DWTS 14 Week 3 Power Rankings
Well thanks to the majority of tonight’s performances, I now have red, puffy eyes and a runny nose – and no, the show did not give me a rhinovirus 
Even though I tell myself I’m not going to, I still get verklempt each season when personal story week rolls around, and end up a big, blubbering blob of hormones that is willing to overlook some pretty glaring technique errors and overall mediocrity & lack of content :-P
Tonight, however, I refuse to overlook to continual over/underscoring and favoritism by the judges, and what I felt to be a rather contrived display of emotion on one individual’s part. Shall we get to it?
1.) Katherine & Mark – I always find myself without a whole lot of notes on these two. What more can I say, other than that she’s beautiful, a great dancer, and an overall likeable person? Thought Katherine danced a lovely waltz, and it’s becoming clear to me that the ballroom dances are really going to be her forte, and perhaps the rumba as well – any dance where she can really show off that posture and those gorgeous arms. Was there a lot of actual waltz steps in this one? Well, no, but on the whole, I don’t think anyone had a TON of real content and syllabus steps in their routines tonight…so I guess I really can’t fault anyone too much for that. With the points spread being relatively close tonight, I can’t say for sure that ANYONE is truly safe…but I think Katherine is probably safe this week. I think she is growing her fanbase, and seems to have kept Mark relatively calm this season. I enjoy watching these two dance
2.) Donald & Peta – I don’t think they had the best routine of the night (or even the best rumba), but man – Donald is endearing himself to pretty much EVERYONE, myself included I don’t think I’ve heard a single unkind word about the guy from any of the regulars here, and the fact that he has managed to go from dancing 3rd, to dancing 10th, to getting the pimp spot in 3 weeks tells me that he is proving to be a force to be reckoned with - he’s probably pulling in quite a few votes. And I do see him improving each week – I love that he devotes himself 100% to his performance each week, and is a joy to watch, but the guy is legitimately improving as well…his arms, legs, hips, and posture have all gotten noticeably better with each week. And I think if last season was any indicator, we shouldn’t underestimate the ones that slowly & steadily improve each week, as they’re the ones that could sneak into the finale out of nowhere…I think I’ve finally decided that he is indeed our dark horse this season Watch out, Katherine, William, Jaleel, & Maria!
3.) William & Cheryl – Grrrr….I can’t believe we’re in week 3 and the over-the-top tongue bathing is still going! This was an ok-to-moderate salsa – I wouldn’t say it was stellar and I wouldn’t say it was bad, either. But a 28??? C’mon, one point less than the top scorer, who did one of the best waltzes I’ve seen on the show to date???! I don’t get it…I just don’t get it. William doesn’t miss steps, and he stays on time; but I also feel like he never truly gets into the dance, and always dances so apprehensively, like he’s afraid he might hurt himself. Cheryl needs to take time out from her busy schedule of designing atrocious costumes from herself and actually bring him out of his shell a bit more, and work on his range of motion. Luckily for them (and not so luckily for us), I don’t think they’re going anywhere anytime soon, with all the judges blindly worshipping his every step. Ai ai ai.
4.) Maria & Derek – Who knew that the world’s most awkward almost-kiss could make my list of most memorable moments in tonight’s episode? 
I’m still trying to figure out what exactly happened (and some interesting screen shots have surfaced on Twitter)…but I’ll save further speculation for the cheese 
I thought these two generated the most heat in their rumba (which I guess is to be commended, since the rest of the rumbas tonight seemed to be of the weepy, “I see dead people” variety), and I think Maria has got the most gorgeous legs we’ve seen on a female contestant since…well I don’t know. Not too keen on the song, but I do give them props for attempting a risky arrangement of it. Overall, I think the buzz of “Did they kiss or didn’t they kiss???” could fuel them through next week…but overall, a sexy rumba to watch
5.) Roshon & Chelsie – Hmmmm. I’m not sure what to make of these 2…this was a cute samba, and as always, I loved Roshon’s energy. But like Len, I’m not sure that the samba steps really meshed well with the Jackson 5 moves they threw in, and the overall result was kinda disjointed and perhaps got lost in the shuffle. These running order positions don’t seem to be doing them a ton of favors, either – 5th, 1st, and 4th? Yikes. I’m starting to genuinely fear that Roshon could be a surprise elimination – if not this week (and it is possible, kids – he’s only got 1 point more than the 5 couples tied for last), then within the next few weeks, unless he starts playing to the judges a bit more, and gets at least one shot at dancing in the 2nd half of the show. It sucks, because I do think Roshon is one of the most talented celebs they have this season – but he just can’t seem to connect to the audience in the same way some of the other celebs do. Maybe he’ll start to stand out more as we eliminate a few more celebs – I hope. I don’t think he deserves to go home yet.
6.) Gladys & Tristan – Sorry Gladys fans, but this week seemed like yet another reminder that Gladys is 67, and not 27. Like her quickstep, this just seemed sooooo sloowwww…and like many of the other contestants, I don’t think Gladys ever lost timing or missed a step, but none of what she did had a ton of impact, either. Everything just felt like a leisurely stroll, and I’m afraid that’s what the majority of her ballroom dances are going to look like – I hope they give her a Latin dance next week, because I have yet to see the same fire from her that we saw in her cha-cha in week 1. I can’t really blame Tristan – the guy is probably limited in his choreo by what Gladys can feasibly handle. I think Gladys just needs another sassy Latin dance – and fast – if she wants to stick around past the next couple of weeks. I really hope she does, because I do really enjoy watching her dance and really enjoy herself.
7.) Jaleel & Kym – Yeah, those high hopes I had for Jaleel & Kym at the beginning of the season? Not so high anymore 
Rumors of their alleged blow-up during their rehearsal on Friday notwithstanding, I just seemed to a very strange vibe from Jaleel this week – I don’t think he was 100% committed to his rumba (which was ok, but not great), and the crocodile tears in the celebraquarium while getting his scores were simultaneously off-putting and confusing to me…just seemed like a desperate ploy for sympathy on a night where everyone else’s routines were kinda emotional and his…really wasn’t. I’m still not quite sure what the message was behind his rumba, other than “Yeah, I’m a cool dude!”, but I do think Jaleel is seriously starting to run the risk of putting off viewers if he keeps up with this erratic behavior I’m seeing from him. I think he ought to be ok for this week, as some of the “forgotten” cast members get the boot, but he has got to find his groove, and his connection with his partner & the audience…and FAST.
8.) Sherri & Val – If William’s overscoring frustrates me the most, then Sherri’s overscoring is a close 2nd. By far the weakest rumba of the evening for me – she seemed to get too caught up in the emotion of it, and consequently didn’t move a whole lot and seemed to miss a few steps. Yet she still ties with 4 other routines that I found to be much more energetic & entertaining than hers. *shrug* I give up. Sherri seems nice enough, and she does tend to make me laugh – but her performance value (and technique) have both deteriorated since week 1 for me – she needs to really crack down and learn to dance. And the judges need to stop coddling her – it’s going to be a rude awakening when they finally start scoring her like they should have from day 1.
9/10.) TIE: Melissa & Maks and Jack & Anna - The former still seems really nervous, and like she’s not improving; the latter just doesn’t seem to get much love from the judges, and seems to get a bit too excited at times. Who’s in more danger of heading home? Idk. My gut says Jack, but Melissa is one big question mark for me – and I’m not sure she’s a question mark that Maks’ fans can overcome with power voting. I actually welcomed Melissa’s jive with open arms - it was a nice reprieve from all the slow, heavy dances we saw tonight; but while I enjoyed the opening sequence, I have to point out that there wasn’t a ton of real jive steps in her routine – and those that she did have? Not a whole lot of bounce there, I’m afraid And then there’s Jack – a guy I see improving each week, and that can actually handle real ballroom technique really well, and still play to the audience and enjoy himself, all at the same time. He seems to get a little over-excited, and his technique suffers a bit as a consequence; but the judges don’t seem to be cutting him the same breaks they do Sherri or Gavin, and I do worry that he’s getting lost in the shuffle. Which sucks, because I really like Jack I’m giving him all of my votes this week, just because I don’t think he deserves to leave just yet, and I know I can’t rely on the judges to actually score him fairly. Let’s hope I’m just being paranoid about him heading home!
11.) Gavin & Karina – Yes, this rumba was indeed an improvement from last week; but compared to other routines we saw tonight, I just don’t feel like he moved much, and seemed more preoccupied with staring intently at Karina while awkwardly stroking her face. I do think he is starting to (finally!) really open up to the audience, but I’m wondering if it’s too little, too late. He’s in a 5-way tie for the lowest score, and he’s the only one there this week that we know for a fact has been in the bottom 2 before. He also danced in one of the “doom” positions tonight. Then again, next week is rock week – will his fans rally & keep him around for one more week, so he can dance to something more in his wheelhouse? I’m gonna guess no – even though I’m not at all confident in that guess, because if he doesn’t go home – then someone I really like might go instead (I’d be fine with Sherri or William getting the boot at this point – but we know that ain’t happenin’!). Thus, I tentatively lock in my vote for elimination as Gavin – with a slight possibility of Jack or Roshon as the “surprise” elimination. Sorry, Karina…no MBT repeat for you, I’m afraid
So what did you guys think of tonight’s show? Did you cry as much as I did? Who do you think will head home? Who’s ready for some more cheesecake?
I definitely agree with you about Roshon being a shock elimination! Could see that tomorrow possibly. Anyone else shocked that there was a five way tie at the bottom for 24 in week THREE? :O
Excellent as always Court!! Here are my rankings….
Donald and Peta – OMG! I just loved these too sooo sooo much. They were passionate, gorgeous, beautiful, emotional, and theatrical. Loved their facial emotions. Love the sharp, dramatic movements. Powerful and just stunning! 10+++
Mark and Katherine – These two were emotional, beautiful, elegant, and so heartfelt. She’s such a delight to watch. 10++
Derek and Maria – They were sexy and so beautiful. My only complaint is the slow version of Material Girl which had me cringing at times. Other than that, pure perfection. 10-
Gavin and Karina -I can’t believe I’m doing this, but, I’m putting these two in 4th tonight. Much much better. Gavin was totally into it, sexy, and full of natural swagger just like Karina said he would be. He can stay in this thing if he wants and if he wants to work hard. 9
Roshon and Chelsie – They could have used some more Samba moves like Len said. Other than that, very entertaining and a great tribute to MJ. 9
Val and Sherri – Like Carrie Ann, I didn’t think she could pull off a more serious and emotional dance, but, she did and I felt it. Very smooth too and beautiful. 8+
William and Cheryl – They were ok, but, they didn’t wow me like in the past weeks. I’m a little disappointed. I really thought this would be his dance. I thought his legs were off and stiff at times. Also, why did Cheryl have to wear the same colors again?
8
Jack and Anna – No matter what, these two are always like a breath of sunshine. Jack could easily be a Broadway dancer. Lots of improvement. His best dance to date. 8
Jaleel and Kym – While smooth and “cool”, I felt disconnected. Too much “cool” I think? I wasn’t sure what to make of the emotion and what he said in the skybox with Brooke and if he’s genuine? I just don’t know what to think of him anymore?? 8-
Maks and Melissa- This dance felt just strange to me. First it started out like a rumba and then went into a Jive. She was stiff and lost through out it again. 7
Gladys and Tristan – It pains me to put these two last since I love them both so much. She was so elegant and she was much better than last week, but, she has issues with her legs and feet. 7
I look forward to everyone’s thoughts. And I am especially looking forward to Heidi’s numbers post again tomorrow.
And Court, I am so ready for cheesecake again. I also wanted to add that I think Melissa might be going home.
Hola!!!! I love your web site
I always get the news from DWTS here…congrat !!!!.I love it… I just want to say that I love William and Cheryl and for those who dances salsa ( like me LOL ) cause im latin too..I have to say they danced a good salsa William was right with the cuban spice movements and the steps…I like the choreography also…my also 2nd favorite are are Katherine, Maria, and Donald…
Have a good night everybody !!!!!
I am worried about Roshon and voting like crazy. That’s one way to get ratings on the result show, having such close scores. I wished he had done 1980′s Michael, oh well. Loved Maria/Derek and Peta/Donald too. Peta’s dress was gorgeous.
w0w, just wow!!
Here’s my top 3:
1.) Katherine
2.) Maria
3.) Donald
Thanks guys!!
As much as I loved Donald and Peta tonight I’m so irritated that CAI didn’t call them out for the lift(s)! A female celeb would never get away with it.
I’m not a fan of Madonna, but I actually loved the slowed down version Maria and Derek used – and that rumba was HOT!
Vogue thanks, totally agree w/you about Gavin’ Rumba tonight.!!!
Ok wo> Yes, a lot of the stories had me in tears. Damn it. Derek and Maria’s dance was beautiful. I love Gladys, but yeah, she’s 67 and isn’t going to be there in the finals.
I love Jack and how much fun he’s having.
Sherri does not and never did do it for me. While her story was moving, I sure didn’t think it was a fabulous dance.
Melissa is trying to hard and it shows.
Roshon also doesn’t do it for me and I wouldn’t be surprised to see him go either.
Katherine. Nice dance, but 10″s? Really. Not so much.
jaleel. While the emotion might have been over contrived, I’m giving him the benefit of the doubt this week. I think the emotion came from a couple of weeks of bad press some deserved, some not. He got a few of my votes.
I’m not saying anything about William other than I don’t think it was the best salsa I’ve ever seen. And seeing his chest really doesn’t make any difference to me. Perhaps I’m just getting old.
For me, the highlight was Gavin. He wasn’t the best by a long shot, but he gets most improved in my book. So he got the rest of my votes because I want to see if he can keep it up.
My favorite dances:
Katherine and Mark- Love the song, story, and the way they dance. My favorite to win!
Maria and Derek – Love the choreography! Their partnership has yet to excite me though.
Donald and Peta: My favorite male to win. They too have great partnership and connection.
William and Cheryl- I expected it to be great and they didn’t disappoint. I’d like to see him rumba!
Jaleel and Kym – I did like their dance, it was smooth and had some swag like Stefan but I think outside distractions threw their partnership off. I still like him to stick around.
Gavin and Karina – Most improved! I’ll give him up to Week 5 to stay.
Wasn’t to crazy about Melissa and Maks’ jive and their partnership doesn’t hold my interest.
They’re my choice to leave.
Thanks Courtney! Couldn’t wait to see your ratings! I was just so taken with Maria and Derek’s sensual amazing dancing tonight, I can’t see how anyone else beat them in scoring. Katherine was great, but I agree with Len. There wasn’t much actual waltz in it and Marks just annoys me for doing it. I thought Gavin did much better tonight and when all is said and done, I think it should be Melissa that goes home for her awkward jerky dancing. However, I think Maks’ fans and her Little House fans will keep her around a while longer. I hate to say it, but I think it will be Gavin saying good-bye tomorrow night.
Love the rankings!! Thanks for getting them up before I go to bed.
Thanks for the rankings!!!
Did I see Chelsie give Roshon a little “love” spank as they were hugging at the end of the dance?
I thought it was really interesting how 5 of the 11 couples tied for last and only 5 points separate first from last. Really keeps things interesting! I, for one, voted for Maria and Gavin. Maria’s technique really impressed me and, IMO, was almost as good as Katherine’s. And the chemistry she has with Derek was nice to watch. I thought Gavin improved a lot and I thought his story was really sweet. I actually don’t think he’ll be in danger of elimination, well, not this week at least. I think that his story might have gotten him a few more votes to edge into safety, and since he’s tied for last, all he really needs is one more vote than at least one of the other four to be safe. I think Melissa might be going or maybe Jack. I like them both, but they each seem to fade into the background to me. But then again…who knows! If Katherine’s, William’s, Maria’s, or Jaleel’s fans get too comfortable, it could be them going. I can’t wait for tomorrow!
Jaleel has really turned me off from the start. I wanted to like him but there’s something so offputting about him – and the contrived display of emotion only further sealed the deal. This was even before I read the thing about the alleged confrontation with Kym. He’s one of the few on the show – ever – that I’ve really disliked. I’d rather have him go home than anyone else.
All my votes went to Jack and Anna. I don’t get the judges and their scoring (ever…) and he doesn’t get any love. 24 is about right, but against some of the others, not so much. He was head and shoulders above Gladys but same score. It’s strange, it’s like the judges don’t know how to score middle aged men – kurt, ralph, now jack….
And Anna isn’t helping things with all the brown and yellows. ick. Put the man in some tight black pants and a half opened white, silver or black shirt. please…..
Yeah Jaleel was really strange tonight & the minute he started crying, oh god that seemed so fake & like he was trying to get emotion from something not that emotional.
I will stand by my belief that the Final 2 will be……William & Katherine…….the 2 least known celebs. lol
Also I just adore how sweet Mark has been with Katherine, the way he held her tonight in that Waltz at the start & end was adorable, did not like dark Mark the last few years so this is a breath of fresh air!
Also they have tons of chemistry & what an amazing connection on the dance floor!
I loved that Derek pushed it tonight with the floor activity. Everyone was holding their breath.
I predict Gladys will go home next.
I just don’t get the over hyping of William. It’s like TPTB and the judges REALLY want Cheryl to get another mirror ball trophy. Same goes with Mark and Katherine. Don’t get me wrong, Katherine is a fine dancer, better than William by far, but I don’t think she’s good enough to get 10′s this early in the game. Frankly, I don’t think anyone is, but when you start out getting 9′s in week 1 right off the bat, then I guess that’s what happens.
Anyway, for me, the bottom 3 would be Jack, Gavin, and Roshon. Jack because I completely forgot about him by the time the show was over (and I do like him and Anna and think they’re cute), and Gavin and Roshon because their stories just didn’t hold my interest. When you have these amazing stories about people overcoming obstacles or dancing for their loved ones, and then you just do a story about the time you saw your favorite singer perform..it’s sort of “so what” to me. In any case, I think it’s too little too late for Gavin, and he will be the next to say goodbye.
And I forgot to add that I agree that it’s wonderful to see sweet, happy Mark back after moody, dark Mark had been around for so long.
One guaranteed shortcoming of personal story week is that there’ll be rampant overscoring, especially in a season already laden with it. IMO, most every pair should’ve been at least one point lower than the highest number they received. Anyway, my thoughts and safety rankings for this week:
1) Katherine – Totally related to her story, emotion, song and dance. Agree with Len that I would liked to have seen more Waltz content, particularly in hold, but only because she is such an exquisite Ballroomer. As an aside, whoever performed that song did an admirable and I’m picky when it comes to Josh Groban.
2/3) Donald – Another seriously invested and likeable footballer with dance talent and fan base.
2/3) William – Would’ve liked to seen as much Salsa from him as from Cheryl. In a rare departure from Court, I think he’s actually one of this season’s most natural out there in a relaxed/less cerebral way.
4) Maria – Those lines, that emotion, the chemistry. Superb though coulda done without that ackward arrangement of “Material Girl.”
5) Jaleel – Interesting he was the only one Len gave any/an honest critique to. Wasn’t a fan of this song with this dance either.
6) Roshon – More actual Samba needed. Talented though he may be, he’ll get fewer passes on hip hop going forward.
7) Sherri – Heavy on emotion but short on hip movement and fluidity.
8) Melissa – A bit more relaxed with a couple nice moments, but still not feeling her, the dancing or the partnership on this one. The PMSers will assure that no partner of Maks ever finishes worse than 6th in this competition.
9) Gladys – While I adore each her and Tristian, I see a continued pattern of poor posture and speed.
10/11) Gavin – An improvement tonight. I find him at least as interesting as Jack, Melissa, and maybe Gladys, so I’d like to see him last a bit longer, but have serious concern about that.
10/11)Jack – The male version of Melissa but without a pro of groupie power voters. His story most surprised me though, so maybe that’ll count for something.
–I loved Maria and Derek’s rumba! This was her best by far — very fluid. And I thought the slow arrangement of Material Girl was quite nice.
– I totally agreed with Len about Mark’s choreography — where was the waltz? I was looking forward to a classic waltz by Katherine because she would have definitely killed it!
–I actually thought Melissa’s dance was pretty good! Athough I think I have to agree with others that perhaps she will be going home soon, if not tomorrow.
–But what was with Len’s 10 for Wililam’s salsa? I love William, but that was not 10 material. I think the judges want to keep him around for ratings purposes.
–Jack: I just like him and want to see him stick around.
– Finally, the band and vocalists: Are they the best or what? Every week I’m floored with what they do.
@SueB, I also noticed the “no-love” thing with Sugar Ray. 3/4 were Anna’s partners. Maybe SHE’S the one not getting any love from the judges. She’s one of my favorite pros, and I can’t figure out why that would be true. At least Jack hasn’t been completely slammed by the judges like the others (including Ralph)…yet…
Gave all my votes to Sherri/Val and Gavin/Karina. These two touched my heart with their words and their dancing.
“Cheryl needs to take time out from her busy schedule of designing atrocious costumes from herself and actually bring him out of his shell a bit more”
LOL That was perfect!
I think Jaleel’s dancing has been flat the last 2 weeks. The emotion in the skybox also seemed fake to me. Maybe I am just being cynical.
Gavin improved, but I think he mainly posed while Karina danced around him. I think he may go home this week.
Gladys is classy, yet boring. I think she got overscored this week.
Roshon is a great dancer. I think he should have had more of the samba steps, though.
I really enjoyed Melissa’s dance. She seemed to be having fun, and Maks is giving her some tough choreography. I hope she stays a bit longer.
Sherry is another one that was overscored tonight.
Jack is good, but I tend to forget about him.
Loved Derek and Maria!
Katherine/Mark and William/Cheryl were good, but I can’t wholeheartedly support them yet. They have been “pimped” so much that it rubs me the wrong way.
An enjoyable episode this week.
I didn’t think there were any terrible dances, but there were ones that were awkward and stiff. What made my night though was William dancing to “La Vida es un Carnival.” That’s one of my favorite songs from my childhood and I supposed my nostalgia made my a bit biased towards his dance. 
And every time Tom mentions Peta, I can’t help but think of Peeta Mellark from The Hunger Games. Sue me.My review of the night:
Jack and Anna – Samba – Probably his best dance yet! I loved his energy and love towards his daughter and the night was fantastic for him. I still don’t think he deserved to be in the bottom but its a close competiton! Score well deserved
Maria and Derek – Rumba – WOW!!!!! omg I freakin loved this dance and my favorite dance of the season so far! There chemistry was spot on and I still think they kissed! haha but her Technique was amazing and I swear this deserved atleast one or two 10s! Wow! Cannot wait til next week!!!
Gladys and Tristan – Foxtrot – I was really THRILLED with his dance. It was good but not capable of her ability! Bring up the cha cha energy again Gladys and rock it out! Score deserved like a 21 or 22.
Roshon and Chelsie – Samba – Complete and Utterly a MESS! I hated it. It was NOT a samba more like a freestyle dance. Really didn’t get the story. How can Michael Jackson be a story and most memorable year? Come on Roshon I’m a fan of you but not a fan of this samba. Score didn’t deserved 9′s or not even close to it! I predict he’s in jeopardy tonorrow or even the bottom 2.
Gavin and Karina – Rumba – Improvement on the last couple of weeks. But I’m sorry Karina I really don’t see you getting the MBT this year I’m afraid
Probably going home tomorrow night.
Katherine and Mark – Waltz – Loved he dance dedicated to her dad. But for me it slipped for me tonight
Really don’t think it deserved 10s right now. I kinda agree with len probably could of used a little more in hold but don’t worry she’s not leaving for a LONG time! Still love ya tho Katherine!
Sherri and Val – Rumba – It was an amazing tribute to her son. I can see she really cares about him and wanted to perfect the dance with Val. Her facial expressions was a little over the top but thats just me. Score well deserved.
Melissa and Maksim – Jive – UGH! Come on Melissa let it out!!!!!!!!!! I swear she is going to go home very very soon if she don’t put the time and effort into the routine it was a mess and not worthy of 8′s more like 7s.
Jaleel and Kym – Rumba – Improvement on last week. But I really didn’t connect with the dance. He need to improve his fluidy in his arms and finish the lines. And probably a little more connection with Kym. Take notes from Maria Menounos.
William and Cheryl – Salsa – Of couse Mr. Latin Hotty gets a 10 this week like I predicted. I admit it deserved 9s but not a 10 Bruno! Kinda stiff in places and hello did you almost see him fall towards the end of the routine and you still give him a 10. Thank god Carrie Ann took off a point for that and not falling for his looks. Can’t wait til this couple is eliminated. I’m sorry to say it but it’s the truth.
Donald and Peta – Rumba – I love this dance and this pairing! It was amazing! I loved it deserved about a 27 in my opinion!
Bottom 3:
- Gavin and Karina
- Melissa and Maks
- Roshon and Chelsie
Bottom 2:
- Gavin and Karina
- Melissa and Maks
Eliminated:
Gavin and Karina
BUT Top three for me tonight:
Hopefully no Latin Hotty in the top 3!
Katherine and Mark
Maria and Derek
Donald and Peta
* Hopefully their the top three in this competition. Great attidudes and everything they have the complete package! Go Katherine, Maria, and Donald!!!!
@ten — What do you mean their partnership hasn’t excited you yet? Did you see them tonight? Ummmm they kissed haha and this partnership is off the charts! They could be a couple but who knows. But their partnership is amazing.
So sick of all the William hype..and Cheryl is getting on my nerves (ps, how did she get so many followers on twitter? haha..is it a Kardashian thing?) I thought Derek and Maria were breathtaking..to me it was fairly obvious that they kissed..but maybe that was just my initial perception. Katherine is just beautiful too, though I am not the biggest Mark fan.
OMG!!!! This is like that half air kiss that Mark did with Bristol season 11 week 4. It was good for them because Bristol was terrible and all media talked about was if they were dating LOL. If a top dwts story from Monday night is if they kissed (D&M) then kudos to Mr. Hough —buzz, buzz, buzz!
The backstage videos are up on ontheredcarpet.com.
Jaleel and Kym were asked directly about the tabloid rumors and they offered a lot of non denials. They said things can get blown out of proportion but kept saying over and over again that it was a stressful week and things can happen. Kym seemed unfortable talking about it. It’s obvious something did happen.
I haven’t seen all the videos yet, so I won’t try to rank them.
I’m no ballroom dancer so I’m not able to judge technique in thoses dances but I’m a salsa dancer and this I can tell you, you may not like William, but this was the best salsa of all seasons. I have re-watched Gilles’ salsa to be sure, it was great, but it wasn’t as good as a salsa, eventhought Gilles was a far better dancer than William.
This salsa was the first 100% salsa we have seen so far (even Gilles’one, which was my favorite so far wasn’t a 100% salsa, the reggeaton music didn’t help for sure). Maybe it didn’t deserve a 10 because as Courtney said, it was a little bit cautious, but when you look back at the terrible “salsa” of season 12 who got amazing scores, it is not that overscored.
I found quite funny that, as a cuban guy, he would dance in colombian style and not in casino style, but it suits him and I was very pleased to find out that they choose “la vida es un carnaval” of Celia Cruz as I learned to dance salsa on this specific song.
It’s a long show when there are still so many couples. Rather like an endurance test to watch. The two big things for me? Cheryl’s costume and Jaleel’s shoes. Shoes first, no white shoes. Ever. Maybe the reason will come out in analysis but for now, no white shoes on a guy. Cheryl? I love her but I almost spit my drink out. The only thing missing was a la Austin Powers with machine guns in the bra. I’ve scheduled analysis.
There are screencaps of them with their mouths on each other – pretty sure that’s called a kiss.
Since they can’t even high five each other without missing, first Derek got her chin, but then it was all mouth.
Let’s see if the entertainment shows cover THAT. I’ve always said that Derek knows how to play this show. Of course, he’s been down before without kissing his partner so I think it was no hardship at all.
Jay, on Twitter I called it “Peep in bikini”. I’ll let Courtney tell you what she called it.
Or we’ll save it for the Cheese.
Wow, I really enjoyed tonight!
Some great dancing one again!
Katherine/Mark-This waltz was just stunning. Her arms and posture are fantastic and I too wish Mark would’ve gave her more in-hold content, because she is superb in ballroom hold. Other than that, this was worthy of at least one 10, probably two for me.
Donald/Peta-I really liked this dance! He was very vulnerable and that was nice to see. I think he also did pretty well technically. It still needs some polish, but he’s looking really good. Definitely a contender.
William/Cheryl-While I did enjoy this Salsa for the most part, I would’ve given it a 26 at most. He’s still a little stiff here and there and clunky. But he had fantastic rhythm and hip action. His best dance IMO. But a 10 Bruno?? No. Put your vajayjay away please, if CAI can do it for a moment, you can too
Roshon/Chelsie-While I loved the fun and energy of it, it kinda felt…well…clustered. I agree the MJ moves were well done, and the Samba steps that were in there were decent, the two just didn’t transition well. Hope he stays in though, because he’s a great dancer.
Gladys/Tristan-Gladys’s frame definitely improved and her arms were lovely. Now she just needs to work on igniting more in her ballroom. Of course, at 67, that’ll prove hard to do. I still love her and Tristan
Jaleel/Kym-I unfortunately am not feeling Jaleel at all anymore. He’s just not catching my interest. And that “crying” afterwards…ummm…okay. Kym looked fantastic as always though
Sherri/Val-I adored her story and all, but this wasn’t great. She could’ve used more hips and the faces she made kinda made me crack up at one point. That aside, she did really try and I really like her. But I wish they wouldn’t pimp her so much.
Melissa/Maks-I saw Melissa being more relaxed than ever this week! But I also think this Jive was a hot mess part of the time, some nice fun and energy in the other parts. Not sure what to say other than that I’m afraid :/
Jack/Anna-Jack is still a little stiff, but he’s definitely a good dancer. Full of rhythm and fun. And his story of finding his daughter? Amazing.
Gavin/Karina-Okay…I actually really liked this Rumba. (Don’t hit me!) A dramatic improvement for me. I actually saw some great movement and some nice hip action from Gavin. Another thing, is that he is genuinely improving as the weeks go on. And he’s opening up more and more. I’m really starting to like him. I just hope it isn’t too late
I can’t believe you forgot Maria! Bad sign?
I’m going out on a limb and saying Jaleel will go home. From all I’ve read, everyone has had the exact reaction I did to him; the dance was pretty entertaining but then he opened his mouth and turned us all off!!! So…I’m gonna say that that was enough to not get anyone really voting for him which is sad because Kym never looked more beautiful and the dance was pretty good but his overly dramatic, bizarre “Mickey Mouse” reference was just a little too much and it might just cost him?
Another night on DWTs that I enjoyed so very much. I am falling in love with Roshon and Chelsie, and a lttle out of love with Sherri. I hope she can get me back
1) Roshon and Chelsie. They got my votes. I loved their dance. The energy, the moves, the costumes, everything. They’re my favorites right now.
2) Maria and Derek. Whoa buddy. I couldn’t believe they pulled that off. It was just…awesome. There’s not much else to say. Rumba was definitely Maria’s dance, and I LOVED the slowed down Material Girl. Leave it to Derek to take a gamble like that and score a win. Impressive.
3) Katherina and Mark. Their dance was beautiful, but I enjoyed it the least of Katherine’s three dances so far. That said, I still loved it. And the emotion at the end, the way Mark comforted her, was very sweet. Like other, I am SO HAPPY Mark is back to old Mark and not cocky crappy new Mark anymore. It’s about dang time.
4) Donald and Peta. Their dance too was good, but I found myself getting distracted by the truly horrendous massacre the female singer did on One Sweet Day. My ears were hurting. Literally. So I didn’t watch them as closely as I did everyone else. I must say though, that I am warming to Peta.
5) Gladys and Trista. Gladys is just pure beauty and that Tristan–he knows how to treat a lady. I loved their dance and thought their song was awesome.
6) Jack and Anna. I didn’t know the song, and couldn’t catch a lot of the words. But I enjoyed watching them dance. Jack has a knack for performing (obviously). It’s fun to watch him.
7) Sherri and Val. I don’t know what that mess was, and y’all know I love me some Sherri. She didn’t seem to move too much, and the faces she was pulling? I know she was trying to look serious, and her story was extemely emotional. But the faces she was making as she danced made her look silly, and they were distracting. Still liking Val a lot though.
8) Jaleel and Kym. It was an okay dance. And I, too, thought his crying while getting his scores seemed WAY fake. I was worried I was the only one who would think so, so it was a relief to come here this morning and see similar reactions.
9) Gavin and Karina. He did much better this week, and I felt his emotion. He just isn’t as good as the rest of them.
10) Melissa and Maks. Same here. She’s trying hard and having fun, but IMO, she’s simply not as good as this group.
11) William and Cheryl. Over it. Both of them. And that’s all I have to say about that.
Did I hear Tom say Anna and Jonathan would be dancing tonight? If so, YES YES YES!
I agree Joan. I hate to say it, but, I hope Jaleel is on his way out tonight.
*Can’t wait for Miss Heidi’s numbers post.
Hola people!!! I’ve been able to watch Gladys, Maria, and Jack, so far ( Had a basketball game last night ) and Jack was so sharp, and precis, and FUN!! Not to mention an awesome story, Maria was BEAUTIFUL and I like the dance too
also loved her journey, Gladys is one of my favorites; This Foxtrot was clean and smooth and an improvment from last week plus Thats song wasn’t very Foxtrot-y ( Actually Buzz Aldrin and Ashly Costa danced a Cha Cha to that same song in season 10. Memories. 
) but nontheless and really good dance. I’ll post again when I see the other performances. 
What a night!!!!
Thought I’d throw in my 2-cents worth:
- Donald & Peta: WOW! He’s got the work ethic, he’s improving, and he has just the right attitude… it’s been said before on this site, you need “the whole package”. I think Donald has it.
- Maria & Derek: I was JUST. BLOWN. AWAY!!!!!! It was AWESOME! Beautiful dance, great execution…. crappy music, craptastic arrangement, but hey, the overall effect was incredible. They were robbed…
- Jack & Anna: Looks like Jack is having a ball, and I loved his story about his daughter. He’s not in the top tier dance-wise, but hopefully he’ll go a ways farther.
- Jaleel & Kym: Oh, boy. There’s trouble in Urkel-ville…
I’m really surprised that there wasn’t ANY footage from rehearsal. Based on the paparazzi footage I saw, *something* went down. Just hard to say what. I think the mods here are right; the tears were manufactured – at least I hope so. Otherwise, somebody should consider one of those “5150 holds” for Jaleel… 
- Sherri & Val: I’m sorry, but that was GROSSLY overscored, IMO. It wasn’t dancing, it was “vogueing” – clomping around and posing dramatically. She was going for dramatic, but for me, it was actually comedic – it was shy of a Lucille Ball routine, but was headed in that direction.
- Roshon & Chelsie: I was afraid he wouldn’t be able to keep the hippity-hoppity stuff out of the Samba. I know it was an MJ tribute, but it was a bad choice choreography-wise. Chelsie looked a little surprised when Len jumped on them for the choreo, I don’t understand why a pro would be surprised about it.
- Melissa & Maks: Melissa is trying, but it’s just not there. Personally, I think Maks is driving her too hard – the choreo is too complex, and she doesn’t have any chance to just enjoy it. She’s having to think too much, and is too nervous. Wouldn’t just kill me to see her eliminated tonight.
- William & Cheryl: OK, TPTB, we get it. He’s sexy. Understood, “Roger that”, message received, COMPRENDIDO…. NOW. PLEASE. MOVE. ON.
- Gladys & Tristan: I think Court put it best: Tristan is going to have to step up a notch from the “old lady choreography”. I know Gladys is 67, and she is a legend. But this is DWTS, and dancing is involved… for me, that wasn’t a foxtrot as much as it was a dose of “Visual Sominex”….
- Gavin & Karina: Who? They were on?
Like I said, just 1 opinion. Sorry for the length!!!!
Wee! My turn!
Jack & Anna – It was a good effort. I still feel like he’s got a lot to work on other than being a showman. I’m not really feeling him. I can’t connect with him. And my skeptical brain was like “Well how do you know she’s not scamming you?”…I kind of feel bad for thinking that actually. lol I think he’s safe, however.
Maria & Derek – Well Derek did it again. Bruno was right, that wasn’t easy to dance or choreograph to. But I have to be honest. My older brother was tweeting at me and texting me during her dance, so I was distracted. I was honestly expecting 10s from Bruno & CAI. I don’t know if I like her yet… Most definitely safe.
Gladys & Tristan – Okay. It was a sweet dance. I don’t know about other people, but I got a “prom”-y situation from the dance. It was better than last week, but not deserving of three 8s. I think it was more worth of three 7s. Maybe a 6…She’s probably safe due to being who she is (again).
Roshon & Chelsie – The only couple I felt was accurately scored last night. Literally, the only couple. It was a fun Samba. I knew Len was gonna knock him for not enough Samba content, but I was surprised when Carrie Ann agreed. I do think he’ll be safe.
Gavin & Karina – I didn’t see hips. At. All. Was it better than last week? Yeah, but again, not 24 worthy. More 22 is what I’m feeling. I’m not connecting with him either. And being in the bottom two in the first elimation does not bode well for the second.
Katherine & Mark – Well my golden girl did it again! Was it 10 worthy? My bias says “HELL YES!” My logic? It says more 3 9s. I agree with everyone when they say ballroom will be her forte. I side with Len: I like my waltzes with hold. It was a good American Smooth, but not waltz-y enough for me. But I still loved it.
Sherri & Val – I don’t care what anyone says, Sherri is one of my favorites. Maybe that’s just because I like Val…Anyway it was a good emotional dance. I do think it deserved an 8, but, again, not 3. I see this dance more of 21 or 22. But I love that she decided to talk about her son. I think she’ll be safe.
Melissa & Maks – Is it bad that I thougth she did better in the opening than her actual jive? She seemed stiff to me. I still voted for her, but I’m on the fence. I think she is safe as well, but she’s going to have to really blow me away in order for me to vote for her again.
Jaleel & Kym – I liked his Foxtrot. And that was about it. Jive was meh and this rumba was as well. I was turned off by his sobbing in the middle of his “interview” with Brooke. I thought he was faking it when he first started to be honest. The dance was okay. Probably more worth 24 than 25, but he’s safe.
William & Cheryl – I think Bruno might have locked in that 10 paddle the second Cheryl ripped open his shirt. Well, maybe not, considering it happened before any dancing started. It was okay. Again, I’m on the fence with William. Clearly, he can dance. He’s not awful…He’s just being “pimped” as everyone so calls it. His abs are what’s saving him, not his dance.
Donald & Peta – Probably my favorite rumba of the night, not the best, but yeah, I liked it a lot. Probably a point or two over scored, but I love this guy. He’s so sincere and he really does want to do well, I can see it. I definitely am calling him a Dark Horse. I think the “cheese heads” and a lot of other people are going to keep him safe tonight.
Now that I’ve slept on it, I wouldn’t be surprised if Jaleel ends up in the bottom three. His whole crying act up in the skybox was beyond fake and a bit psycho, to be honest. I still think Gavin’s going home though.
Why so many rumbas in one night? That and all the tear-jerking had me channel-surfing through most of the show. Lots of under-dancing and over-scoring. But I hope after this week the judges will settle down and get more serious about the actual quality/substance of the dances and stop with the favoritism. Katherine has been good so far, though we’ve yet to see her do a latin dance (but I wouldn’t be surprised if she’s good at that too). So far, she’s the only celeb I look forward to watching each week.
You can dance the lights out but if you’re off-putting it’s tough to overcome. Unless you’re Kate or Bristol. They were in the watch-for-a-train-wreck category, though. Unlike them, Jaleel can dance but he comes across as manipulative. Wonder if he got that from growing up in the entertainment industry?
And may I add how much I hate contrived showmances. It’s one thing if showmance rumors develop naturally (still irritating, but at least tolerable), but when the couple seems to be pushing for the rumors in order to get/keep attention, it turns me off even more than fake tears. And what’s worse is that this couple doesn’t need these rumors to get the scores from the judges or the votes from the viewing audiences. Just dance.
Okay here we go:
Jack and Anna – Ohhhh, Poor Jack, I want to enjoy his journey but man, he is making it hard for me to do that. I kind of have a feeling he may be in the bottom tonight. Just not memorable enough.
Maria and Derek – WOW, I didn’t see that one coming. These two were incredible.
Gladys and Tristan – My lucky leprechaun… Well he’s gonna need some luck if these two want to stay on. I love Gladys but loving Gladys isn’t going to keep her dancing shoes on much longer.
Roshon and Chelsie – Not feeling him. His dance was okay, the Afro was distracting, I just kept envisioning Kyle, and Kyle he ain’t….
Gavin and Karina – Yawn! Sorry but this partnership is boring. He did improve, but he is my pick to go home this week.
Katherine and Mark – I loved her story, my father has passed on, so it was very moving to watch. But nothing stands out with these two.
Sherri and Val – Didn’t like the song or the dance. I thought they played it safe.
Melissa and Maks – Okay, get out the pasties….
I thought we not only going to have nip slip but a whole boob slip… WOW, so distracting I barely saw anything else. And maybe thats a good thing.
Jaleel and Kym – I didn’t get it. The whole story behind the dance and I could feel some tension brewing. I think there is more trouble ahead for these two. If he keeps his mouth taped shut, they may last a few more weeks. IMO they can go right now. See-ya!
William and Cheryl – Actually I turned the channel when he came on, but I did watch part of his dance online this morning. Ripping the shirt off was as far as I got. TPTB Please Get Him off my Favorite Show ASAP…….
Donald and Peta – I *heart* Donald. As everyone probably already knows this is my favorite couple this season. Everything about this pairing just works. Donald has *IT*, he has what it takes to go all the way to the finals.
I worries Jaleel would be Ralph ( good first week only) and seems to be the case. But Ralpj ad an injury and judges picked on him. Jaleel seems to be self destructing.
I liked Katherine but not my favorite of her dances. The choreography was just pretty but nothing amazing to me. I am just left with pretty after her dance and do not remember anything else. I wish Mark gave her more in hold. Eh, I do not think he is nicer. Again, it is easy to be nice when your partner is good. I want to see he he treats his next Shannen or Melissa to see if he really changed.
I loved Donald and Maria. Really impressed by the choreography Derek put together. Pleasantly surprised by Peta’s costume. It was pretty and not too revealing.
I do think Roshon is vulnerable but I saw a lot of I voted for Roshon and Gavin on twitter. You never know.
I am looking forward to Heidi’s number post. I am predicting Melissa or Jack.
Overall, another great night of dancing.
So proud of Maria! Derek is doing an amazing job with her and she’s looking beautiful on the dance floor.They definitely have the chemistry to pull this routine of beautifully!
This was their best performance. So sexy, yet beautiful! Amazing choreography. I think the musical arrangement was gorgeous. A difficult piece to perform a Rumba to and they nailed it! I was certainly hoping for at least one 10. Anyhow, very pleased with Team Menough and overall great score. She’s getting better and better each week.
For me they are definitely top 3…
I pretty much enjoyed all the performances but Maria & Derek’s Rumba blew me away!-HAWT!!!
Forgot to say:
Derek & Maria listened to his fans, we asked for a sexy Rumba and boy did they deliver one!-Woohoo!!!!
Go Team Menough!!
at this point, i would fully support jaleel’s departure from the show. his dancing is fine, but he has a litany of questionable behaviors stacked against him – some proven and some alleged. for me, telling kym she had a “crazy eye” and the weird tears/mickey mouse speech were enough to warrant getting the boot. overall he has an air of cockiness about him that is unattractive. couple this with the allegations of anger management issues flying at him from left and right and i want him to go. they could be untrue, but what are they chances that both stories (regarding his ex and kym) stem from nothing precarious at all?
I think, except for Katherine, Donald, William, Maria – any one of the others could go home tonight….
As for Jaleel, I enjoyed this week 1. I feel like he is trying too hard, much too hard to overcome his “ghost” persona, what he is known for, and trying to be something or someone else so hard and it’s beginning to work against him. When the DWTS journey this early on becomes less than enjoyable for both the celebrity and the viewers – it shows, for his sanity and own personal well being I think maybe it would be good he goes home tonight.
Courtney, I know bi-polar as well – my father, you know what every tone, movement, sound represents, you know how to tiptoe and when to hide; you also hold onto the more “normal” moments for all they are worth because often they are fleeting and few.
With that said I respect your take and opinion, yet, I’m hesitant to use or say about anyone that I don’t know and interact with personally “bi-polar”. Whether true or not; it is a label – like it or not (as you well know) that is hard to live with…. but I do see where you see aspects of it and I truly hope there is no element of that particular disease rooted there. Its an ugly hard life as much for the person as it is for loved ones…. I’m preaching to the choir I know
Last night, was emotional in many ways – I thoroughly enjoyed the evening and very curious about the numbers and what it will take for favorites to stay in the competition….
I agree Mark was crappy to Melissa Joan Hart. But I thought he was fine with Shannen. And he had a good partner in Chelsea Kane. He was nice to HER that season, but he was generally a little putz. I’m not seeing any of that this time around.
Last night was really good and i only hated oen performance (and it was before i read the article about the confrontation in rehersals)
1) Gavin: LOVED IT. he offically is a contender in my book.
2) Donald: AWESOME and it deserved tens.
3) William: I usually hate his dances BUT this one deserved a perfect score. It was fun and he really looks like the one to beat.
4) Katherine: AWESOME dereved a perfect score.
5) maria: song was odd choice but it was great and they deserved at least one ten.
6) Sherri: It was great and she deserved 9s.
7) Jack: Dude is having a blast out there. He is going to go very far if he improves at this rate.
8) Roshon: Too much MJ but good perfromance.
9) Melissa: I hate the song but loved the dance.
10) Gladys: It was cute but overscored.
11) Jaleel: Hated the dance and hated the fact he had to outdo everyone with the emotion. That had to be fake. After reading the article on this site, I really hope he goes home.
Wow. I love this season! So many beautiful dancers, and last night, so many emotional stories. I was a teary mess for most of the night. I am going to be very sad to see anyone leave.
Maria and Derek: Holy cannoli, how hot was that? I loved the choreo, I loved her dress, I loved the kiss/near kiss/air kiss – whatever it was. I felt like I needed a cigarette after that dance – and I don’t smoke! Seriously, I thought that she looked like a goddess – beautiful lines, wonderful hip action. And I loved the music. The whole thing was just riveting.
Katherine and Mark: So much beauty! She seems to be a beautiful person – inside and out, and I love watching her dance. I appreciate how Mark lets her shine and complements her, rather than overdancing and stealing the spotlight as he has done in past seasons. Katherine is so graceful, so elegant, so lovely…my favorite so far this season, I think.
Donald and Peta: I just love this man. Such joy! He is a ray of sunshine and I thought their dance perfectly conveyed the emotion he wanted to express. I went through several tissues watching them on the dancefloor. I’m really impressed with Peta and her choreo.
William and Cheryl: I like him. He could be an arrogant ass, but he seems pretty down to earth. He is not pimping for votes – that’s Cheryl, and that really turned me off in the beginning. But, I loved their salsa – I think he has a ton of natural ability and loads of charisma – he pulls the audience in effortlessly. He is really fun to watch. And I thought Bruno was hysterical with his comments!
I like all the rest too, but these 4 stood out the most for me. And what the hell was Jaleel crying about? I couldn’t understand what he was saying. The whole scene was very awkward.
And on another note – I think Brooke is doing a much better job this season! She finally has the hang of it.
Sorry, but William Levy’s salsa was just awful. His foot work was too heavy. Stomping all over the place. Even Cheryl messed up. Way over scored. It seemed more like an 8.
Didn’t feel Jaleel’s story or danced. And that fake crying? really?
I liked Melissa. Great combination of rumba and jive. Can’t wait to see her do other dances. Maks is giving her complicated steps and she’s doing well.
Gavin, ugh! not much to say. He can go home.
Gladys, aside from being a very famous singer, she doesn’t do anything for me. Boring dance.
Sherri, over dramatic facial expressions. I thought she was in pain.
@Amanda – Well at least Cheryl finally got to rip off Williams shirt…. Good for her she got her thrill….. Now maybe I will get my thrill and watch William exit the ballroom, the sooner the better.
It’s funny about the stomping remarks re: William – that was the same thing I saw from Rob last season. Maybe a fault in Cheryl’s teaching?
Loved: Jack, Gladys, Gavin (who’s kinda my guilty pleasure).
Liked: Maria, Katherine, Melissa, Rochon, William (for the first time), Donald
Meh: Jaleel
Can leave now: Sherri. Please.
Will leave: it pains me to say it, but I see Jack getting the boot…
Twick – I’m afraid you’re right, but I’m hoping you’re wrong…
I’ve got the incense burning, and the Ouija Board fired up – with Sherri’s picture in the middle… 
@ Sandra777
I don’t think Gladys’ and Tristan’s showmance is that contrived!
Loved Donald and Peta, Derek and Maria, and William and Cheryl to a point. Gladys and Tristan took me back to a time when I would watch my mother and father dance. They loved Sam Cooke. I-tunes made a mint off of me after Gladys and Tristan danced. It reminded me of an innocence that existed back in the day.
[...] Had trouble as well, but said Gavin as well, with Jack or Gladys in the possible next [...]