DWTS13 Week 6 Power Rankings
Wish I could say I had a blast watching the show tonight, but unfortunately, I found myself counting down the minutes until it was over 🙁 With the exception of a few bright spots, I was left with an overall feeling of “meh” tonight, and there were a few cringeworthy moments. But I will say this: I commend all of the stars tonight for actually looking like they had FUN 🙂 Seriously, it seemed like every single one of them enjoyed themselves out on the floor, even if things weren’t so rosy off the floor.
Thoughts on the group dance: First off, a shout-out to Amanda, a fellow Blockhead who reminded me that Kevin Maher, the guy who choreographed the group routine, has also worked with NKOTB, namely choreographing their video to “Single”. Instant points in my book 🙂 Anywho! I think I enjoyed this dance more than any of the other group dances in the past, for the simple reason that it felt more theatrical and also less-obviously structured – the ones in the past have always driven me nuts with the whole “Ok we’re dancing as a group, in unison – now here’s this couple doing a solo bit, and then this couple, now this couple, etc etc etc”. Nancy stood out for me – loved that she seemed to be having a ball. But really – how could any dance go wrong with Carson as the creative director? 😉
1.) TIE: Ricki & Derek and JR & Karina – Obviously they’re tied in terms of score, but there were specific things I enjoyed about each performance. I thought Ricki & Derek’s was a bit cleaner and better-executed, but I thought JR & Karina had the more eye-catching, theatrical choreography. Loved Ricki’s fearlessness in just attacking the dance head-on; loved JR’s fun-loving, energetic attitude. I really love both of these couples, and I’d be fine with either winning…although I’d be lying if I said I wasn’t pulling for JR a bit 😉 I think it would take some pretty eye-popping voting going on by fans of the other couples to topple either one of these couples this week, but Martinoff & Drickilous fans beware: the judges could try to pull the ol’ storyboarding act in the weeks to come in order to keep things “interesting”, and it could be to the detriment of one of them. Keep voting!!!!
3.) Nancy & Tristan – FINALLY! We get a routine out of these two that’s equal parts meat-and-potatoes choreo and carefree fun 🙂 Definitely the cutest, most upbeat routine of the night – and Heidi got her Spamalot! wish! 😀 It was the most relaxed and uninhibited I’ve seen Nancy, and I loved it. Loved the little hop-steps Tristan threw in – a nice, very Monty Python touch. I’m glad these two were finally able to get out of the funk they’ve been in the past few weeks. I’m thinking they’re probably going to be safe, given that they’ve had a breakthrough week and got a comparatively good score.
4.) David & Kym – First off, I’m soooo glad Kym opted to go the “hand jive at the dance” route with their theme, rather than the iconic, done-to-death Sandy-in-tight-leather-and-Danny-in-a-black-tee route! That was my big worry – another cliched Grease routine. But I love the understated look they both had – although I have to wonder if it kind of subdued David a bit this week. Not sure if he was just super-focused on the dance, or is getting more comfortable, or what, but he almost seemed a bit sedate during their dance this week. I’m gonna assume he was just very focused on the steps, because he actually managed to keep his topline level and his footwork decently clean. I guess I just wouldn’t have minded a bit more of the “flare” we’ve gotten accustomed to from David 😉 But overall, I’m really growing to like David these days, and I’m definitely pulling for him to get the 3rd spot in the finale now. His dancing is improving and his personality is kinda growing on me. Hopefully America agrees, because he makes me giggle 😉
5.) Hope & Maks – A part of me almost wishes these two would go home tomorrow night, because each successive week seems to take a bigger and bigger toll on both of them emotionally. It wasn’t the dance itself that was hard for me to watch – Hope actually seemed to let go and show some vulnerability, although I HATE when the girls don’t wear heels to do Latin in! – it was their rehearsal package and the subsequent verbal spat Maks & Len had that made me squirm and just kinda feel…sad. Which is strange, because it’s not my typical go-to emotion…but I guess Maks’ very vocal frustration with the show is just driving the point home for me that he likely won’t be around next season (and Derek likely won’t, either), and it’s kind of the ending of an era on the show. But that’s neither here nor there – I was actually pleasantly surprised by Hope’s rumba, not for the technique (lord knows there was no hip action there), but just the fact that she finally seemed to relax a bit. Just wish that Maks hadn’t taken the bait and engaged in a proverbial chest-beating contest with Len, to Hope’s possible detriment. That’s where I’m really a bit torn tonight – I would say that 2nd to last with only a point separating them from the bottom is a very dangerous place to be, given that the guy in the bottom has proven to be the Little Engine that Could Get The Votes to Stay for several weeks now. But at the same time, for as many folks as I saw on Twitter that were disgusted with Maks’ behavior, there seemed to be just as many who were behind him 100% and praised his honesty. Granted, what I saw was a very narrow cross-section of the viewing audience, but it does make me wonder: how will the average viewer take it? Will his rant be a deal-breaker? I’m honestly not sure…but I do think that these two should not be surprised if they end up “in jeopardy” again tomorrow night, for nothing more than to scare their fans into voting harder.
6.) Rob & Cheryl – I actually think Rob did pretty well tonight, and his cha-cha was cute – he smiled, he moved, and he looked like he had fun, although I daresay he’s still a bit too timid for being this far along in the competition. But I think he is improving 🙂 The question is: is he getting the votes to stick around and improve some more? I can’t say for sure without looking at the previous scores this season, but I don’t think Rob’s ever been this close to the bottom with people with arguably bigger fanbases than he has. Seems like he’s been a bit shielded the past few weeks, thanks to Carrie Ann’s va-jay-jay. 😉 But I’m gonna venture a guess that he might just have enough of a margin over both Hope & Chaz to stay safe, even if he’s not getting a slew of votes. The bigger problem will be in the coming weeks – he needs to make a splash, because he’s running the risk of getting lost in a sea of much bigger personalities. And the only person that seemed to be struggling with the same thing (Nancy), has suddenly had a bit of a breakthrough. Wake up, Rob – time to summon your inner Carson, if you wanna stick around!
7.) Chaz & Lacey – Well, unfortunately for Chaz, I think the judges probably dealt a death blow with their scores this week – not that they weren’t deserved, because Chaz didn’t really seem to do a whole lot in his tango, although I did enjoy some of the theatricality of it. I’m afraid Chaz has gotten by the past few weeks on the fact that he’s the underdog, and has been improving just enough that people feel the need to vote. But is it enough for yet another week? I really don’t think so, especially since the only other person close to his skill level (Nancy again) has suddenly improved by quite a bit. If they had scored the group dance, I might have given him a fighting chance, as it would have decreased the margin a bit; but I don’t think Chaz can compete with angry Hope fans power voting, or the higher scores of anyone else. But smile and hold your head high as you walk out, Chaz – yours has been quite the amazing and inspiring journey to watch 😉
So how did you guys feel about Broadway week? Who were your stand-outs and your duds? And if there is indeed an encore (seems like they’ve been jam-packing the results shows with all sorts of other stuff the past few weeks…), are you as gung ho as I am about seeing Nancy & Tristan dance again? 😉
Maks shouldve know the moment Len seen Hope in boots he was gonna hate it (remember the barefoot rumba with Lance and Lacey that was good but Len hated). I was surprised with Nancy and how much better she’s getting. I don’t think Hope is the worst but after tonight I just wish they’d put her out of her misery. This redemption arc they’ve been pushing the last three weeks isn’t happening nor does it look it will anytime soon. I also think what happened pretty much shows that this is Maks last season. This is my only rant on Hope and Maks this week, I swear. Overall this night was a big letdown I was hoping for more.
I looked the group routine too. Courtney, Kevin also choreographed the NKOTB reunion tour. You can also see in that number Derek’s theatre background. He was excellent. I loved all of the quicksteps. No way JR will lose. He is going to win. I thought Ricki danced this quickstep better than her tango. Loved the choreo from Derek and Karina tonight.
Like you, Courtney, I found the show to be a bit of a bore! Until all the yelling and screaming woke me up! LOL Loved JR and Karina’s Quickstep 🙂
Really enjoyed Nancy & Tristan. Glad to see her having fun and improving. She seems to give 150% to learning even if she does argue with Tristan. R & D and JR & K were great as expected.
Derek and Ricki – Wow, this dance was pure perfection at it’s finest. Fast, entertaining. Once again, Derek’s choreography was out of this world. Ricki wants to do Broadway? Hire her, people! She can do it with the best of them. Then there is Derek. *sigh* A TOTAL BLOW AWAY PERFORMANCE and one of the best ever on DWTS! 10+++++
JR and Karina – And what a dazzling performance this dance was!! It was smooth, entertaining, fun, and elegant!! It probably didn’t quite blow me away in the way like Ricki and Derek’s dance did, but, it was still outstanding!! 10
Nancy and Tristan – What a cute dance from Nancy and Tristan! I loved how Nancy seemed more relaxed and just having fun tonight. She might have been a little stiff in her knee kicks(I wish she’d get them higher with Tristan’s), but, overall, very very nice. Her best dance yet. Light, fun, clever, and entertaining. 8 I really have to give it to Nancy for her group performance as well. I couldn’t take my eyes off her her. GOOD JOB NANCY FOR DOING A HAND STAND LIKE THAT AT 50 YEARS OLD! I’m starting to wonder if these two can make it in the Top 3 now too? 😯
David and Kym – Kym was right. The quickstep was David’s dance. What a totally fun, high energy, and entertaining performance. They made have been out of a sync a little and messy at times, but, it wasn’t a big deal. I liked it. 8-
Hope and Maks – D*MN, I was really hoping for a better and tighter performance tonight from these two. I felt the “athletic-ness” in her more than ever. I didn’t like all the running in it. I usually love Maks’ rumbas, but, this wasn’t as good as all his others. I don’t know…maybe I was turned off of their costumes? I was wishing she wore her group costume for the Rumba.:) 7+ As for Maks, even though I thought he’d never stop going on and the more he did, the more he hurts Hope, I was glad when he told Len and the judges off mainly because I was steamin’ after Bruno calling Chaz a “penguin”. What the ?? That was going way too far!! If I was a celebrity, I would never do the show for these reasons. Go ahead and critique, but, don’t humiliate any of them especially when they are giving all they’ve got week after week. The more and more I witness these judges, the more I want a new set. Enough is enough.
Chaz and Lacey – I didn’t think Chaz was as bad as the judges went on about. In fact, the choreography and the acting he did was more complicated than Rob’s. I especially loved his footwork and the intense ending. Once again, shame on Bruno for going too far saying he looked like a penguin. So totally un-necessary. 👿 7
Rob and Cheryl – I loved how Rob seems more relaxed than ever dancing. He’s really settling into the entertainer mode (“Charisma” like Carrie Anne described?). However, I thought he was slow and Cheryl over danced him a lot. I didn’t like their dance as much as last week. He really didn’t do anything spectacular or mind blowing tonight either. In fact, he just walked around and flung his arms around. The choreography really lacked. They took the easy route unlike the other couples. 6
The end and I can’t wait to read everyone’s reviews!!
Courtney, great review. I’m with you….bring back Tristan and Nancy for an encore!!
Like you, I’m fearing more than ever now Maks won’t be back next season which will make me sad.
“Cheryl over danced him a lot.” I agree. As someone said, it is what it is. Just not that many excellent dancers this series, we lost Chynna and Kristin early, but everyone is trying hard. Nancy Grace-wonderful-doesn’t carry one bit of her “day” job over to this program. Smart move. I thought costume and make-up were excellent-Kym and Cheryl-ADORABLE. Hope just didn’t jell for this show. Contrast to Natalie Coughlin, who became a good dancer and started to understand what the show is about, letting her personality and some charm out. I think Kym can pull David A to #3 (unusual fellow, to say the least), but a final of JR, Ricki and Nancy would be fine. The judges seemed to be letting Chaz and Rob down for possible elimination.
1) Ricki & Derek / J.R. & Karina: I’m with you one this one Courtney. I can’t rate one above the other. If these two couples aren’t in the final something is VERY wrong in this world.
2) Nancy & Tristan: Best dance for Nancy so far and I loved the Spamalot music 🙂
3) Hope & Maks: I didn’t like the dance, and I certainly didn’t like Maks’ attitude, but their fans will be power voting all through the night. So I think they are safe, but will likely be put in the bottom 2 again
4) David & Kym: an okay dance IMO, but as Coutney wrote, he seemed a bit subdued tonight. I think they might be a bit forgetable with Ricki/J.R. and Nancy’s great performances and Maks’ outburst.
5) Rob & Cheryl: I expected more from him after last weeks dance, and like David I think people might forget about him compaired to some of the other couples.
6) Chaz & Lacey: Loved the song, loved the outfits, but didn’t love the dance. I kept thinking how great it would be to see lacey dance it with Derek. 🙂
Chaz should go home tomorrow, and he shouldn’t be ashamed if he does. He has done a great job on the show, and I respect him for his determination and the enjoyment he brings to his dances.
Groupdance: Loved it! 🙂
“Then there is Derek. *sigh* A TOTAL BLOW AWAY PERFORMANCE and one of the best ever on DWTS! 10+++++” But he wore 2-tone shoes and did a cartwheel! Just kidding. It was dazzling. I hope his movie does well. I still like that dance with Nicole S. and the newspapers and the one in the sailor suits.
Not at all surprised that Maks finally vented tonight! I am surprised that it took this long. I just can’t understand why they allow the judges to belittle the stars after they are asked to come on the show. You can critique someone’s dancing without being insulting. Maks was speaking for all the other pros & stars who are working incredibly hard and are being belittled for their efforts. Hope did not become an Olympic gold medalist by not caring and not working hard. Dancing is not her gift, but she should not be insulted for trying her best. If TPTB think this makes good television, they are wrong! Maks has helped to make DWTS successful! I certainly don’t watch DWTS because I can’t wait to see the judges!!
Chaz and Lacey were doomed this week the moment they got Phantom as their song. I saw an AMAZING paso doble choreographed to the same music on the British version of this show last season. That dance made this one look very amateur (Seriously, youtube it. It was great).
My bottom 3 would be Chaz, Rob, and maybe Hope, if not just for “punishment” for what Maks said. But Chaz will go tomorrow. Enough is enough. Hold your head high, Chaz, you did great, but I think it’s time.
It wasn’t as exiting as I hoped either. As far as the fight between Len and Maks. Its not the first time and won’t be the last. That actually was the best part!
1. JR and Ricki – Wonderful dancing!
3. Nancy- It was cute, I liked it
4. David- Enjoyed his dance
5. Rob- Enjoyed it but liked David’s better
6. Chaz
7. Hope
I thought the group dance was so fun! Loved seeing everyone together, and as Heidi said on Twitter, I love that this cast gets along so well together. It really makes a difference on the show, I think.
Jr/Karina and Ricki/Derek killed it tonight! Great performances, and they deserve to be in the finals.
Nancy/Tristan were great tonight! I was hoping for a breakthrough performance from them, and we got it! Cute, fun, cheeky and light-hearted…And Heidi called Spamalot for sure! I, too, wish Nancy’s frame could have been a bit better, but I was just so excited to see her let go and have fun. Her connection with Tristan is gold, on and off the floor. I hope these two are the encore tomorrow, I felt they earned it with this dance.
David/Kym – I thought they were great and loved the choreo. David’s his own worst enemy with his energy, and it got the best of him at times, but he’s fun to watch.
Rob/Cheryl – Not my fave but not the worst. For me, he was just kinda there tonight. I wasn’t overly impressed but I wasn’t completely disappointed either.
Hope/Maks – I have to agree with the judges to a certain extent. Technique-wise, it wasn’t her best by far. But as far as connecting with the dance and Maks – I thought it was great. I was sorry to see Maks let his temper get the better of him. I know he was taking up for Hope, but personally, I don’t feel he needs to do that to that extent.
Chaz/Lacey – Not a good dance. I’m sorry to say, but I think we’ve seen Chaz dance his last dance. It wasn’t very good, and though I’m glad to have seen his journey on the show, I think it’s time for him to cheer on from the audience.
Very interested to see everyone else’s thoughts on this…
Honestly, I really remember very little from tonight except Maks’ rant. I even missed JR’s dance because I was too busy twittering about it. I wonder if other people had that reaction and what kind of effect it will have on the voting.
I realize Hope’s dance wasn’t technically great. (I agree heels would have helped in this case. I wonder who makes that decision?) I also think Maks’ choreography was surprisingly lackluster – normally he gives Hope very difficult routines (and doesn’t get any credit for it). However, it was so nice to see her more relaxed and she emoted better and seemed to be feeling the music, which was also nice. She took a step back in one way but improved in others, so if she were to stay on the show maybe she could put it all together. I also liked how Maks was basically rolling on top of her in the end and she slapped his rear! Their rehearsals are sometimes not pretty but I think they are genuinely friends.
Eliminations tomorrow should be interesting. I’m leaning towards Chaz. Even though he’s been surviving each week, I feel like he needed a good dance to motivate voters and this wasn’t it. He also came across badly in the package, I thought. I felt for Lacey’s frustration.
I liked the group number a lot. This is such a tight cast. It was nice to see them together and back with Carson!
I don’t think the judges have been harsh on Hope when it comes to the dancing criticism. She needs constructive criticism on her dancing, because she isn’t really improving. Now the Len rants about working hard or Maks’ cursing weren’t things the judges needed to be saying. But tonight, they actually gave constructive criticism on the dancing and they do have a right to speak when it is their turn without interruption. If the judges are ridiculous, the fans know it and vote even harder, so just let them talk.
I just think Maks makes it harder for himself and his partner to ever win this show. He makes it clear as the season go by that he has no respect for the judges, always saying he only care about the fans opinion, and he also said that again tonight. He knows how the show works though. I mean, he should, since he said it is his show right? 🙂 I know what he meant, but that is a comment that isn’t going to play off well. Why doesn’t he just play the game a little more, like many of the other pros do? The judges are most definitely inconsistent and ridiculous at times. Just appease them a little for once! Work on the stuff they ask, wear proper shoes, choreograph in a way you know they will like. It isn’t just about the fans, you need the judges help too. I would think he would find that obvious, since he never has won yet just on his/his partner’s fan base.
Maks popularity doesn’t hurt his partner one bit. I just think he should give his partner the best chance of winning by being quiet every once in awhile and trying to do what he can to up his scores. Everyone knows he isn’t pleased that he has never won. So, really try to win, on more than just your twitter fan base. Just accept the show for what it is, faults and all, and try to enjoy it. If you can’t, maybe it isn’t worth it to stay? He says he’s happy to be on the show, but it hasn’t been coming across at all.
Haha and as for the dancing….J.R. and Ricki were the bright spots of a crazy evening.
I think Chaz is going home too.
Maks, thank you for making the show what it is. It was boring until your rant… U got my votes
Yay I get a shoutout…lol. Thanks Courtney and you’re welcome…glad I could help.
First off how about that opening number from “Sister Act” and Kristin Chenowith. Loved every minute of it. Kristin’s number with the boys was one of my fav numbers of the night.
Loved most of the routines tonight…but Im thinking Hope might be in danger tomorrow and along with Chaz.
Vogue, I agree, the judges have been going way way too far with some of their comments in general for several seasons now, especially Bruno and Len. I often think how much I would like new judges on this show! It was a strangely misplaced rant tonight though. It was like he was reacting to a different, much more harsh critique.
There are so many talented pros who aren’t used for a variety of reasons (height, personality match, etc). Why can’t we use them for judges instead? They’ve competed, won titles, judged competitions AND been there with celebs each season. Are they not uniquely qualified to judge this show? You’d think TPTB would jump at the chance to save the money from flying Len and Bruno in and out each week.
I do agree that the judges comments can be harsh and rude but their comments make it a bit entertaining. That’s why the show is popular – they judge who’s fantastic and who’s not. And we the viewers have more power than they do to vote who should stay or go.
Loved Ricki and JR’s dance tonight and Nancy surprised me! My 7 votes will split between those 3.
Bottom 2 Hope and Chaz. I was always a fan of Maks but tonight, I lost all respect for him. I agree about the inconsistent scoring and comments he needs to be more humble and composed. He’s a bit self-centered and wants his efforts to be rewarded but every pro is on the same boat. It’s not “his show” as he said. He’s part of the success of the show but the show doesn’t revolve around him. He isn’t the star of the show, it’s the celebrities. The show will go on and succeed without him. Besides he doesn’t need to be on the show; he’s a successful business owner with several dance studios.
I am torn on the Maks-Len fight.
One because I think Hope despite the tough comments has always been scored VERY generously. She has received straight 8’s for many routines that barely were worthy of a 7.
But in Maks defense it must be very hard to see how down Hope is on herself due to some past very tough judges comments questioning her work ethic and sex appeal while Chaz, Nancy, and Rob have basically been treated with kid gloves.
As for tonight I am ready to put a curse on the voting audience. You have 2 couples left that look absolutely miserable- Chaz/Lacey and Hope/Maks. Chaz has not scored above a 21 in week 6. Hope has not performed 1 memorable dance yet. I have never seen Lacey look that serious before. She does not want to advance solely due to Mama Cher of the Gay/Lesbian/transexual community anymore.
Rob and David are doing dances worth 7’s but are being given 8’s because well…who else is there after Ricki and Derek. Their dances look the same to me. Rob is stiff and clean. David is fun and sloppy. I usually always forget their routines by the end of the show.
Nancy is doing solid for her skill level but a 9? LOL. And you wonder why Maks is so angry? Her dancing looks about the same. Liek Rob/David she is doing work worthy of about a 22 and nothing higher.
I think most of these 5 couples would have been given the boot by the halfway point in any other season but the talent level is so low that they will comprise the entire 2nd half of the season including a spot in the finals. Yikes.
JR and Ricki well…just pencil them in for the finals. No one left even deserves to be on the same floor as them.
Seeing Carson made me miss him especially with the sour energy around Hope and Chaz. He was not a great dancer but he was FUN and I always remembered her routines. And Chynna would have atleast given JR/Ricki SOME competition. Even Kristen. Heck even George Clooney’s ex improved 6 points from week 1 to week 2. Perhaps tonight would have been a little more exciting had the eliminations been a bit more…ehh sane this season?
Group dance was fun. And glad to see Carson back to help out. 😀
As far as Maks’ rant — he definitely let his emotions come to the surface and probably the fact that he still has translation problems, well, I am sure he meant that “we” and not “I” on his comment to Brooke about it being his show.
That being said, I thought Len’s comments were cruel and once again all three judges were smoking crack. Carrie Ann….a 9 for Nancy’s dance??? I suspect Maks’ fans are voting like heck tonight and probably getting some of the carryover from Carson’s since their “mutual affection” for each other is still going strong. 😀
Best dances of the night were JR and Ricki, no doubt about it.
What the heck was Hope Solo wearing. Is that suppose to make her look sexy? Some knitted top? Come On.
It distracted me from the dance. I was wondering if she or Maks was going to take that top off.
Great job, Courtney, yet again. I’m always amazed at how quickly you can put up your consistently lucid, perceptive, and IMO fair reviews of the night’s dancing. I don’t always agree 100% but can rarely fault your reasoning. Being west coast, I often have a choice of reading you before watching all the performances, but I seldom do, cuz the power rankings are so reflective of the actual show that after reading them, I feel like I’ve already watched it. 🙂
After seeing lackluster dances and Maks rant and saying that he owns the show, I wish Kristin, Chynna and Carson can be brought back to the show and have a double elimination with Chaz and Hope going home. I actually prefer Hope going home because of Maks’ attitude. I’m fan of his choreography and dancing but after his reaction to the judges comments, i hope they’re eliminated. It wasn’t a great rumba and I do agree with Len – it was her worst dance.
My hat’s off to JR and Ricki. I love them both since the beginning of the competition. So I’m happy they were both scored accordingly for their amazing quicksteps tonight.
I really enjoyed Nancy’s dance tonight, so I am happy that she finally got her 9. I know lots of women love Tristan, and I think he’s a cute and charming guy, but I am really getting annoyed at his tongue habit. Can’t he just keep his tongue in his mouth?! LOL! I also really enjoyed Rob’s danced and thought he was underscored.
As for Hope and Maks…. first they were actually running a lot in that dance and then at the end they were doing Maks’ signature walking move. I knew Len wasn’t going to like that. I know that perhaps Hope and Maks have a lot of ardent voters who are going to vote all night to try to keep them in the competition, but power voters just aren’t enough. They need to capture the average voter or the swing voter. In her packages, they just don’t portray Hope that well and she looks like she’s miserable. Then you have Maks yelling and cursing at her all the time. It’s a turn off to me. I don’t know… deep down, my impression is that Hope is not having a good time and neither is Maks. But that’s just my opinion. I think he was so much more palatable to me last season with Kirstie because they both were having a genuinely great time together.
Anyways, loved the group dance and seeing Carson together. I think Chaz or Hope will go home tomorrow night.
Why am I not surprised that Rude-o Bruno engaged in name calling again? Reminds me of him saying Ralph Macchio was wearing diapers last season.
Okay, NOW can we send Hope and Maks home, please? Nancy and Tristan were fantastic tonite! May we all be so willing and so energetic at 52! Of course Nancy argues with Tristan. It’s what she does- she is a strong, opinionated woman-with the ability and experience to back it up. And Tristan, with all his professionalism and even being as young as he is, knows exactly how to handle her. He gives as good as he gets, and Nancy respects him for that because she can’t bulldoze him. They have been fascinating to watch. So much growth and effort and energy. More power to them!
And regarding Maks…he is such an egotistical hypocrite. He and Kirstie were absolutely treated with kid gloves last season while others were more harshly criticized and he didn’t have any problems with that.. Shoe is on the other foot now.
Chaz and Lacey were pissed in the post show interviews. Chaz thinks he’s being picked on unfairly and not scored fairly.
Lacey called out people getting 9’s that don’t deserve it (must be Nancy) as a slap in the face.
Meoooooooow.
http://www.ontheredcarpet.com/video?id=8404162#global
@PC Hope’s outfit was a reference to Mimi, one of the main characters on Rent. Rent is, of course, the Broadway musical that their song, Seasons of Love, comes from. Maks probably tried to allude to Roger, another character on Rent as well, with his outfit.
Oh Lacey she by far is the worst choreographer on this show. She does she same key move atleast half a dozen times in every dance. I didn’t hear her complaining when Chaz was overscored the last 2 weeks. The same with Maks last season with Kirstie.
If she would take her mind off of her self serving choreo and her lame unflattering outfits maybe he’d be better dancer.
It’s funny how Maks only has a problem with the unfair judging when it doesn’t benefit him. He and KA benefited more than anyone last season and he didn’t say squat about it.
Chaz was mostly upset at the judges’ rude comments, especially the things Bruno keeps saying to him. And I can’t say I blame him – critique the dance, not make fun of someone like they did last season with Ralph. Watch the confessional!
Wow, maybe it’s just me but I actually liked Hope and Maks’ dance, and when I rewatched it, I actually think it’s pretty cute. This is one time where I think you can see them connecting and I really liked their chemistry. This is the best Hope has looked, as far as hair, makeup, and costume all put together. She looked gorgeous. She was just wearing a costume that reflects what the characters wear in Rent. I am not sure why they went with the boots, but it wasn’t that bad. Plus, their song was more friendly than romantic. There were parts of it that were cute. Her rehearsal was much better than last week, the troupe came in to help her, she looked really good. Maks was just saying that a lot of people have lost faith, which I’m sure Hope knows, but Maks still believes and has not given up.
If you have a moment and can rewatch their dance, please do, because you can see and feel the chemistry there between Hope and Maks. I am sure there are some that don’t like what Maks said, but there are also those who like how he stood up. I like that he stood up for Hope, but also for others, and clearly was talking about how the dancers contribute to what the show is. People watch to see the dancers and the stars, and he’s been there forever. Honestly, when Maks did that, he SHOWED Hope, as opposed to just saying, that he’s with her as a team and is going to stand up for. This was reflected, in my opinion, in the chemistry I saw on the dance floor. They’re getting closer and are connecting. I personally think they should have gotten better scores. This dance was better than last week, I think. Carrie Ann said she sees improvement, Len said he never lost faith in Hope, and Bruno said she was able to show the emotion of the song. Not that bad, but Maks just focused on the negative, when Len said he thought it was her worst dance, which honestly, I really don’t think it was at all. I feel like the judges know she can put it all together, chemistry, good dance, and are just waiting to see her do that. It’s just like when you know that moment is coming, and you’re just always looking for it. I still feel like if she can just put everything together that she’s learned, she can have that breakthrough dance and be at the top for once. I disagree with the people saying she looks like she’s not having fun. She smiled throughout the dance, the ending was cute, and in their rehearsal, she was happy and said she wanted to be there. She did not argue with Maks at all, he just said you have to show me something to make me keep believing. She responded well to his help and listened. This is the best I’ve seen her reacting to the judges. She has finally let go and relaxed.
Obviously Ricki/Derek and JR/Karina were the best, but they do have to watch how they come across in interviews and their rehearsals as well, because some of the things they say can go either way with viewers, I think.
I thought David/Kym were good, but yeah, they were off in some areas.
I think Rob/Cheryl were ok, but he does not come across as a dancer, and I don’t see that much between he and Cheryl. The chemistry is kind of off, I guess.
I think Chaz and Lacey really struggled with their dance, and Chaz looked very upset after the dance in the interview. Lacey looked very annoyed and like she was just not happy with the situation.
Nancy and Tristan were really cute and it was nice to see her so happy about their scores.
As a fan of Hope and Maks, I would REALLY love to see them put it all together and get everything right with another dance. She should definitely be able to have another chance at this with her much better outlook to it all, and knowing that Maks is there for her as a teammate and she can trust him. I really, really like Maks now, he is a good guy, and I feel like I know what he was trying to say when he was talking to the judges. I also think he is really cute with Hope!
# Buttercup commented on October 25th, 2011:
Chaz was mostly upset at the judges’ rude comments, especially the things Bruno keeps saying to him. And I can’t say I blame him – critique the dance, not make fun of someone like they did last season with Ralph. Watch the confessional!
Ehh not in the interview I linked to above. Chaz and Lacey specifically said they are not getting the scores they deserve and called out certain contestants for getting 9’s they don’t deserve.
But I think Chaz and Hope fans are so busy trying to turn them into wronged victims being picked on to distract from the fact they haven’t put together a strong dance in 6 weeks so I can understand if you think he is just upset over being called a penguin.
Soccer Is Awesome- Do you just watch Hope’s dances, or do you watch them all? That was painful to watch, reminded me of Bristol trying to act sexy and being so uncomfortable. Newsflash to Maks, “You are NOT the Miracle Worker!!” Not everyone can be taught to dance and dance well! Hope is one of those people like Mike Catherwood, Wendy Williams, etc.
I’m actually more concerned that Maks tweeted he got an amazing text from his momma. Sorry, but if my son acted that way towards his student and a judge, I wouldn’t be commending him.
Hmmm? Lacey didn’t seem to mind when Kyle was waaay overscored in season11, and that Chaz was overscored for his Paso. Does she really think his dancing is worth 8s? Really…Maks thinking Hope deserved 8s or even a 9????? Maybe some pros need to be replaced or sit out a season or two, so their heads & egos can return to their natural size.
Oh dear, I always watch a day later and check here first, but after seeing from the first comments that’s it’s too much drama again, I turned instead to the New York Times, and there it is too : (
http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/2011/10/25/arts/AP-US-TV-Dancing-With-the-Stars.html?_r=1&hp
Ricki/Derek: I think their QS was the best.
J.R/Karina: Great also, but I think Ricki and Derek had the edge.
Loved Nancy and Tristian, finally she looks like she’s having fun!
I think Maks was out of line. I know he’s defending his partner, but his comments to Len were uncalled for. CAI actually looked shocked that he made such comments to Len. He was a bit rude and I hope he and Hope don’t pay for it.
I am sorry but Chaz has to go. I absolutely give him credit for even attempting this. But he cannot dance. Lacey is even getting frustrated. She was right when she said she can’t help him remember the steps, he has to do this on his own! He is way to heavy and awkward. I think Chaz/Lacey and Hope/Maks will be at the bottom tonight!
Sheery,
Yes, I watch all the dances. What I mean is that there were parts of the dance that Hope did very well, and as an athlete, she can pull off some moves that look better to the eye than if another contestant did it, like a dip. Of course, her dance needs work, but she showed a lot of improvement. I don’t expect someone to already be perfect in Week 6. The beginning of the dance was cute and romantic, and so were other parts of it. Most of all, I just saw and felt Hope’s chemistry with Maks. They were connected this time, and their chemistry showed. Hope was also relaxed and that’s something we haven’t always seen. Also, Hope and Maks make a very attractive couple, so when they are out on the dance floor, it’s kind of impossible that they wouldn’t at least look good when they’re out there, again my opinion. Like I said, this is the best Hope has looked, she was absolutely gorgeous out there!
The main thing for me and I may be speaking for some others as well, is that I WANT to see Hope and Maks dance again. I think they have so much more that they can do, so basically, I think they definitely should stay. Again, that is my opinion.
I just saw their Red Carpet interview, and they both look very happy, and I’m seeing their connection and chemistry a lot stronger now. I hope we get to see them dance again.
I think bringing in the troupe dancers helped Hope a lot. Like Carrie Ann said, she showed improvement, and just didn’t maintain it throughout the whole dance. I wish she would have so it would have gone a lot better. But she did a lot of the moves they worked on with her (the whole hair thing when she’s facing Maks, her holding Maks’ hand) so I saw improvement, which is what this show is all about. Maybe the dance would have gone better with heels, but I thought it was still pretty good.
Also, Maks didn’t say anything about what specific scores they should have gotten. I personally think when someone stands up like that, not just for Hope but for all dancers and stars (he said everybody in the balcony works…) it is a good thing, because this world does not have a lot of people that are willing to do that. I am sure a lot of people that didn’t know Maks before saw that and thought way to go, for standing up for Hope. It would not be a good thing if he did that every week, but sometimes you feel you just have to say something. He does not speak perfect English either so maybe it didn’t come out the way he wanted it to. He always stands up for his dance partner, and honestly, it’s not a bad thing. I know there have been times in my life when I feel the need to stand up and say something when I feel someone is over the line. Like I said, not everybody would do that, but that’s why Maks is Maks the way he is.
Firstly, LOVED the group dance. I hate to say it but J.R. looked like one of the pros out there. Ricki NEEDS to be on broadway she rocked it as well. Rob also very impressive.
But on to the rankings:
1) J.R. and Karina: LOVED it! Best quckstep of the night in my opinion.
2) Derek and Ricki: LOVED it but I hate that song. Nonethless, she rocked it as well.
3) David and Kym: I really liked it a lot. He was well suited ofr the quickstep.
4) Nancy and Tristan: She was great! Foxtrot is totally her dance. I think we have a contender for the third slot in the finale if she keeps this up.
5) Rob and Cheryl: It was good nothing that really blew my mind and madem e say this dude was great though.
6) Hope and Maks: Hated the dance BUT Maks standing up fpr Hope should keep them around at least another week. On that little confrontation, I have two things that I want to say. 1) Carrie Ann was right. Telling Len that he should quit the business was uncalled for. 2) Maks could have said it a little bit nicer cuz I think he might have turned off a lot of potential voters.
7) Chazz: He really tries but it was not good at all.
As for having Carson there for group dance, I thought that was genius and truth be told I kinda hoped hear the judges or Tom say he was back in the competition but unfortunately not.
@Lenka: doesn’t surprise me that Maks and Lacey have sour grapes though. Lacey has Chazz and really can’t do much in the dances. Maks is just mad becuase he expected Hope to be a dancer but in reality she is good (don’t get me wrong) BUT he really can’t transfrom her into a dancer. I forsee the producers not asking one or both of them back next season.
Lastly, best costuming had to be J.R. and Karina. They really captured the essence of Chicago but I think Nancy is getting the encore this week. Worst costuming had to be Maks and Hope. I think mt grandkother used to have one of those blue thingsshe was wearing on the louncge cahir/arm chair when she used to ocver the chair with plastic during the 70s (mym other said that it looked pretty much like it lol).
D Williams “I certainly don’t watch DWTS because I can’t wait to see the judges!!”
My thought exactly
I was like, Ruh Roh, when Maks started in on his comments. The person watching with me, not a regular viewer, didn’t think a thing of if. “Why not say those things?” If I were Maks, though, I would have dialed it back a bit. But, GOD, calling Chaz a penquin, etc. Crossed the line. No one signs up to get flat-out insulted.
And some of the lifts in the group dance were scary awful. Just sayin.
Wow, the comments about Hope and Maks on here are so strange. Hope and Maks were wearing costumes from the Broadway show Rent. I am sure if they got Chicago, they’d be wearing Chicago costumes. I loved their look, it was totally Rent!
Hope looked absolutely gorgeous and can wear whatever and make it work because she is that attractive, and so can Maks.
I think the looks for Chicago and Guys and Dolls are great, but sometimes on this show they can come across as too much. I think I like those looks just on the Broadway stage to be honest.
I think Len was just upset about Hope wearing those boots and some of the parts of the dance that is really on Maks. It sounds like Len actually likes Hope and thinks she can do well. Maks just took the comment and went with it.
By the way, for anyone that knows Hope and her soccer career, it is amazing how alike she and Maks are. Hope has and would stand up for a teammate as well.
I feel like when I post here, I am always the one with the opinions that others don’t agree with!
I personally did not like Rob and Cheryl’s dance. Cheryl kind of outdanced him and not feeling their chemistry.
There is something about Ricki and Derek’s either dancing or just being partners that falls a little flat to me sometimes.
It was difficult to focus on JR/Karina’s dance because I was thinking about the discussion between Maks and Len.
David and Kym’s dance was good, I like that song so that helped to want to watch the dance.
Chaz and Lacey’s dance was not a dance I particularly liked.
I liked Nancy and Tristan and thought this was a good week for her.
Len is a traditionalist and I think he was expecting a traditional rumba but Hope and Maks dancing to Seasons of Love. They had to portray the characters and storyline (My guess is Len’s never seen Rent). It wasn’t her best dancing, I didn’t like her movement but the choreography was great. However, I don’t like how Maks disrepected Len and claiming that it’s “his show”. He’s a great dancer and choreographer but he has too much pride in himself. After last night’s rant, I hope he doesn’t win unless he learns to be humble.
I hope bottom 2 will be revealed. My bottom 2 are Hope and Maks and Chaz and Lacey.
Just wanted to also say, isn’t the point of the show to see improvements and couples’ best dances later on in the show?
What if Hope and Maks get a 30 in Week 7 or 8? Some people learn things here and things there and then one day, it all comes together.
I am from the athletic world and also the singing world, but I thought that was the point of the show? If you go back and look at say, Hope and Maks’ foxtrot, that was really good just based on dancing alone. I would like to see her put everything together and see how she does then.
Adam on comment 23- totally, completely agree with your entire post!
I agree with those who say that last season Kirstie & Maks completely benefited from the same thing he is so mad about this season. Viewers definitely voted for the journey and not the quality of dance last year (since Kirstie almost won the show), so if it is really just about that for you Maks, just focus on that and ignore the judges. This happens every season to the benefit and detriment of various pros and stars. If the show isn’t going to get new judges, all you can do is understand the system and work it…..
I do believe he has good intentions to defend the pros and his celeb, but the way he actually goes about it makes it seem more about him than his partner and that is a shame.
Really hope we see either Chaz or Hope leave tonight and that there is better dancing and less drama next week!
Underwhelmed by the group dance overall. Thought Derek was going to drop Ricki right on his head. Sure am glad they werent being scored on that mess. Biggest highlight of that dance was Nancy doing a handstand…. YOU GO GIRL!!
First to the judges, I was beginning to think Bruno was a kinder soul this season. Guess not! His remark to Chaz was inappropriate. As far as the Maks fiasco, its unfortunate, I had wiped my slate clean with Maks… But after this, he fell back down to the bottom of the barrel.
JR and Karina and Ricki and Derek were both phenomenal. Both in different ways. Agreed with Courtney on that one.
Nancy and Tristan – Thank Gawd! What a bright spot in an otherwise at times boring show. She was so happy with a nine. I love these two. I agree they could sneak into the finals….
David and Kym – David does seem to be getting better and the Grease number was cute. But it all seems to go haywire once he starts to talk… All I hear is: LKJDI ENGNIDL SEHEYG… Just a garbled mumbled bunch of words… Is it my hearing, my TV, or Is it David? If its David, of which I know it is, its not such a good thing..
Rob and Cheryl – I know hes trying but at the end of the night I just don’t remember him. Did Khloe yell again last night? Okay, Kardashians we know you there, just ZIP IT!
Chaz and Lacey – The mask was bothering me, I am not gonna lie. I know it went with the music but I was just distracting. I put these two in front of Hope and Maks.
Hope and Maks – You know, benefit of the doubt, I went back and rewatched this horrid spectacle. His rehearsal packages do not shed him in a favorable light whatsoever. Maks really is pathetic, and I feel bad for Hope. Look I get his point somewhat, BUT disrespectful to the judges, whether you like what they say or not, Is a BIG NO NO in my book. And WTF is up with the boots, I believe she had boots on before, all the other ladies are wearing the proper heels. And since when is it HIS show?? Time to go Maks, I have seen enough.
On something non-MaksandHoperelated, I think the band did great last night. Best they have ever sounded.
Not sure I agree with how he did it, but I di agree with Maks’ point. Some people get pats on the back just for showing up, while others get nitpicked over very minor things. He’s been saying it in his blog for years, I guess he just hit his breaking point (the proverbial straw on teh camel’s back if you will).
I think it will be Chaz to leave tonight, he’s had an amazing journey and has grown so much but his time is done.
Was very suprised at how well the band did all the songs, no butchering at all 🙂
@Lisa C: I honestly thought the band doing phantom was going to be terrible but they did ian excellent job. I have seen Phanton on broadway twice and it was up to par w the broadway version. And as much as I hate to say it, I even liked the band’s version of seasons of love and I hated the original version andm ovie version off the song. On a side note, I saw Rent and it was good but why is it so beloved?
Does anyone else remember when all three of the judges actually let each other talk, and when Tom didn’t need referee stripes and a whistle while dealing with those three egos?
Of all the judges, I respect Len the most… Yes, he is tough, but what he says, is really pretty spot on…. And he seems to be able to look at a celebrity dancing, and figure out how much potential they have, and then judges them in successive weeks, according to that. And, it does mean that he seems to be tougher on some than others, because he sees more, and wants more. And he wants to see more from Hope, than she’s shown so far…
Last week, I thought the judges sat down, and figured out who they thought should leave based on how well they dance, or not dance, and scored appropriately, so that audience vote couldn’t overcome the deficit, so that one of the less able dancers went home. And that was Carson. And this week, I was thinking the same, with Chaz and Lacey scoring well below everyone else, that they felt that Chaz isn’t improving quickly enough, and should go home. Then Hope and Maks danced, and now I don’t know.
@Soccer is Awesome – I know you are really passionate about Hope, which is great…but do you think you could maybe try and keep your comments a bit shorter? It’s just getting a bit laborious to read & scroll through…
@Adam – I wouldn’t dismiss Buttercup so quickly, given that the knowledge she has of the show is far greater than that of the average viewer. I tend to believe her when she says things about some of the couples’ true feelings.
Oh, and thank you very much, Faby 😀 It’s a struggle sometimes, but I try to be both coherent and speedy in posting my rankings 😛
Well, I rewatched Hope’s dance and actually agree with the score, which I didn’t at first, as anyone following my twitter will tell you. I even agreed with Maks up until he got to the sky box and continued to let it rip, throwing his fellow pros and other celebs under a huge freakin’ bus. He sure didn’t mind when Hope was ridiculously over scored last week! He didn’t care last season when Kirstie was over scored frequently! As for Lacey – same for her. EVERY pro has benefitted from over scoring, and EVERY pro has been underscored – season after season after season. Chaz is actually likely who Maks was referring to when he said some were being scored “on effort” while others on technique. I DO agree with Lacey when she says she is pissed that the judges keep calling Chaz names – that is uncalled for, totally.
Most of all, I feel sorry as hell for Hope. That poor girl. I think Maks put her in a horrible position and she looked like she wanted to cry when they were down on the floor. I just don’t think Maks helped her at all. Combine with the piss poor tone coming from Len and you just have way too much mean surrounding her week after week.
And, best of all, Derek pretty much, for the first time ever, actually says that he didn’t agree with what Maks did. Bravo, boy – got thrown under the bus one too many times, I would say. He was, of course, extremely diplomatic about it, and clearly would have rather not discussed it – but he said that they are all seasoned professionals, they know how the show works, they know they get over or underscored at time. Bravo. Exactly right. You have all been on this show for years, you get paid very well, and you know how it works. Or you should.
Well, Maks might HAVE to take some time off after this season – TPTB might have difficulty finding a partner for him in the future. What a jerk. And I don’t for a minute think he was defending his partner. He got ticked when Len said that half of the problems Hope had with the dance were his fault. Maks really hurt her, not just by going after Len but also by belittling her in rehearsal. WTF?
I thought Hope did a good job with the dance – the costume was unfortunate and really did nothing to soften her and I totally agree with Len about the boots. But I thought she put herself out there and her movements were more feminine and her lines were much better than they have been in the past.
LOVED JR and Ricki’s dances!! And didn’t Nancy shine! So fun. Liked Rob’s dance – he is improving but he is still too stiff. Didn’t care that much for David’s dance – and it is time for Chaz to go. I was surprised at how harsh Lacey was with him and Bruno was out of line, but he is the weakest of the celebs.
@Sandy: It’s David. I have the same issue w him. When you watch one of his movies he speaks so clearly but when he talks on the show he is like that. I’m chalking it up to nervousness when in front of judges and when receiving scores.
@Lori: I really hope that Maks’ little tirade isn’t going to come back to bite him in the butt. If Hope gets eliminated it would be his fault since he let his ego get the best of him. Yes his main point was made (judges are a lot more pickier w Hope BUT he fails to see its for her benefit.) But i feel like this was pent up anger over what he considered low scores (bet he wishes he got 8s this week) and the fact that Hope isn’t what everyone expected her to be on the show. She went in the frontrunner in the eyes of many and lost that spot pretty quick to J.R. and Ricki. She is good but good enough top win the trophy nope.
Er….Maks has lived in the US since he was, like, 12. I don’t think a translation problem is really a great excuse.
Great post Heidi.
The On The Red Carpet interviews were certainly interesting this week.
Maks got his point across in a much better way in the interview. Bottom line is I don’t think the judges will change. It is hard to judge this show fairly anyway in the format. So many dancers on different levels, doing different style each week. They really need to use more of the range of paddles from the beginning. If you start at week one at 6 or 7, there aren’t many paddles left to show gradual improvement.
Derek didn’t agree with what Maks did on the broadcast and had the guts to say that too, where most of the pros danced around their opinion. Derek also made the point I’ve been posting about–it’s been 13 seasons, they know how the show works and the judging works and should just deal with it professionally.
Kym seemed confused about why Maks was that angry since the judges have been supportive of Hope in her opinion (minus the 2 rants from Len in earlier weeks, I agree)
Lacey & Chaz were really, really upset about their scores….and yes they are working hard, but I don’t see how they can expect high scores with what they put out there. I think he’s been scored plenty fairly. He is the worst dancer left…do they really think they deserve to be above several of the other dancers? They seemed to allude to being judged unfairly compared to everyone else….interesting….I don’t see that at all. Except for the rude comments that have nothing to do with dancing, they have been judged fine to me, arguably too high…. Lacey obviously threw Nancy Grace under the bus too in the interview, saying someone didn’t deserve a 9. Well, whether she did or didn’t, she is still better than Chaz….
Courtney,
Yes, sorry, I will try not to write so much, just have a lot to say!
Vin,
If you are familiar with Rent, I don’t really understand the comments about Hope and Maks’ costumes, they were playing the characters.
Princess Heidi,
I don’t think Hope feels that way at all. Just watched their Red Carpet and Access Hollywood interviews. Hope and Maks are alike, what Maks did is the equivalent of what Hope would do for a teammate.
Okay, if Lacey actually was complaining about Chaz’s scores and NOT just about the name calling, I have to say that the judges aren’t the only crack smokers in the room.
And I have to laugh when a Hope fan has concerns with how Ricki and JR come across in interviews. Hehehe
Wow. What a night of dancing and not all in a good way. Agree largely with Adam in post #23 about the shape of this season and will add the following on last night:
1) JR: To me the best dance of the night at a tough time to dance it. The Maksplosion sorta changed the tone and put a damper on the rest of the night, but I thought JR did a commendable job trying to reset, though do think the preceedings detracted the Group and particularly JR’s dances.
Any overshadowing aside, still the best dancer (and prob personality) of the season and a splashy enough performance that doubt he’s goin anywhere other than top of the leaderboard next week,
2) Ricki: Great effort and dance. Still in it to win it.
T3) Nancy: Alright, I still think her dancing is small and uneventful, but I did appreciate her trying to take it up a notch and inject more character into the dance. Wasn’t quite 8s & 9s but likely to enough to go on to dance at least another week.
T3) David: Another one who is not the best dancewise, but is making an honest effort to be there and enjoying it in the process. And having Kym is a tremendous asset. Prob safe at least another week.
5) Rob: Like David, not the best dancer but growing on me for the attitude and effort. Lacking in rthym and hip action and but prob safe at least this week.
6) Hope: Oy. A bit like David but without the enjoyment factor. Unlike Len, I have never questioned her effort but despite her best intentions, felt the Rumba technique was largely lacking as well as the connection with Maks. In fact, she seemed much more comfortable (and markedly improved) when working with the Troupe gals…and at this point, not sure Maks did her any favor with his outburst. This was an all-around classic case of ‘it’s not so much what you say as how you say it.’ Maks has a bit of a point, yet ironically Hope has been one to (at times) benefit from judges’ overpraise and scoring this season. Not sure if that display was for ratings, publicity/attention, sympathy votes, show of solidarity or whatever, but Maks came off particularly bad wfith his insulting quip to Len and “my show” bit. Anyway, doubt we’ll see both Hope and Maks leave on such a low note, especially as there’s much drama and storyboarding to be had here. However, there is a history of impetulant pairings soonafter being dismissed.
7) Chaz: The aura around him wasn’t the usual light and fluff and the mask was lifted so expect the stage is set for him to disappear Phantom-style tonight. Sidenote: Can see Lacey taking issue with the penguin type comments, but saying Chaz has been underscored…um HUH???
Group dance: In short, Rob stood out in a good way as did David. JR weras less noticeable to me, Ricki needed a lift icebreaker, Hope was Hope, Chaz was Chaz and Nancy went for it.
Laurie- I think Maks has failed to see for several seasons now how much he has hurt his celeb’s chances in various ways- usually by his mouth or by his choreography. I kind of giggled when Len said that too because it is true. I don’t care some things Len has said to Hope this season, but that comment toward Maks wasn’t all wrong. And I know it is one part of a whole week, but yes, I thought he was very rude in the package. Just suggesting that you feel like you don’t have faith in your celeb anymore is just the opposite of the point of this show.
No one has mentioned the numerous shots of Chaz way up in the third tier in the fog while Tom was talking – happened at least twice and it creeped me out both times, which is what they meant to do. Really brought the feel of Phantom to the ball room. Very clever, IMO.
Of course she’s saying that now, Soccer, but it doesn’t change the fact that Maks’ behavior really doesn’t help her. If they make it through, they have to be judged by those same judges again next week. Which can go one of two ways – either they go in the opposite direction and over score her to prove maks wrong (thereby doing AGAIN what Maks was bitching about when it happens to others) OR they bottom her out and decide she’s next to go. And based on her dancing last night, that’s entirely possible.
This may be an unpopular opinion, but sometimes people have an issue with something like what Maks did because it’s something that they would never do. There are only certain people in this world that are going to rock the boat, and that’s why we are all different.
Another thing, this is me the athlete speaking, the number one thing in competition is to respect your opponent. I think when discussing other contestants, everyone should say that everyone is their competition and respect everyone as their “opponent” in this competition. I feel like that is not being done.
That’s like being in the World Cup and being in a group with a team that is not that strong and respecting the other teams in the group as your competition and not that team. Every athlete knows to respect everyone as your competition that is in the game.
You’re exactly right, Soccer, that is NOT being done….by MAKS.
Do you think it’s respectful of other teams and the competition when you basically say that some are getting scored on effort and others on technique?? Basically throwing others under the bus? That would be like saying “the other team only won because the ref made a bad call” – is that respecting the other team?? Not where I”m from.
And remember, there is truth, there is hypocrisy and there a lack of professionalism – Maks displayed all three, when he would have come off much better if he had stuck to defending Hope. Although, telling Len that maybe he should get out of the business is WAY far over the line and just as uncalled for as anything Bruno has said this season.
Heidi,
Yes, I see your point. I do think, however, that Hope and Maks’ rehearsal was much better. He did say he has not given up on her and that he just wants to see something from her. I understand that this is more his personality coming through and just how he is.
I think Hope and Maks showed a much better connection and chemistry and really liked pretty much everything Hope said in rehearsal and after the dance. Best I have seen her handle the whole thing honestly.
Ok, I am not all that knowledgeable about dancing as far as the type of level you would have to be to understand everything. I play soccer and I sing! I don’t think Hope looks that bad?! I personally like her dancing better than Rob’s and sometimes David’s and Nancy’s! I hear a lot of comments and read comments that some actually like her dancing. The guy that does the Red Carpet interviews said that he likes what he sees and commented on her dip today.
Heidi, or other dancing people, could you help me understand more why it looks so bad to everyone? I rewatched it and it’s actually one of my favorite dances from them. I like their chemistry and Hope looked beautiful. Maks was cute with her, and like their Viennese Waltz, I liked the actual dance.
Heidi,
Just saw your other post. Yeah, it’s weird, I saw it completely different honestly. I thought Maks was standing up for Hope and also for the other dancers and stars as well, and just was saying that he wants the judges to be fair and not say those mean comments they were saying. Hope and Maks danced right after Chaz and Lacey which may have had something to do with Maks getting upset given what the judges said to Chaz.
I get the feeling from Maks, and I know Hope is like this because she’s an athlete, that he respects the actual competition and wants things to be fair. I get the feeling sometimes from others that they don’t look at everyone as their competition.
I would hate to see Hope go out on such a low note – I really hope it’s Chaz – but it’s also hard to watch all the negativity that swirls around her. I feel bad for her for that too.
Sad if she goes, sad if she stays. Poor Hope.
Sorry Maks was out of line and disrespectful!
There is a way to get your opinion across without being disrespectful! Even Derek disagreed! How many times has Derek been thrown under the bus and attacked by Maks, but still Derek was a gentleman!
Sometimes its all about Maks and not his partner! This just may cost Hope!
Did u’all notice that Maks unfollowed Derek because he disagreed with Maks? Wow!
Trying to stay out of the Hope/Maks discussion but….I liked her waltz & the Toy Story foxtrot (which she seemed to enjoy). Think Maks has been making a mistake trying to make her this sexy woman he thinks she needs to be.
Right or wrong, I think Mak’s mini rant brought he and Hope closer. I for one think they needed that “us against the world ” mentality. I loved how he came to her defense,something she hasn’t seen from him much. Their Twitter messages to each other we so sweet. Just the kind of partnership I have been looking for. Her dance wasn’t perfect but she definitely redeemed herself reputation-wise. Plus,she is drop dead gorgeous and I loved their costumes. but people are right when they say the boots didn’t help with her dancing. It’s crazy to practice in heels then switch to boots. I think she will squeeze through tonight and Chaz will go but I don’t have to remind anyone how unpredictable this show is. We’ve all seen couples sent home with good scores…Brandy,etc. Only JR and Rickie are truly safe.!
I don’t see where Maks was throwing any of the pros under the bus. I thought he was taking up for all the pros. What I got out of his rant was that he thinks the judges should show a liitle more respect to the celebrities and judge everone on the same scale. He never said Hope desevered a better score, just judge her and treat her like the rest of the not so good dancers.
The problem is, Soccer, Maks has benefited tremendously from the judges wacky behavior and he certainly had no problem with it when it’s in his favor. This is not a new thing, it happens every season (although not to Hope, last week) and having been on the show as long as he has, he should know that, and be prepared to deal with it. It has really nothing at all to do with Hope. I’m sure he *believes* what he is saying, but I think he needs rest and a break cuz I don’t think he’s thinking clearly. Bitch about Len’s tone and disagree all you want – but as soon as you tell someone to get out of the business AND then claim that others are getting better treatment you’re crossing an invisible line.
As for Hope’s actual dancing – well, nothing the judges said was actually wrong. There is something very confused about her dancing and I think it makes the judges rather confused as well. She seems…out of control, weak arms one minute and then powering through the next. I did think she captured the emotion and was actually lighter and more personable in the dance last night that she has been in the past – she actually had me believing she deserved a higher score than what she got. The problem is, is that big fight between Len and Maks made me watch it over again, a few times – and I saw their points completely. Maybe if Maks had kept his mouth shut I would have been left with the feeling that Len was on crack, and not Maks. We’ll never know, now. I’m suggestible, as I imagine the rest of the audience is as well. But we have DVRs now. 🙂
Every pro has their frustrations about overscoring, judges comments etc but they all know who to deal with it without throwing a rant about it over and over. I agree with Derek – Maks has been on the show long enough. If he’s not happy with the judges, leave the show. The pros need to respect the judges regardless.
Me: You hit head on!
Ya know…I probably wouldn’t support Maks’ rant so much if it weren’t for Bruno sayng Chaz looked like a “penguin”. I am more upset on that more than anything else said last night from the judges. What they said on Hope was nothing compared to what Bruno said on Chaz.
And Soccer, it’s really all subjective. You have to accept that not everyone sees what you see with Hope and Maks.
Soccer: My issue with Hope’s dancing is that she is so flatfooted with her steps. Or at least that’s all I can figure out that it is. She looks like she is clomping around the floor when she does one of the ballroom dances and when she does the latin dances she looks like she is just walking. I feel that Maks should have been working with her on that. Stepping with your heel or your toe instead of just putting your whole foot out there really makes a huge difference in that it makes you look much more “dancerish”. The boots seemed like a way to try to hide the flatfootedness, because they are flat also, but to me it just accented it. I don’t think her dancing is all that awful, but the deal with her feet just make it painful for me to watch her! And it seems Maks never addreses that issue when IMO that one thing it could make her look soooo much better. I do agree, though, that the judges should have all along been giving her better advice than that she should practice longer….how is that helpful? Tell her specific things! Especially if its something that Maks should be dealing with but isnt. I also feel like she may have done better with another pro who isnt so harsh in his teaching. I have worked with both harsh instructors and ones with the patience of a saint and let me tell you, it makes all the difference in the world!
To all those that say the pros need to respect the judges and that Maks should have never have said that- I bet if it was your favorite pro that had said what Maks said, you would be singing a different tune.
Evelyn:
Maks is really the only pro (regardless of who we support) who has jumped on the judges rudely and harshly. He was also insulting. ( I like Maks believe me). There is a way of getting your point across without being rude!
He said they were too judgemental, isn’t that what they are, judges?
Thing is, Evelyn, NONE of the other pros have ever done that and they’ve been on the show a long time as well. So, there you go. Derek went off in the confessional and was soundly criticized by EVERYONE for it – he also apologized to everyone and wrote notes to all the celebs and pros saying he was sorry. Not even Lacey has crossed the line, and she would be next most likely to. It’s been on the air 13 seasons now – really, is any of this a shock?
Maks is my favorite pro! Although Tristan is quickly moving up on my list. 😉
oops! Forgot to say in my previous post that the penguin comment was totally unnecessary. I dont think they should be allowed to say stuff like that; I think they could get bigger stars on there if they were not able to. The show is shooting itself in the foot with its need for drama when it comes to the judges. I already mute or fast forward thru their comments and Brooke’s interview afterwards…I missed Maks outburst and had to go back and watch it later because I just can’t stand the hear some of the stuff that comes out of the judges’ mouths (or Brooke’s for that matter). Of course, my favorite part of the show is watching the pros dance, so…. *shrug*….
Soccer, the best thing to do is to compare dances. Look at rumbas from other seasons on YouTube and see the difference in Hope’s from theirs. Codebear4’s channel is probably the best place to go. Scroll through the seasons and watch the rumbas. Pam Anderson’s comes to mind, Chelsea Kane, Jennifer Grey…
Ok, maybe I was too busy taking notes or just zoning out, but everyone’s up in arms about Bruno calling Chaz a penguin LAST NIGHT, right? The reason I ask is that this isn’t the first time someone has referred to Chaz as a penguin on the show – I think the same comment was made back in week 2 or something, and Chaz responded in the confessional with “Oh well. At least penguins are cute!” and seemed to take it in stride. I didn’t hear anyone getting their knickers in a twist about it then, including Chaz & Lacey themselves. It just a bit funny to me that everyone seems to suddenly be bothered by it now…
The judges comments have gotten way out of hand in regards to the celebrities who are accomplished individuals in their chosen fields and deserve respect for trying to learn ballroom dancing. Judges want repect – respect has to be earned. The judges comments and antics of the past few seasons are just too much. I applaud Maks for standing up for Hope.
I didn’t find the penguin comment all the insulting, honestly. I guess if it was me taking it, but still…I think he was trying to say that he was being cute and waddley instead of attacking and ferocious and graceful. Which he was – and he was in black and white, come on.
Oh Maks. I love him, and he has great intentions – but he does this at least once a season where he says something stupid that he may not *really* mean, but in the heat of the moment it comes off just bad. The comment to Len was a little over the line, and I just groaned. But it’s funny, cause HOPE is the one being constantly overscored. Flat feet, nonexistent hip action, flaily arms, weird expressions sometimes, wobbly OR too powerful legs. She is just not a good dancer. It happens.
I can’t decide if I like JR or Ricki’s QS last night, they were both soooo good yet different. I think Ricki was way better last night than the tango, personally.
Yay for Nancy and Tristan. What an adorable foxtrot. She also seems to be having way more fun than most people could have believed. Honestly it’s an inspiring pairing, and I am so glad for them this season. Especially Tristan, of course /drool
I feel like Rob took a step back with the cha-cha. I liked some of David’s QS but a few parts were definitely out of sync and it bothered me a bit. Still, I think Chaz or Hope should go home. Either way I’m fine with it.
Court, I remember thinking Bruno was wrong to say Chaz looked like a penguin in week 2, but, I let it slide since Chaz and Lacey let it slide. But, last night, I felt it was done in poor taste and in a more mean spirited way. I mean…Bruno just kept going on and on and on. He did the same last year with Ralph. How much does a person need to be beat down on something before it becomes downright abusive and you want fight back for yourself?
I just rewatched Maks and Hope’s segment again. I do think Maks gets arrogant with the “my show” comments. It was also wrong for him to tell Len he should retire. That part was disrespectful. But, Maks was right about the judges being too harsh at times and not knowing when to stop. These celebrities don’t deserve to be publically humiliated like that after they are clearly giving it everything they can. The judges need to know when they need to stop when you can clearly see the hurt in their face after they get the message.
Okay, just stating the obvious: it’s J.R. for the win and Ricki for second place. J.R. is the total package — he’s a hero, a humble, hardworking guy, and a natural dancer to boot — and if you don’t love him, you quite obviously, as Mr. Stephen Colbert would say, hate freedom. 😉 The only uncertainty that the producers have left to milk drama out of is who will take third, and I actually do find it interesting because it does seem wide open.
I agree that it was pretty obviously the judges’ intent to give Chaz the axe last night. I can’t really blame them THAT much. I like Chaz as a person; I respect his work for trans acceptance and for going on the show in the face of bigotry (digression, but I respect everything almost every contestant has done this season to be positive representatives for diversity — J.R. for veterans’ issues and people with facial differences, Carson for pride, Hope and Nancy for women working in male-dominated fields, David for recovery… I’m aware that sounds totally cheesy, but it honestly has given me a lot of joy these past few weeks) but… the show is called Dancing with the Stars, not The Celebrity Decent Human Being Awards. I dunno what came over him last night, because he has to realize it’s Week Six and just realistically, his time to bow out must be drawing near. I mean, Carson saw it coming, and so do David and Nancy (Rob might have the Kardashian clan behind him, but he should also be afraid too)… I also noticed that in the OTRC interviews, Lacey wasn’t angry on Chaz’s behalf, or jumping to his defense… she seemed to be trying to stay as impartial as possible, but she didn’t agree that he was underscored and deserves to stay. That should clue him in, no? I dunno, his behavior just seemed quite weird and ungracious to me. Also, I know it’s Broadway Week, and Phantom does not skimp on the dramatics, but did it seem like the stage team was doing everything in their power to augment/distract from Chaz’s performance with the spotlights and props? I dunno, some other performances seemed quite stripped down in comparison. Regardless, I think lasting until the halfway point, especially with bad knees, is nothing to sneeze at, and I hope Chaz can be satisfied and proud of his work.
Re: Maks’s outburst — I’m stuck at work while the show airs, so I follow a liveblog until I can get home and watch the recording (the suspense might be too much for me otherwise) — maybe it was that the bloggers were overreacting and I was expecting major drama, but it honestly didn’t seem like that big of a deal. Especially with all the booing and shouting over each other and other tomfoolery that’s going on with the judges this season — I can’t deny that it seems to be escalating, and I can’t say I like it, but if Maks is going to play the “bad boy,” then I guess it makes sense for him to up the ante. And if it’s really “his show,” then he knows for sure that the absolute last thing you want to be is forgettable. Which, in all honestly, I thought their dance was. I’ll admit it didn’t make a good impression on me due to weird personal bias, because I possess an irrational ire for “Seasons of Love…” oh lawd, do I ever hate that pretentious, tuneless song. 😉 I don’t know who’s responsible for putting her in those boots that, as Len said, hampered her dancing, but they also didn’t do her any favors. I did think she hit nice lines, but Bruno was right (and I’ve totally done the same thing too, so I empathize with her) in that she wasn’t dancing through all the beats and it looked stilted. Still, I don’t think it’s impossible that the Powers that Be are in fact scripting a mighty comeback for Hope, and all the “persecution” she’s getting from the judges is just to raise the stakes for her eventual triumph.
As for my boo David, I also agree with the comments that he wasn’t bad, but wasn’t good enough to be particularly memorable either, which makes me worry we’ll see another “shocking elimination” tomorrow. I noticed other bloggers commenting that they were sick of Grease routines and expressing relief that it least it wasn’t the millionth performance of “You’re the One That I Want.” The bar had already been set and they needed a major wow to even make an impression, which I don’t think happened. David did best when he was playing really distinctive, larger-than-life characters, i.e., Indiana Jones and Sid Vicious/Billy Idol, which makes sense as he could channel his extra energy into those mannerisms… it seems like a weird paradox, because as many people have said, David is completely, totally, 100% candid, but at the same time, I don’t think he’s comfortable in his own skin. If he had more purpose to his expression, instead of just rattling off everything that comes to mind because he’s not processing his emotions, he’d come off as sincere, and not fragile. I’d say (and this is me playing armchair psychologist from my own experience, so feel free to disregard) that some of it probably comes from being in recovery — addictions thrive in secrecy; you just waste so much time and energy covering your tracks, so a huge part of getting over it is learning to be honest again. But while you’re in the process of casting off the “old you,” you’re not quite sure who the “new you” is yet. He does seem to be settling down, though, and I’m gonna keep rooting for him, whether he’s eliminated or not.
I think Bruno needs to stop his critiques beginning with “you looked like” or “you reminded me of”. This week Chaz looked like a penquin to him and last week it was a basketball – if my memory is right. Who wouldn’t get tired of comments like that when they should be being judged on their dancing?
As for what everyone is saying about Hope’s attire, this is one of the reasons I despise theme weeks. If it hadn’t been explained that this was similar to a character in Rent, I would still be wondering why she was dressed as she was.
And Maks’ tantrum.. yes, I view it as a tantrum because it reminded me of a child not getting what he wanted.. I thought he was completely out of line with saying it might be time for Len to get out of the business. How insulting and disrespectful is that? Can you imagine the reaction if anyone should suggest the same to Maks? I’ve always liked Maks, but have to agree with others… he has been at the other end of the spectrum and had no problems with receiving scores not realistically deserved. The judging is never consistent, unbiased or fair. If he’s been on the show long enough to consider it “his”, he should know this by now.
Having said all that… I think Chaz has gone as far as he can. I see it possibly being between him and Hope tonite.
In many ways I agree respect often has to be earned. But it is also a given in certain situations.
We are supposed to respect our parents and elders as a general rule. And in business, most of the time we should to respect our bosses. Lawyers are a great example, they have to respect courtroom judges in the courtroom (like Nancy Grace said in her interview). The judges deserve to be given some respect since they are the judges. They deserve to have their turn to speak. And if they are constructively criticizing the dances, they are doing what they are supposed to be doing. When they start name-calling or being insulting, I think the pros have a right to speak back. But if they are actually judging the dancing (which they were when they were speaking to Hop and Maks last night), it is their right to speak and not be insulted just because the pro doesn’t want to hear any criticism, even good criticism.
The structure of the show isn’t ever going to be fair. Make lemonade out of lemons and get over it. Somehow, the right dancers usually end up in the top 2, so it still works out most of the time.
Chaz did take it in stride the first time, and the second, etc. There’s only so long you can laugh along and not be offended.
One of the problems is that each judge has a format they use repeatedly and i do think some of their comments are “prepared.” Bruno always has a performance story ready, doesn’t always even fit what we just saw. Make it simple: say what was good; what could be improved on; the overall impression (technique + performance). I doubt many of the better-listers than what we have seen recently (say, a Jane Seymour, even George Hamilton or Wayne Newton) would do this show as it is now??
Exactly, Buttercup! Even good-natured folks have their limits. And it HURTS. I don’t want to think it’s intentional on any of the judges’ parts, but they need to realise how hurtful those words are. Especially since they’ve spoken out against bullying – well, I know Carrie Ann and Bruno have – in the past. This is bullying at it’s most insidious.
Re Chaz as the Phantom, showing up in various spots, yes, I liked that.
Is this whole experience a repeat for Hope? Remember, she got thrown off her team a couple of years back for disrespecting her coach, fellow players, etc. My guess is that she and Maks have similar views and can be tone deaf (un self aware).
For me, when the back and forth gets too much – like the earlier comment about Tom having to step in a lot recently – the entertainment aspect suffers.
Maks needs to use his words wisely. I love his brutal honesty but it’s getting tiring. I’m sure he’s tired of it too. It’s an entertainment show. Yes the judges comments are over the top but that’s what makes it interesting to watch.
He’s been on the show for 10 seasons and regardless of what dance background CA and Bruno have and Len being a traditionalist he needs to be open to their suggestions.
IMO, the rumba wasn’t Hope’s best dance. I didn’t feel a connection.
JR/Karina and Ricki/Derek were fabulous last night. Nancy/Tristan were cute; nice to see more expressiveness from Nancy. Wish David/Kym had nailed it. It wasn’t a standout show, but most of the couples seemed to be having fun with their Broadway-themed dances and I was enjoying it well enough until the Maks-Len smackdown. After that ugliness, I just felt sad and tired.
Tons of good comments and discussion above. One of the thoughts that resonated with me was the one from Lori (#56) “Does anyone else remember when all three of the judges actually let each other talk, and when Tom didn’t need referee stripes and a whistle…”
Yeah, the good ‘ol days *sigh* It seems to me the lack of respect the judges have shown for each other and the lack of respect they’ve shown the celebs by making cutting personal remarks (e.g., “penguin” and “ewok”) has eroded what little professional respect they had from the pros, celebs, and audience. Respect is a two-way street. If you don’t treat others with respect, you’re not entitled to any in return (regardless of what your position in the hierarchy is). This lack of respect creates the conditions for unprofessional outbursts.
That said, this is not a defense of Maks (in whom I’m deeply disappointed). As my dad is so fond of saying, “two wrongs don’t make a right.”
Chaz/Lacey and Hope/Maks are my choices for tonight’s elimination. Either one would be OK, because I don’t think either couple would be sad to leave. Just wish we could trade both for Carson/Anna.
I’ve decided to rank this time or try too. 😀 I havn’t this season so far but i’ll try too!!
JR AND KARINA: WOW! This was soooo the best dance of the night! Everything was pure perfection. Karina’s cheorio was outstanding and he delivered and more! I’m almost ready to say J.R. has this thing BAGGED!! 😀
RICKI AND DEREK: Another great perfromance by these two! She danced mainly very clean too. Sometimes her feet did a little wonky thing but that’s very small thing. I loved the song too! Very Broadwayish. 😛
NANCY AND TRISTAN: BREAKTHROUGH! I loved it! I’d also rather get docked a point by Len and be fun and entertaining then get an estra point and be boring. Great dance, great score, great package. I’m hoping she gets the turd spot in the final. 😉
DAVID AND KYM: He’s always entertaining but last night he seemed off. His technique kinda suffered too but all in all a really good dance. I love Kym too. 😛
ROB AND CHERYL: I really enjoyed this dance! I thought did great and is starting to move really well. I think he CAN do better though. He could be great but he just has to let himself. Come on, Rob!! You got this! 😀
CHAZ AND LACEY: Well dancing wise…Lacey said they would get murded and they did. It was well…bad. 🙂 Really bad. Actually at the beggining I thought it would be great but it fell to pieces. I think he should of been gone WEEKS ago based on dance performance, but I did fell kinda bad form him after they got that terrible score and I think certain couples who reeeaaallly BOMBED on attitude and dance will save them this week. I’m fine with tihs, mind you. 🙂
HOPE AND MAKS: Yeah….Not gonna say much excpet for Mak’s attitude is….turdy. 🙂 Annnddd I think Hope is an ackward mover. Really ackward. When Oksana and the troupe were helping her I saw potential but she didn’t deliver. At all. It was just odd from the dance too the shaw/blanket she wore to the millitary boots. Just odd and they are kinda ” I hate to it ” off putting. I think it’s them tonight. It’s between and her and Chaz I think but I think Chaz might actually pull though. Again. 🙂
I just hope Nancy stays because i really want to see her make more fans. Its fuuny to me that people had no clue who she was before other than the lady who reported the casey anthony stuff on GMA during the trial. I honestly think that if there were more peoplel ike Nancy out there who were not affraid to speak their mind and never waver from what is right the world would be a better place.
Maybe it’s time to replace all or some of the judges. Carrie Ann’s scores are strange. She thinks with a part of her body that most women don’t have. Len is just downright grumpy every week. Bruno is just rude.
The bright spot of the show is Tom trying to keep all out war from breaking out.
And by the way, after learning what Kim Kardashian did last night on twitter, I hope they ban the whole K clan from the audience.
Watched on DVR the show last night. Maks needs to go with Hope. Man, I like Bope but DWTS is making me not like her more and more. So it’s best she go so I can still like as she keeps playing soccer for us. Max,Sorry dude, i like you but sometimes your just to much for me.Your ego is too much this season. Since it’s his show as his said no wonder his brother is almost in every pro number this season. Take him too.Hope if your back again next season Maks hope I see you in better mind and ease with yourself.I loved Jr and Karina’s dance along with Ricki and Derek those two hope are the in finals. I gotta say also liked Nancy and Tristan. Tristan is so cute!Hope they get to stay another week.Does anyone know if maybe they would get the encore? or Jr or Ricki? The group dance wasn’t all that it felt like a kiddie dance number but the kids would have done it much better. It wasn’t up to par as in season 4 and 5 but hey this season doesn’t have the best dancers so it what it is.
This is weird, I am definitely not in the right place here, as there are no Hope and Maks fans.
Natalie,
Yes, one person who agrees with me though! I think what Maks did totally got Hope and Maks closer as a team and they showed chemistry and connection. Something was different this week, in a good way, and Hope said she finally learned what you need to do to dance. I hope they are still here next week so we can see them with a better dance. I am certain now, though, that they are friends and will continue to be. (Again, I would say look at their interviews, Twitter, and just pictures of them hanging out, if you have time.)
Jay,
The 2007 World Cup situation is a complicated one. Hope was right and wrong at the same time. Like Maks was last night! She said what everybody was thinking and it was right, but not in the best way. The coach Greg Ryan got fired, and Hope Solo is currently the best female goalkeeper in the world.
She and Maks are a lot alike, that’s how I KNOW they get along. It’s pretty impossible in my opinion to not get along with someone who is really just like you.
Also, I will say again, I really liked Hope and Maks’ dance last night. Was it perfect? No, but it had a connection and I saw and felt that yesterday. I like them as a couple and want to see them dance again.
I am not a Maks fan but im glad he said something. Im so tired of the judges being negative week after week with Hope! Its one thing to say “work on”, to say you did this wrong and work on this.
Yet you have them ‘praise’ Chaz every week for TRYING! So frustrating!!!!
I am not a Maks fan but im glad he said something. Im so tired of the judges being negative week after week with Hope! Its one thing to say “work on”, to say you did this wrong and work on this.
Yet you have them ‘praise’ Chaz every week for TRYING! So frustrating!!!!
Also want to add: even what was wrote is exactly what im saying. Chaz is inspiring so he should stay and that’s why the judges are so goody w/ him. Hope could easily be inspiring to others as well representating her country in soccer, etc.
@Mr/Ms Awesome – I don’t know that I agree with you 100%, but I am a Maks and Maks and Hope fan. I have my opinions on what went down last night but I’m not engaging in the discussion because I dont’ want to end up with my blood pressure skyrocketing and tears and recriminations et al. I have a difficult time with the way some things are expressed, you see. 🙂 My problem.
BUT… I totally think that Maks is the right dance coach for Hope and I don’t think the majority of people questioning it know what the hell they’re talking about. Yes, there’s tension between them, but I think in this case it’s normal. I also think that Hope is unlike anyone else that’s been on the show, personality-wise and people don’t quite know how to take her. She is difficult to feel an affinity for, for a lot of people. But I’m certain that Maks ‘gets’ her. 🙂
Soccer, correction. I’m a Maks fan. But, I can be a fan and still agree and disagree when I want with him. I don’t have to like his partners either always. I’m not saying I don’t like Hope. At the same time, she’s probably my least favorite of all of his partners.
I like Hope and think she got a raw deal being partnered with frustrated Maksim.
I also like Maks but I don’t think he’s a good teacher which, paired with his stubbornness and ego, leads to situations like this one.
Actually, a few of the pros aren’t really good teachers IMO. Apparently that is not high on the priority list for choosing a dwts pro. At least they lucked out with Tristan who, so far, seems to be the patient and supportive kind.
I don’t think Hope could do anything to make Len happy, no matter what he says. And Bruno really was rude to Chaz. I think that the judges have decided that it is time for Chaz to go, fan base or not.
Here’s a suggestion for TPTB. Have a season where the contestants are top finishers from past seasons. Not winners but other top finishers. That way there would be some great dancing and people with similar, established fan bases. Might give a viewership boost, since it’s looking like it’s starting to drop off a bit.
Well, I don’t post on here too often, so it took me some time to see this, but I’ve figured out that this is mostly a place where if you’re a Derek fan, you would probably get along a little bit better! Don’t know how else to say it!
I like Derek, but since I am only watching this show for Hope, I have to go for Hope and Maks. I have started to like Maks because of this show, and one thing that is cool with me is when people are real. That’s what you get with Hope and that’s what you get with Maks. If Hope was Derek’s partner, obviously I would be talking about how he gets along with Hope.
My opinions look like they are unpopular here, but just get the feeling a lot don’t like Hope because she’s with Maks, who a lot here don’t like. Hope is actually very personable and has a great personality. Her interviews, Twitter, personality in games would show you that, so I don’t get all the negative opinions about her to be honest.
I like Chaz, and think his journey has been great, but it would be the weirdest thing if Hope goes before him. Don’t they have team dances next week? I just feel like his story was there at the beginning when he kept going through each week, but now it’s kind of not as strong. I don’t think it makes sense to compare him to Bristol because they were totally different on the dance floor. At this point, I just don’t really understand anybody leaving before he does. I will say that if Hope and Maks go, especially with all this drama, Hope’s dancing being talked about and shown on ESPN (an ABC partner company)… this show will lose like 85% of its viewers, in my opinion. I just hope they can dance again next week!
Soccer, your opinions are unpopular here (or atleast starting to be unpopular here?) because all you talk of is Hope and you are being intolerant expecting us all to like her and only see her from your point of view. Once again, I’m a huge Maks fan. This isn’t just a Derek site or I wouldn’t be here.
As people have told you more than once, Soccer, there are plenty of people here who aren’t Derek fans. They have told you they are Maks fans. They’ve also told you that they don’t automatically agree with everything Maks does or says just because they’re Maks fans. If a whole bunch of people don’t agree with you, they aren’t automatically Derek fans. They just don’t agree wtih you. Period. Don’t blame it all on people randomly hating Maks – that’s kinda immature.
Maks had pretty much gotten back in everyone’s good graces up till last night and right now, I actually like Hope IN SPITE of Maks. So there you go.
Oh, and by the way, the ratings for this season thus far are approximately 15% LOWER than what they were last year at this time – so, your estimation of Hope’s ratings draw are severely over estimated.
LOL at DWTS losing 85% of their viewers if Hope goes. Come on. Ridiculous.
I like Maks a lot – in fact I love all the pros to varying degrees, with Tony being my least favorite of the bunch (but I don’t wish him ill or anything, he’s just not even in the same league for me as the others). Everyone else – love em. That doesn’t mean I always like their celebrity partners. I don’t care for Hope (and I’m an athlete too), just like I didn’t LOVE Jennifer Grey when she was with Derek (although I sorta like her, just not as much as his other partners). There are lots of Derek fans here, but there are plenty of Maks fans as well. I think what people are irritated with is how you seem to have this unyielding adoration of everything Hope, and how you seem to interpret things way differently than most of the people here – regardless of whether they are fans or not. Plus it’s comments like the 85% stuff that make your point of view seem ever so slightly delusional. I’m sure you are a nice person and it’s great you are so passionate about one person on the show – but no one likes when ANYONE is so far up someone’s butt that they can’t see the rest of the world.
I wish people would stop being so mean i love every dancer on the show and some of these comments are mean so if u don’t have any thing NICE to say PLEASE don’t say anything at all and hope and maks r the best and she is so tried of these comments i know because she said it on the show i wish i was as pretty as her and i also wish i could dance like her so those judges should really stop being so mean when they are trying so very hard to get those steps and it is hard to learn a dance in one week and there dances are very hard to learn and i wish those’s judges could just see and know how hard EVERYONE of those dancers are working i know that it is hard because i am in two dance classes and it is really hard for me to learn all of those dances in one week and i also really like hope because she looks like my ballet teacher and she can dance so just stop commenting bad about people it hurts there feelings really bad and it hurts mine also to see those amazing dancers cry and be crushed how would any of you like to be talked about where the hole world could see?! And i wish one day i can be on DWTS.Go HOPE AND MAKS me and all of my friends will vote for you every monday night so thats 17 more votes for you twoo and i will try to get more people to vote for you I hope that you read this hope because I want to meet you! -Tuesday 🙂
Wow Tuesday use a period or two and I might actually read what you wrote.
Ok, just read everyone’s comments now, getting a better idea! That was kind of funny! I guess I am a huge Hope fan, but I play soccer, so that makes sense at least!
What it is honestly is that I know a lot of you may not be familiar with Hope, so some comments that are so off base, I guess I just feel like I have to say how it really is. Mostly it’s just personality things.
Like if I said Maks is not funny, if I didn’t know any better. Most people on here would tell me, actually Maks is really funny. It’s just about not really understanding a personality because editing does not always show that. Only people who are familiar with the person know a little bit more of their personality. I think I can pretty much say that there aren’t many people here who are familiar with Hope’s personality. That’s all I’m saying. I don’t regularly watch DWTS, so I can’t say I’m familiar with Derek’s personality. I’d probably have to listen to some interviews, and so on.
I get all the comments about Maks fans!
Soccer is Awesome–I think it’s sweet how you always stick up for Hope/Maks (though it is often a bit long) and I feel your frustration about there seeming to be fewer Maks fans here.
I’m a Maks fan and no matter what shenanigans he gets up to, I’m always sad when he and his partner get voted off the show. But a lot of the criticism he comes in for is, IMO, deserved. I think he’s probably not the best teacher. I wish he’d take Hope as she is and not try to make her his idea of a SEXY woman. He’s hotheaded.
This site probably seems so Derek-centered because even the non-fans (like myself) can still see what a good job he does with his celebs and how well he dances/choreographs. Besides that, he’s seems quite clever about how the show works and uses all the elements to his/his celebrity’s best advantage.