaxed. He is “Donny Osmond” in the making, simple as. 7
Sugar Ray and Anna – Sugar was a little stiff and this could be his weakness. But, he was so charming and entertaining. He has a great smile too. His dancing and style reminded me a lot of Rick Fox last year. 6
Kendra and Louis – I thought Kendra would be better than she was, but, she wasn’t. I felt like she was trying too hard to be sexy when she needs to just let it all out naturally. I’m not sure what it is….but, she has a lot of nerves and moves to work out. 6
Ralph and Karina – Wow, he was so smooth and charming!! I loved the unique choreography. They have done their homework. He has a lot of potential more than he thinks he does. I love that he is so humble. Very cool! 8
Cheryl and Chris – Another one with a big bright smile that is fun to watch!! He was a little stiff and slow, but, he’s a natural on stage and you can tell he is having a blast with this experience and loving it. 6
Mike and Lacey – First of all, can I say how much I can’t stand Lacey’s hair? It looks like she hasn’t washed her hair in weeks.
lol As for Mike, I think he is so scared. I don’t think he’s as bad as he thinks, but, he just needs to believe in himself and then maybe the moves would come more naturally to him? 5
Kirstie and Maks – Wow, they killed it. These two have the chance to take the Mirror Ball this year if they play their cards just like they did tonight. She used her acting ability in this dance. She was quick on her feet. She truly “sparkled” and they brought everything together. Excellent. I loved that little sexy hot move she pulled off with Maks at the end sealing it too. Outstanding! 8
My faves of the night in this order: Kirstie, Ralph, and Hines.
Now onto read Courtney’s rankings and thoughts!!
Courtney, great rankings. You said it about Kendra. Her dance felt forced. Louis has been acting so over confident. Well, he needs to rethink his game plan and they seem very detached.
Great notes. It would be nice to see Karina carry someone further.
For me, I think the judges actually scored pretty decently tonight. I had problems with one or two single scores (And look at Carrie Ann voting with her hormones again.), but overall, no complaints.
My favorites of the night were Kirstie and Maks – I had been a little worried, but DAMN, that woman has sparkle and sass and she plays off Maks SO well. I really hope they can keep it up because she’s truly enjoying it and as a result, we’re enjoying her!
I also enjoyed Mark and Chelsea and Ralph and Karina (it about kills me to say it, but there you go, fair is fair.) Ralph was a real pleasant surprise and he reminded me a bit of Evan with his long, lanky limbs. And as for Mark – I LOVED how he choreographed for a partner who has some innate ability! I saw the story in the routine and felt like he was finally able to do something with what he was given instead of trying to rescue a trainwreck. (And I don’t know, I thought his ‘spazzing’ as you called it, Courtney, fit properly into the overall story of the dance itself.) And that Chelsea is a little charmer, isn’t she?
I have to agree with Courtney, though, about Louis and Kendra – and God, didn’t HE looked pissed at the end of their routine? – their personalities are gonna kill them, I think. She looked like her teeth were clenched together throughout the whole dance – at least when she wasn’t counting. I was very unimpressed, I have to say.
And I wonder just how much of a liability Petra’s past injuries are going to be to her and Dmitry. I thought their dance was quite pretty, but it really didn’t have much ‘soul’ to it.
Wendy, OMG, I said to my friend who I was chatting with that it was like watching Kate dance again, only she was happy to be dancing. But, by Christ, that woman has some frontal acreage! It might need a partner all its own!
So yeah… it was a GREAT show tonight and I’m already jonesing for next week!!
Great post, BTW, Courtney! (Even if I didn’t agree with quite everything. *g*)
Vogue, we have the same favorites!
Sooo happy that Ralph did so well. I knew he was going to be the sleeper hit!
why wasn’t Derek involved in this season’s show????? He is still the best male dancer, as his sister was while being with the show….
Amazing first night! For once ABC got it totally right! The judging was uniform and fair, all of the voting systems worked well, for a first night all of the dancers were at least entertaining, and there were no politicos! I love Petra Nemcova! I’ll vote for her as long as she is there because I love her attitude and dedication to others…we should all be so kind! Unfortunately If she makes it past week 4 I’ll be surprised.
My friend is obsessed with Ralph (and he’s over 30 years older than her.. uhhhhmmm…), so you can tell that she was ecstatic when he did well. And he did! His routine was my favorite of the night. I was also pleasantly surprised by Kirstie, she can really move. Sadly, my favorite (Chris Jericho) didn’t do well tonight, but IDGAF. Kendra’s “sass” did seem a bit forced, but at some parts she was working it. She just needs to clean up a bit. I enjoyed most of the performances (terrible dancing by Wendy and Mike aside). Dude, Wendy’s boobs are HUGE. I began to wonder whether or not I was watching in 3D, they were popping out at me.
- Chelsie looked GORGEOUS tonight. O_O
- Mike is a terrible mover, but he’s hot.
- Chelsea was so light and airy in her routine.
- WERK IT Hines and Sugar Ray!
Absolutely loved Kirstie and Maks.
I can’t believe it. I vowed never to watch or root for Maks again after last season. But here I am, pulling for team G-Maks. His relationship with Kirstie has totally transformed him in my eyes. Him leaping in front of the camera tonight???? Past seasons Maks would never do that. I’m so happy that he finally seems to be enjoying himself after a few lackluster seasons.
I also was disappointed in Kendra. Here’s hoping she gets the nerves out and improves next week.
Loved Ralph and also was very surprised by his showmanship, which I think covered some awkwardness.
Enjoyed Hines very much, but actually was disappointed with “Ray.” I had hoped for more.
Has anyone noticed that Wendy is in second place on Dial Idol, ahead of Kirstie? Weird. I really seriously did not enjoy Wendy. It was at the point of me being embarrassed for her, honestly. I wonder how big her fanbase is.
Anyway, thanks Courtney! Great recap as usual.
@Robert Derek is filming a movie that is why he isnt a part of this season
@Courtney: The Fred Astair comparison to Ralph and Karina….so true. He was the biggest surprise of the night for me.
Love this season. Favorite line from Len tonight “Your hips must be allergic to music”
I thought Ralph was smashing! His movement is very entertaining and same goes for Kirstie. (I canNOT believe I’m saying that) I’m not gonna lie, I rolled my eyes when she was announced, but she has made me eat my words! I fond Mike to be quite endearing despite….disaster on the dance floor…I really hope Petra can stick around; she is such a breath of fresh air. And I want Kym to stay longer this time (which she probably will) because I adore her bombshell type of demeanor and thank the lord she didn’t get another Hoff this season
So glad the season started! I may change my assessment on a rewatch but for now –
My favorite of the night was definitely Ralph and Karina. I know a lot of people don’t “feel” Karina but I have loved so many of her routines – her choreography at times is so amazing and surprising, similar (but not as consistent as) to Derek. I hope they can deliver in the Latin, as I feel that may be less suitable for Ralph.
A close second was definitely Kirstie and Maks – she moves really well and I loved her lines for a bigger/older woman. My bf can’t get over that she’s 60. My only beef – her hair was in her face a few times and it was a bit distracting. But otherwise it was fun and she has great musicality. I like this partnership a lot.
My third is a tie between Chelsea and Hines – I thought they were both fun – which is not surprising. I thought at times Chelsea downright floated – but she could do even better, I think, with more experience. Hines and Kym’s routine was great and I was quite pleased just because I like Kym so much – she deserves a great partner. Hines is Jimmy Kimmel’s pick to win the season.
Fifth, I guess Kendra – but it was definitely a disappointment. I was really looking forward to this but her legs were AWFUL and she didn’t look like she was having fun most of the time.
Sixth – Romeo and Chelsie – but I do think he needs to let his guard down or he’s not going to last as far as his ability could take him. That approach is not going to carry him when there’s so many likable people on the show.
Chris & Cheryl – His personality did come through a decent amount, and if he could improve his posture and stick his chest out more his lines will look better. I like him and I think he could be fun to watch, but again it’s tough cause there’s a lot of great people this season.
Eighth – Sugar Ray – I know his posture was bad, but he really appealed to me and I hope he can last a little bit longer. Out of hold he looked good, maybe next week will be more his thing.
Ninth – Petra – I really hope she can last another week. She seems like a lovely person (I’ve thought that for a while, since I’ve been following her for several years) and I do hope that she has another opportunity. Dmitry does her no favors by being the dullest pro ever, although he does seem “nice”. I do fear for her though.
Tenth – Mike. Yeah I know he had the lowest scores, but at least I liked watching him better than Wendy. His humor and Lacey’s fans may help save him for a week. But it’s hard to think so – but I’d rather he stay than –
Wendy. She was my least favorite going into tonight and she remains in that spot. Ugh. It’s like a combo of Bristol and Kate. Slowwwwwwwwww, almost non-movement. I can appreciate that she has a BIG personality, but her overcompensation comes through in her packages and her deer in headlights look was not appealing. As a popular person, she may outlast a few but I don’t see her making it very far – and of all the celebs she’s the one I’ll miss the least.
Loved Kirstie tonight and ralph. Think Wendy Or Chris might be first to go home next week. Will see.
I managed to find everyone’s clip except for Wendy and I pretty much agree with the general assessment.
Ralph was outstanding and he is my #1 pick for the night. Seeing his style of dancing does raise some questions about how good he will do in the Latin.
For second I cannot choose between Kirstie and Hines. They were both great. His smile is absolutely adorable and her attitude and timing is amazing.
Third place Chelsea. I think I would like her much better if the choreography didn’t have so many funky moves which I felt were too distracting.
Fourth Kendra. I felt they were maybe a little underscored. Yes her legs were not great but apart from that they were pretty good.
I’m not scoring the bottom of the pack, just a few comments.
Romeo was such a non event for me. Chelsie looked hot though, that’s about everything I got out of their dance.
Sugar Ray has huge problems with posture and unfortunately for him his first dance was one where it is most crucial. Out of hold he was charming and fun. I hope to see them do much better.
Chris- I still don’t know what to think about him. He is not a dancer naturally and the performance was not terrible but nowhere near good.
Petra was lovely but they should try to disassociate from the boring model dancing stigma not come up with choreo that in itself is not very exciting. I had a feeling I was watching a Waltz. But she is not a bad mover, I hope she sticks around for a while.
Mike- well, that was a disaster. On a positive note his package was very funny but the dancing sucked on the Situation levels.
I didn’t catch Wendy but judging from the comments I didn’t miss much.
I liked Romeo and Chelsie the best because he has the spunk and the attitude that I like in a dancer, yes he does have to let his guard down more, I think he has the most opportunity to grow over the season of all the stars.
1. Kirstie & Maks, to me all was there, great choreography, great performance, good technique, great song (even though I’d rather have had the original “f*ck you”, funnier) and great entertainment
2. Ralph & Karina, Karina wowed me with this choreography, and Ralph did a great job, very classy, I am a little concerned for their jive nonetheless
3. Chelsea & Mark, some parts of the choreography were great and Chelsea is a great dancer but like you Courtney I thought they were too many open parts and it’s funny the choreography made you think of Derek, because it made me think of Julianne
4. Hines & Kym, the man knows how to move for sure and I think Kym is exactly the partner he needs to go further
5. Romeo & Chelsie, OK the boy has abilities but I had the same impression Len had, he is so care free ! That doesn’t appeal to me at all.
6. Petra & Dmitri, I thought she was very elegant and gracious, but I thought that the choreography was very simple too. I’m surprised that Len didn’t say anything about the jacket thing, I’d have to suppose that as long as a feather duster is not employed, wasting time is OK
. I’m afraid her jive will be a disaster.
7. Chris & Cheryl, that was a nice performance on a tricky song
8. Ray & Anna, the dance was not bad but his posture sucked. And I think fuchsia is not a good color for Anna
9. Kendra & Louis, besides the impression that there was no interaction at all between those 2 (too bad for a flirtious dance), I thought her moves were very awkward and her posture bad.
10. Mike & Lacey, the guy is not a dancer for sure but he is a hoot, and I think Lacey did a quite good choreography on a crappy song, she’s not Karina for sure but well tried !
11. Wendy & Tony, she got her nails and hair done and got a nice dress, so I suppose that dancing was not that important after all. She seems to have a big personality but I saw nothing of it, it was so timid and Tony doesn’t help of course.
Oh, the face Louis made when they got their scores was priceless. I was thinking- Brooke, watch out he’s gonna cut someone.
I was a bit surprised to see Chelsie also making a face. She has always been uber gracious and careful not to show negative emotions so it came as a surprise to me.
I feel so bad for Wendy I can’t even watch the video. She is obviously terrified out of her mind.
I agree with Courtney’s ranking completely. Loved Ralph, but I hope Karina tones it down a little when getting their scores. She’s definitely doesn’t have a humble bone in her body and it really shows next to Ralph. I know she was excited to do so well, but I hope she doesn’t ruin it for Ralph. Toatally agree about Louis and Kendra. They disappointed and you could see Louis seething after the scores. I didn’t realize he was so much of a diva!
Wasn’t able to watch last night and got home to check here but not enough comments before Courtney put post this up. This is a great post and the comments are good to read! Just wanted to say that, while searching for news online last night, I came across sites saying how the fans like the cast, but not the press (and the press needs to get excited). No Bristol or Kate. I’m wondering if Wendy will now fill that role for them. Off to watch, thanks for the head’s up!
I am hoping that Petra/Kendra are not the next Paulina/Shandi.
Two pretty girls who danced reasonably well, but got eliminated early due to the pretty girl backlash and the popularity of the other cast members.
I am scared that it’s gunna happen
I was impressed with all but two of them. My rankings would go as follows:
11) Mike and Lacey: just bad all around but his personality annoys me equally as much. Hate lacey’s hair as well.
10) Wendy and Tony: better than I though she would be BUT not good as well. She could really do better if she wasn’t so emotional/nervous.
9) Chris and Cheryl: Not bad he was a hoot but like the judges said he still has a way to go if he is going to be a conteneder. Cheryl’s biggest challenge to date.
8) Petra: Loved her. She is very graceful and has a lot of potential in my opinion.
7) Sugar Ray: Big fan and I was kinda disappointed. He is his own worst eemy it looks like. If he just lets himself go and let loose he would do better.
6) Romeo: Didn’t expect to like him. He has potential and hopefully grows during the competition. He has personality and everything but one thing I don’t like about him: he keeps bringing up his dad on the show. If this continues, people will start to look Master P up on the show and maybe hold it against him.
5) Kendra: I liked it but I expected so much more. It was fun to see Hugh Hef. in the audience though.
4) Hines and Kym: surprisngly, I liked it but he kinda remindedm e of Warren Sapp w the footwork like you said. Overall, he just mightm ake me fan f he continues to do good though.
3) Chelsea and Mark: She is a natural. Mark’s choreo was perfect and I enjoyed it. Can’t wait to see what she has in store next. Don’t think she is going to win though.
2) Kirstie: Loved It. I thought she dereved all 8s. Her footwork was great and it was a balst to watch. I split my voes between her and Ralph. I expect these two in the final for sure.
1) Ralph: While others couinted him out, I knew he would dod good. He was awesome. He could be the one to get karina her trophy. He has entertainent skills to spare and a great personailty. In my opinion, its between him and Kirstie.
So as I see it now, Mike or Wendy first to go BUT hopefully its Mike since he just annoys me more than Wendy does.
Kendra and Louis disappointed me the most out of all the 11 couples. They don’t seem to click personally. I see them butting heads this season. Wendy reminded me of Kate Gosselin with a better personality.
I loved Kirstie and Maks! They are now my choice to win the MBT! Their personalities click and her journey will be fun to watch. Hines and Ralph are great too!
Kendra and Louis disappointed me the most out of all the 11 couples. I had high expectations but they don’t seem to click personally. I see them butting heads this season. Wendy reminded me of Kate Gosselin with a better personality.
I loved Kirstie and Maks! They are now my choice to win the MBT! Their personalities click and her journey will be fun to watch. Hines and Ralph are great too!
I was looking on twitter “I #voted for…” Most of the votes are going to Hines, Chris, and Wendy.
What’s up with Tony? It looks like he has checked out and is ready to move on.
I agree with most of your assessment Courtney. I personally was thrilled to see Ralph come out and do so wonderfully. I thought he was the best of the night. Kirstie did well but I still say she is not that good. Her hair is definitely a distraction when it is in her face. I loved Chelsea and Mark’s dance-full of fun and it was my second favorite. Kendra was below my expectations and they weren’t that high to begin with. Sugar Ray had some moments I just loved him, and then others….. Chris was a disappointment-just expected more. Romeo has got to quit trying to play it cool or he is done for-didn’t care for them. Petra is a nice woman but I wasn’t impressed with the dance and I think she is going to struggle later on with anything needing hip action. Mike and Wendy were just bad. I assumed it would be one of them go first. Just a point of interest: I know dialidol is not the best gauge, but it has Sugar Ray and Romeo at the bottom. I don’t want Ray to go first so I’m really hoping its wrong.
Great feedback, guys
It was good to wake up this morning and see such good conversation about last night’s show!
One interesting thing I noticed on here and Twitter this morning: everyone is putting a lot of stock into Dial Idol and what they say. Do I need to do a post reminding everyone why Dial Idol generally doesn’t work when it comes to predicting the results of DWTS?
Neither Kendra nor Chelsea lived up to expectations in terms of their dances – which didn’t surprise me in the slightest.
Marky took some notes from Derek on his Foxtrot – all the Derek fans on Twitter immediately said that Derek helped him with that dance and then he couldn’t resist throwing a bit of spazz in it. Derek said he’d seen them dance – think maybe he did a bit more. Nothing wrong with that, except the execution was too Mark for that choreo.
Louis – suck it up, dude, and focus on your partners dancing and not just getting her to “be a stripper”. Seriously.
My favorites of the night were Hines, Kirstie and Ralph – by FAR. I believe I swore on twitter after all three dances, I was so surprised by how good they were. I do think that Hines was underscored relative to some of the other, worse couples.
Just shows how hard dancing is. There is no tougher or brutal sport than boxing and it takes extraordinary stamina, coordination, reaction time, movement sense, etc.-but dancing is hard. Ralph knows. Wax on; wax off. If the fans don’t catch with Ralph, although I think they will, the judges will “correct,” I’m sure. Yes, Karina, you have a great partner for once. Play it cool.
Meggie, Louis is a massive Diva – since Derek isn’t around and there’s no real “ringer” this season, who’s he going to blame now??
Don’t do it, Courtney, I’ll put it in with my numbers post which I’ll do later today, since there is no show tonight.
Dial Idol isn’t even predicting anything! According to their rankings, every couple could be anywhere from 1 to 11. It’s silly.
But you can get an idea this season if you check on twitter “I #voted for…”
One point about Chris is that wrestling was on when he was dancing. I don’t know what the crossover is but it hurts him when his fan base is preoccupied especially given the run up to Wrestlemania.
I agree that Derek is probalbly giving Mark some choreography behind the scenes. This could give Mark a leg up as Derek really is the best choreographer out there.
I was following the pre-season news and tidbits and I thought “wow, they don’t have an eldery contestant this year” and then I realized that the oldest one is Kirstie! What? She did so well! I loved her and Hines (I also think he was a bit underscored), Ralph, Chelsea, and Petra was so graceful – hope she stays around a bit. I did not like Wendy at all. She didn’t move! And I didn’t like Kendra, but I am not a fan of hers anyway, so maybe I’m biased.
I did like Mike. The dancing was painful and he seems pigeon-toed (like the Situation), but he’s hot and funny, and he made an effort. I hope he makes it past this week.
Once again, a great cast! Can’t wait to see what happens.
Well, after this week I doubt Mark will be getting anything from Derek other than the occassional phone call.
His movie shoots in NYC and Toronto and it should be starting soon. And no, you silly uninformed bloggers out there, he did not take the season off to spend with girlfriend Cheryl Cole. :::rolls eyes:::
Courtney, forget what I said – I took a peek at your Dial Idol post and it looks great so far. Dial Idol RARELY actually makes a prediction, if you read their results pages carefully and not just look to see who’s at the top. It’s always been ridiculous.
And no, Jennifer, you can’t get an idea from the “I voted for..” on twitter either. Many people (like me) don’t bother with it and I bet many of DWTS demo isn’t even using twitter.
Heidi, people obviously have problems with words like “FAKE NEWS” or “SPOOF” even when they are CLEARLY labeled. I bet if you made up some satire, and labeled it as such on here, and, even INSIDE the story say clearly that it’s meant as humor and is fake, and not true…. You’d find versions out there somewhere stating the same info as truth…. It’s amazing. And considering that the original story has the word “spoof” in the URL should be a clue that none of it was true….
I don’t know if I can rank 1 through 11, but I think I have them in “tiers…”
Top Tier would be Ralph, Kirstie, Hines, and Chelsie.
Middle Tier would be Chris, Kendra, Petra and Romeo.
Bottom Tier would be Ray, Mike and Wendy.
What a fun first show with a very likable cast. My favorites were Ralph, Kirstie and Hines. I also liked Chelsea, Chris and Ray. My favorite going in, Romeo, has a lot of potential and I hope he’ll continue to work hard. But I question Chelsie’s professionalism this season, as she seems to have other “interests” than working hard for and with her celebrity. I hope I’m wrong, as she’s my favorite pro.
A good start to the show. I agree with your rankings – great to see Ralph really make a great first impressions – even if he is paired with Karina….
On the Kendra thing, I think she’s got the talent, but let’s be honest, she’s not the sharpest knife in the drawer. I think what you saw tonight was nerves – hesitant, making sure she didn’t forget any of the really hard choreograpy that Louis gave her. That’s where good pros make the difference – realizing that you have to design a dance to help the STAR shine. Kendra may be good enough to do hard steps, but she’s insecure and will panic on show night – so you have to build her confidence and ease her into it. Louis is too much about him and wanting to show off what he can do, so he gave Kendra a hard routine. Bad Louis, bad…
I’m about the boys this year – Hines, Sugar Ray, Ralph – and can’t wait till next week and the next set of dances. Jive’s gonna be hard….
Also, random question – is there any correlation to those who do well and the order in which they do their dances? ie Jen started slow (Viennese waltz), then got the jive. First week is always tough, will the first week of chacha hurt those who got it versus the foxtrot. Haven’t watched enough seasons to know….
Sue, not sure I totally understand what you’re asking, but I will try to take a stab at it… I’ve been watching regularly since Season 3, and did watch PARTS of Season 2, I do remember Master P.
I don’t think it really matters who gets what the first week, in regards to how they place. They always have half do a ballroom dance (foxtrot this year) and half do a latin dance (cha cha this year). I think that most of the time, it is foxtrot and cha cha, but they do switch it up with one of the waltz some seasons. I don’t think that having a cha cha this week will necessarily hurt any of the contestants this season, any more than having the foxtrot will hurt any of the contestants. Next week, they switch… Those who did the cha cha will do the quickstep, and those that did the foxtrot will do the jive…
And now that I typed all of that, I don’t think I answered your question at all, but I’ll leave it, and let someone who knows about dance answer better…
Wow! What a great show last night. When I saw Jennifer, it sure made me miss Derek. Anyways, I agree with your rankings Courtney. I have to say my favorites are sure going to be Ralph, Kirstie, Hines, and then Cheslea. I was impressed by all four of them. Hoping Ralph and Kirstie can keep it up after such a great first impression on the dance floor. I was actually expecting more from Kendra/Louis and was a little disappointed.
I don’t particularly care for Kendra but I think people are being hard on her. She did a decent job with a difficult choreography. It seems she had a reason to be nervous because the expectations really were present which I can see only now when so many are saying she disappointed. I didn’t think she was going to be Jennifer Gray and she wasn’t. That’s fine with me.
I agree that Louis should ease up on the steps and also on the sexy. It could make her more comfortable.
First, thanks Courtney for the excellent power rankings, and thanks to all for the great comments and discussion. I love that people actually discuss the performances in an informed way here as opposed to the abc mb which is a rude, obnoxious train wreck.
My thoughts for what they’re worth.
* Kendra completely underwhelmed me. In her defense, I think she was just about as scared as Wendy. Apparently performing in front of a live audience is a problem. To make matters worse, she and Louis might be well-matched physically, but there’s absolutely no point of connection between them as people. My guess is when he doesn’t like his partner, all his less pleasant personality traits are gonna come out. I think we’re going to see that, and kinda fell sorry for Kendra. She didn’t dance up to his expectations on Monday and he showed his displeasure.
* Romeo frustrated me. Wanted to shake him! The guy has potential, but he if he can’t/won’t abandon the macho persona, he needs to be gone IMO. His free spirit is charming but it doesn’t cut any mustard with me if he won’t do cha-cha-cha moves when he’s dancing a Cha-cha-cha. He needs to show me some more maturity and commitment to the dance next week.
* Wendy was appalling and disappointing. @Jennifer – my guess is Tony has checked out b/c he thought he was getting a fun, confident partner and instead he got another watering pot! I hope Wendy has an epiphany this week, embraces the whole learning experience, and starts to enjoy herself. She could be such fun.
* Mike is definitely a hot mess, and also scared stiff (almost literally). His quirky humor appeals to me at times, but he needs to use it sparingly. Lacey needs to stop talking about seeing all his body parts (a definite case of oversharing) and get a new stylist (the hair is gawdawful). Don’t think they’ll be around very long.
* Petra was less stiff and awkward than I thought she’d be but still rather week. She’s such a sweet spirit, that I’d like to see her stick around and improve. My questions are (a) will her pelvis hold up under the strain and will she even have the range of motion she needs for some of the Latin dances and (b) will Dmitry develop some sparkle to his personality so they don’t fade into the wallpaper? They’re just not memborable.
* Sugar Ray is a delightful gentleman. It was unfortunate he got Foxtrot. I think Cha-cha-cha would have showcased his strengths. My biggest worry for him is that he won’t be able to pick up the choreography quickly enough week-to-week, and then he won’t be able to relax and perform on Monday.
* Chris needs to dance again before I decide about him. He looked big and bold and endearingly cloddish. Love his personality and whole-hearted commitment to enjoying the DWTS experience.
* Loved Chelsea, Hines, Ralph, and Kirstie! They were all a joy to watch, each in their own way. Chelsea and Hines need to smooth out and polish up, but the potential is there. I feel they’re well on their way to doing a marvelous job. Look forward to seeing their growth week to week. I couldn’t stop beaming after Ralph/Karina finished their Foxtrot. Hopefully his modesty will counteract some of Karina’s over-exuberant self-congratulation. Can he do Latin? I wouldn’t put it past him. Come on Ralph, show us some hip action. Kirstie and Maks are a revelation. I thought they’d bring out the worst in each other. Instead, it seems the opposite has happened. Sure hope that continues because I loved Kirstie’s neat feet in the Cha-cha-cha, heir connection during the dance. Kirstie showed she’s one hot chunky grandma. Now can she be elegant in ballroom or will she look slow and wobbly? Hmmm. My biggest concern for both Ralph and Kirstie is will their stamina hold up and their bodies hold together as the season progresses.
Does anyone know the dances for next week?
Yeah, I’d be interested to know what’s up for week 2 dances re the first elimination. I finally watched the show and Kirstie and Ralph were my favs (had to literally fast forward through Wendy – I felt bad for her). I get the impression that Ralph understands pacing himself but wonder if Kirstie does. I’d hate to see her get injured. I know she’s funny and quirky (in spite of scientology) but she IS 60 and seriously overweight. I hope she paces herself.
Jay that’s a good point. I can easily see Kirstie not pacing herself. The way she was breathing yesterday, even in the celebriquarium (or whatever the heck it’s called), had me worried. I hope her body can match up to her mind.
As someone above said, next week is Jive and Quickstep.
Katy: From what I see next weeks dances are Jive and Quickstep
My favs from last night were Ralph and Kristie! Hope they can remain this good in the following weeks. Great power rankings. It would be nice to see someone win from the famous 80′s era!
Love the quickstep when it is done right. Can’t wait.
Does anyone know if those were Kirstie’s kids; the two cute blondes that they showed after her dance? Hoe she goes far as that will give hope to us “older” women everywhere.
next week is the Jive and the Quick Step – both pretty challenging dances for week 2. Getting the Jive this early in the competition may be an advantage to some – get that tough dance out of the way while there are still “bad” dancers in the mix who will likely be voted off first. I think this was the case with Jennifer last season. Her Jive was good, no denying, but probably a good thing that it came early in the season for her rather than later.
I’m afraid Wendy will not be able to master the quick step, although she’ll be in hold for most of the dance, and that may help. I think.
Petra will have the Jive, which will be a real challenge for her. She desperately needs Dmitry to sparkle, though, and I don’t know he’s got that in him. She’s not going to be able to shine on her own in this arena without him leading the way. They need to pop out of the wallpaper.
The Jive will give Sugar Ray an opportunity to WOW us. I think he’ll do well with this one. Despite his age, I think he’s got the energy and stamina for it.
Hines’ Quick Step will stomp the house! I love this team. You can tell just from this first dance that he’s going to be good at all of it and may garner the first 10 of the season.
Those are the ones I know for sure. I do think it’s only those 2 dances next week so I’m assuming everyone who did the ChaChaCha this week will Quickstep next week and all those with the FoxTrot this week will Jive in the next.
On a side note – I really do think the judges scores were pretty much right on right on. I would have probably given Hines a point more, Chris possibly a point less, but all in all I concur with the Judges’ verdict.
I watched the episode again and a lot of things were reaffirmed – Ralph and Karina were a joy to watch and I really hope they make it far. He was my favorite since the announcement and I was so scared for him that I almost voted last night. Almost.
But one thing that caught my attention was Mike. I think he may have been underscored just a little bit. Yes it was weird and bad, but I think he was still better than the Hoff, who got a 15 last season. Maybe it’s just that this season the scoring seems to be more reasonable as a whole, I dunno. I think he tried really hard but I don’t think his funny will be appealing enough to carry him far without serious mega improvement next week.
Scared for Petra and the Jive. Might be her undoing, which is unfortunate. Would rather have seen her ChaCha and then Quickstep – but it was not meant to be I guess.
And seriously, does Maks camera block to show his butt at just the opportune time?
Would anyone be surprised if Maks did camera block for The Butt? I mean, it’s a good butt and all so I don’t really mind but you just know Maks has a name for it.
I would have given Hines and Kendra 1 point more, Chris and Romeo 1 point less. That 7 was completely hormonal. But it’s all very minor tweaks so no complaints.
I hope I don’t go on post overdrive every week like I did today, compensating for not being able to watch the show live.
Chelsea Kane’s DWTS blog: http://www.people.com/people/article/0,,20474791,00.html
I can’t believe that you would even suggest that Mark is getting choreography from Derek. Mark is one of the best choreographers on the show. When Mark had Kristi or Shawn, he did similiar things with them. I think Mark and Chelsea did a wonderful job last night and can’t wait for their jive next week.
Kirsti and Ralph were also wonderful last night. I can see them going a long way.
Bottom of the list is Mike and Wendy. I think Wendy has a big fan base so she may stick around. Romeo needs to improve or he won’t be around much longer.
I don’t like jive in week 2 at all. Secondly, Chelsea better be ready for some really cheesy wardrobe cuz that Marks thing w jives lol. Thirdly, Raph w jive should be cool and Kirtie w quickstep is going to be interestibg. We know she can do latin well but gets winded but we don’t know about the ballroom dances yet. If she does equally as good as she did this week she could win it all. Lastly, I was wondering if anybody else thought that Mike looked like Joe Rogan from Fear Factor. When I saw him that was my frist though lol.
It makes me wonder how Chelsea will fair in Jive or in the latin round in general since she said in a comment about not having hips and all. So I wanting to see how Ralph and Chelsea will fair in the latin round.They both if you think about are skinny and don’t seem to have hips and all and no wonder started off with foxtrot. Wonder what Maks has up his sleeve for Kristie and his Quickstep?Should be interesting next week with the dances to seem who can dance what better in latin or ballroom.Great blog site you all here.
Both Kendra and Romeo were a bit of a disappointment, but I do can see them both improving, as long as they’re able to stick around a little while.
Petra is lovely, but unfortunately not a dancer. Her foxtrot did make me smile though, just because she looked like she was having such a great time.
I think Chelsea could be really good. I wonder why Mark chose to go with a routine with very little actual foxtrot content. I understand why he did that with Bristol, but Chelsea’s better than that.
“I wonder why Mark chose to go with a routine with very little actual foxtrot content. I understand why he did that with Bristol, but Chelsea’s better than that.”
Maybe her not liking the foxtrot as a dance had something to do with it. She said she thought it was boring (in nicer words) and she’s happy they made their choreography fun and different.
Lori and Sue – I think Lori had it mostly right but there are exceptions (of course, it’s DWTS!). For example, I remember when Joanna was dancing with Derek she did like 4 latin dances in a row – I think starting in Week 1 – and Derek’s fans (and Derek) were starting to worry that she would look too one-dimensional.
@ Kelsey and sasa, I also wondered about the lack of Foxtrot content in Chelsea and Mark’s Foxtroxt and was waiting for Len to get all over Mark for it. Maybe he really was in a forgiving mood, but Mark can’t depend on that lasting for long. On a similar note, I was amazed Carrie Ann gave Petra and Dmitry a buy on the lift. I winced when I saw both Petra’s feet off the floor.
There will be polka dots, Vin. Lots and lots of polka dots. And he’ll be wearing short pants with white socks OR funny horn rimmed glasses. Only question – big polka dots or little ones? Anyone wanna bet??
Len also gave Dmitry a pass on the time wasting move at the beginning and end of their dance – he’s gotten on Maks for the same thing. He’ll be back to Mr. Crankypants next week I’m sure.
LOL to the polka dots. EEK to the cheesy wardrobe Mark is known for. I’d never want him as a partner.
@Princess Heidi and @Lori, thanks for your feedback.
I wiki’d (is that a word?) and 7 of the 11 winners started with standard (ie v. waltz, waltz, foxtrot) in week one, then moved to latin (jive, rumba, salsa – and a mambo, is that considered latin?), including the last four winners. Not sure if it makes a difference, maybe the selection is not random, but those dances might be a bit more ‘forgiving’ as a first dance.
gotta love the internet. Love love love this site – so entertaining AND insightful – I like learning things….
Ow, I can’t believe that season 12 has already started. First of all let me say that I’m back. It’s been a while since I show up here or leave my comments, but I was always taking a look here on the site, after all, if it was not for you I guess I never had the chance to have some DWTS information here in Brazil. I’ll try to make my comments during the season, I hope I can show up a lot here.
I must say that this season I still do not have a favorite (especially since Derek is not on, LOL) but I think during the show I will pick someone. I’ll try to be brief in my comments, because in the first week is still a bit difficult to analyze everyone well. And since I’m from Brazil, sometimes it’s difficult to know the popularity of everyone.
So, let’s go to my power rankings:
1.Ralph & Karina: What a nice surprise! This was one of the couples that really surprises me. Just loved everything from beginning to end. Ralph showed that knows how to move very well. His steps were clean, light and quite accurate. I also love the combination of Ralph with Karina, they make a cute couple. I have the impression that they are going far in the competition and the popularity of Ralph will grow during the show. I’m a little afraid of Ralph did not go so well in the Latin dances, but I hope I’m wrong. I think I’m finding my favorites…
2.Hines & Kym: Another great surprise. I confess I did not expect that Hines was so good (I could not watch the rehearsals), so it surprised me a lot. I loved the choreography and I think Hines and Kym will make a great couple, especially since Kym has experience with football players. I also see them going far in the competition. Hines moves very well, has pace, he executed his moves well and best of all, he enjoyed his presentation from beginning to end. His presentation was clean and I really enjoyed it. And the guy really knows how to move his hips. I would give one or two points higher, partly because he was very good, especially if we consider that it was Latin dance for him. And if he managed to do well in Latin dance, I think he can do well at ballroom dancing.
3.Kirstie & Maks: Another surprise of the night. These two have brought joy, fun and entertainment with their dance. Kristie has performed very well her movements. It was a clean performance, correct and cheerful. She’s still some things to improve you, but I think this will not be a problem. What a nice pair, they seem to understand each other perfectly. I see them going far in the competition and I think Kristie’s popularity will only increase. I have to say I found Maks very nice last night, or at least he controlled his temper and his arrogance really well.
4.Chelsea & Mar: If the other couples were a surprise, I admit that these two disappointed me a little. I expected more of this couple. I do not think they are bad, on the contrary, I think Chelsie has great potential, but Mark needs to get back to the old days and teach as he did before. It was a beautiful choreography, but it was not clean. Chelsea has beautiful movements, but she needs to refine them. And please, Mark needs to control his energy, everything seemed faster than it really was. After all it was a beautiful dance and I think these two will go far in the competition. And yes, I agree with many of you, the choreography seemed to have been made by Derek, except that every moment we expected one of the follies of Mark to ruin everything. Ow, how I miss Derek … I think he and Chelsea would make a beautiful couple.
5.Ray & Anna: I think I can say that Ray surprised me a little. He looked so serious, that I started to think that everything would be a disaster. But when it all began, he seemed to have so much fun and enjoy your presentation. He still has a lot to improve, but for the first presentation I think it went well. I’m a little worried about how it will come out in Latin rhythms, but I think Anna will know how to handle the situation.
6.Chris & Cheryl: I liked the presentation of them. I think the music did not help much, but overall it was a good presentation. Looking at the package I thought it would be a disaster, but they managed to take everything to the end. And I think Chris was very good, especially if we consider that it was Latin dance for him. He needs to improve his posture and refine their movements. I hope he stays for a while. I want to see how he can improve. One note: I have the impression that Cheryl is going the same way that some professionals in the program, she is becoming repetitive. Her choreographies is always the same, are not bad, but not excited.
7.Romeo & Chelsie: Romeo has done better than I expected. He still has a lot to improve but he is much better than his father. He needs to drop over and let the dance flow. He is far from being the best, but I think he can grow a lot over the competition. I agree with Courtney, perhaps Chelsie has spent much time with Mark, because she took the habit of dancing around their partners to hide their defects. I love Chelsie but she needs to stop this thing.
8.Petra & Dmitry:It was a beautiful dance, but without much emotion. The surprise about Petra is that she is not as clumsy as the models used to be. I think she was not too bad. She managed to bring the choreography to the end without looking too uncomfortable. I think she can still grow a lot. I liked seeing the enthusiasm with which Dmitry returned to the show, it really seems to be enjoying it. I’m worried about how to Petra will be out in the Latin dances, especially the jive next week. Unfortunately I do not see her doing so well and taking into account that she hasn’t a large fan base, this can be a problem.
9.Kendra & Louis: I do not know what to say about these two. I have not seen anything impressive in them. Maybe Kendra surprise me a little bit for not being as bad as I thought she would be. But I swear I can not stand Louis anymore. Doesn’t he realize that all the nonsense he talks eventually affects his partner?? Kendra was actually better than I expected, but maybe the choreography has not helped much. I just can not see her doing very well in ballroom dancing. Maybe I’m biased here because I can not stand Louis, but I do not see this couple going too far.
10.Mike & Lacey: I have to admit that I did not find Mike so bad. Not that he has been good, far from it, but I think the show had participants who were worse. He has a lot to improve, mainly because he hasn’t a high popularity. I also think that the song did not help much and I found the Lacey’s choreography a bad imitation of Karina and The Situation’s Foxtrot in last season. I would love to see him for a few more weeks, but with the jive next week it might be difficult.
11.Wendy & Tony: I think I have nothing to add to what Courtney said.
If there was elimination this week, I wish Wendy and Tony were eliminated them, butnevertheless I think that maybe, Mike and Lacey would be eliminated.
I’m staying here. I try to make my comments earlier next week.
Kisses and hugs from Brazil.
Great first show! Kirstie’s personality, and hers, Ralph’s and Hines’ dances almost (almost) made Derek’s absence less noticeable. Is Max not ca-yute with Kirstie? So laid back, and I’m loving his sense of humor.
As someone in my mid thirties, I’m kind of loving that the ‘old folks’ are setting the bar high this season.
Lastly, am I alone in not feeling this supposed ‘cockiness’ or ‘supreme confidence’ of Karina’s? I know she had Mario many seasons ago, but she has been stuck with a bunch of stinker partners (as far as dance ability), if memory serves me correctly–I think she (and Chelsie) is due a strong partner (I say that to say I’m not sure when she’s had much opportunity to appear cocky). I feel she’s one of the stronger dancers/choreographers on the show, and seems to teach well, too. She smiles really big when things go well, but also appears to do that when she is uncomfortable or unsure of what to say…
Wendy
“I can’t believe that you would even suggest that Mark is getting choreography from Derek. Mark is one of the best choreographers on the show. When Mark had Kristi or Shawn, he did similiar things with them. I think Mark and Chelsea did a wonderful job last night and can’t wait for their jive next week.”
Barb, thank you. I cheered inside when I read this. Mark is a wonderful choreographer who is not afraid to take risks, even if they don’t turn out to be a hit. Even if Mark is far from your cup of tea, to say (as an insult to Mark) that he has to have Derek help with his choreography is disrespectful to Mark’s success on the show.
EVERY pro does better and more intricate choreography when they have a celebrity who has some natural dance ability. While Mark is my favorite pro, some of my favorite dances ever were done by Karina with Mario L. (not so much with Billy Ray or Steve Wozniak), Dmitri with Mya (as opposed to Holly Madison), Lacey with Kyle (as opposed to Steve O), and so forth.
I vow never to say anything negative about Derek, but he has gotten the reputation in a lot of fans’ minds that he is perhaps the best choreographer on the show mainly because he was given 7 seasons of opportunity to showcase it. Good for him, and I enjoy his dances very much, but I don’t think it’s fair to knock the other pros’ choreography skills just because they are not given the chance to reach full potential due to the celeb partners given.
Wendy – Karina also had Aaron Carter, so she did have at least one other partner with potential. I actually *loved* some of their dances and their Muppet quickstep remains as one of my favorite dances ever, not to mention their fantastic jive. He was really good, but unfortunately his meltdown really turned off the audience. I am glad she has Ralph, as I think she has the ability and creativity to really amaze with her choreography. I wasn’t always a Karina fan but she’s really grown on me, whereas my appreciation for Cheryl has waned a bit. As a few people have mentioned recently, I feel like I know what I’m going to see out of Cheryl now and I don’t really look forward to her routines any longer. Of course they aren’t bad – but I do get a bit bored by them. She has choreographed a few of my absolute favorites, so I haven’t totally given up on her abilities (and it doesn’t seem so much as ability but rather her investment in the show – she seems to be a little bit checked out last few seasons).
I’m with you, Wendy – I had NO problem with anything Karina did when they got their scores. Why on earth WOULDN’T she be happy?? It was the high score of the night and anyone would have been jumping around and happy. Nearly all the men do it from time to time, so I can’t take issue with what she does.
Al, no one ever said that he HAD to have Derek’s help, only that he probably did get some ideas from him – specifically Derek’s foxtrot with Nicole. Mark’s fans made it into “Derek choreographed Mark’s dance” when that’s not what was said. Marky’s fans are making this into some huge deal – where everything less than glowing is an insult. It’s not the insult that you want to make it into. And guess what, they have BOTH freely admitted that they’ve gotten ideas from each other – best to get over this idea that all the choreography on the show is purely by that pro. Even Derek said he got an idea from something he and Mark were talking about for a freestyle – don’t think it ever got used, since he didn’t make the finals that season.
And I have news for you – it has nothing to do with “potential” – I didn’t like his choreography with Sabrina at all and she is certainly one of the more talented dancers to have been on the show. Derek hasn’t had more potential than Mark – far from it. That’s a fallacy that fans of OTHER pros like to spread to make themselves feel better about Derek doing so well. Try looking at the facts instead of buying into your own “conventional wisdom”. Many people believe Derek is the best choreographer on the show probably because he can make a stiff model dance well enough to get to the semi-finals and someone fresh out of PRISON (and a foot shorter than him) make it to 5th place. Then there’s the woman who’s 50 years old with screws in her neck and the 35 year old married mommy with terrible stage fright. Oh, and let’s not forget his ex-girlfriend who had no hips. It’s people like you who continually do a disservice to Derek by claiming that’s he’s always given good partners and that’s why he’s a good choreographer – it’s bull, and actually far more insulting than anything I say about Mark.
I must say I was not expecting to enjoy the show as much as I did. Ralph, Kirstie & Hines wowed me in that order. I loved how the packages showed them just working their butts off to nail it. And that they did.
I think Kendra, Petra, Romeo & Chelsea could be real contenders and push out of the middle of the pack with the kind hard work that are pushing my top three to awesome performances like we saw on Monday. They really need to step it up. I think Ray could fall into this group as well.
For Mike, Wendy & Chris they are putting in a good effort, but in my opinion, dancers they are not and probably never will be. But hey, this is DWTS and you just never know!
Once again, thank goodness for this site. I spend more time here than actually watching the show! The comments about Mark’s costumes are hilarious. Is he channeling Gene Kelly – thinking about that first scene in the big dance number from Singing in the Rain…geeky glasses, socks and saddles, loud tie and coat…
Ya know, Jay, I didn’t make the Gene Kelly connection and I just recently saw that movie on Showtime or some such. I think you might have it.
Now, if only you could explain the polka dots. In going back and watching the seasons again in order, I though maybe he stepped away from it with one of Kristie’s jives, but then I noticed the tiny polka dots in her hair bow.
Re: Karina: Yes, the men do do it from time to time (jump around and go crazy after a good score), and we all know what some have said about Maks when he has done it in the past: He’s cocky when he’s on top and he’s a poor sport in his actions when he disagrees with the score. I think Karina tends to wear her heart on her sleeve in the same way. I agree that Karina is a brilliant choreographer and dancer, but I hope her personality won’t turn people off from voting for Ralph. His modesty just accentuates Karina’s over exuberance. In past seasons she has been very pouty when she got a score she didn’t agree with. Maybe she’s changed and we’ll see the “good sport” Karina from now on when the score doesn’t suit her. Maybe she’ll be more gracious like Anna or Kym or Cheryl would be. I hope so for Ralph’s sake! Admittedly, she seemed better last year with The Situation, but then she probably couldn’t argue too much with his scores.
Princess Heidi: I don’t know if this link will work. It’s to a photo of Gene Kelly in a polka dot tie http://www.icollector.com/Gene-Kelly_i10393010 or on youtube with Rita Hayworth in a similar tie http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T3KPlGQNrVc. Anyhew, I think it’s a psychic connection thing…or not.
As for Karina showing excitement versus a gracious Anna…I remember Anna with Evan jumping up and down and up again after a 10 and even he backed off her while she did her endzone routine. Maybe the pros just can’t help it when their best hopes get realized, IMO.
I meant Anna is always gracious when the scores are not to her liking!
I like it when they jump up and down. And while I adore Anna she has been known to roll her eyes on occasion. I don’t mind it when she does it because she generally doesn’t have her guard up quite as much as some other ladies. When Chelsie made a face on Monday it actually bothered me a bit because she is always careful to be mega smiley and friendly. I think Kym and Cheryl are the most mature when it comes to taking criticism.
I wonder if it’s possible to make an exception this season and have Hines only do Latin dances. Just rotate through Cha Cha Cha, Samba, Mambo, etc.
If only…
Good to see that Ralph remembers some of his martial arts, I think that may be where his center of balance (the best of the night) comes from. As for him struggling with the Jive? I dunno, I remember that clip of him doing Swing in KK2 that you posted a while back – if he rmembers the feel of that he’ll be fine. Only thing about him that I feel skeptical about is the wig….
Also loved Kirstie. In general the oldest stars had the best performances this time around, an interesting development.
LOL it’s not a wig, that’s his hair. He even tweeted a picture in response to a joke about it http://yfrog.com/h311onzj