DWTS Season 15: “All-Star” Possible Pairings
After last two weeks of polls
- Choosing favorite star from every season, then choosing your top twelve
- Choosing the top twelve professional dancers
Below are the pairings that I could put together based on the fact that they were together originally.
- Jennifer Grey / Derek Hough
- Sabrina Bryan / Mark Ballas
- Joey Fatone / Kym Johnson
- Apolo Anton Ohno / Julianne Hough
- Kyle Massey / Lacey Schwimmer
- Ralph Macchio / Karina Smirnoff
Below are the polls for the professional dancers w/ multiple celebrities:
Here are the “floating” celebrities and professional dancers that have yet to be paired up:
- Peta Murgatroyd
- Chelsie Hightower
- Tristan MacManus
- Val Chmerkovskiy
- Dmitry Chaplin
- Gilles Marini
- Kelly Osbourne
Once you guys have chosen the pairings that you prefer to see with their original partner then all the other floaters would be polled together for you to choose and we will see how the faux-season will come up. Don’t worry, the polls won’t last… 
Thanks Vogue!
Only thing is I don’t think Jennifer Grey will do the show again as she pretty much said it. I do think it would be a dream pairing.
I’m thinking maybe Nicole, Maria or even Jennie Garth are more likely to return for the All Star Season w/Derek.
Just guesses of course!
I voted for Mel B, Melissa, and Evan.
Where’s Cheryl? LOL
oops, sorry, just saw that this was the top 12 pros picked by the polls. Disregard my question, please.
Gilles and Peta would be sizzlin!
val should be paired up with sherri again……
Dmitry and Mya! If their sticking to the orignal teams! (really hope not ). They been their, done that already!!!
Marianya, these have to be the toughest polls ever on this site. 8) Ok, I voted for Mel B, Stacy, and Evan. THAT WAS HARD since I love Kirstie and Carson so much too. I voted on ‘skill’ in the end in making this competiton a tight one.
Oh yeah, Gilles and Peta = HOTNESS!
I voted for Tony to dance with Stacy only because I want Melissa to dance with Tristan! I never saw Stacy’s season. PETA & Gilles would be hot!
I’m kind of hoping they shake up all the partners. I loved some of partnerships and part of me would love to see some together again, but overall, I think the show will be much more interesting if they have new partners. I’ll be happy to watch either way though
Is there anyone else on here kind of wishing that they would just scrap this entire All-Stars idea and treat us to our regular show that we all know and love.
I find there are more celebrities that I don’t want to see again, as opposed to ones that I do.
Me too, Sandy, re comment #12. I wish TPTB would just scrap the All Stars idea. The show we all know and love is fine as it is. I worry All Stars is going to end up a train wreck.
I’m happy and cautious about the All-Star season… I really would like to see some have a second chance, etc.
Part of these polls is to see what people like and develop a “faux” season and see how the “faux” season would have worked.
Afterwards, just for the hell of it… I’m going to work on a season by season analysis of the scores for all the celebrities starting with Season 13 and moving backwards.
I completely agree that Peta and Gilles Marini, paired together, would be out of this world amazing!
Has anyone noticed that both Donny & Marie have cleared their schedule for the entire Fall? I just saw that on Donny’s website.
I don’t see that ever happening. I thought this show took a toll on Donny. But one could ask themselves, Has his ego swelled so enormously since other men have taken the trophy, that he needs a rematch? The anwser is probably YES to the Big Fat Ego, but No to the show.
As far as Marie. So much has happened in her life since doing the show, I think she probably has more important priorities in her life now other than dancing.
Oh dear god, Christy….No…No…
They are so egocentric I can see them doing the show together.
Most of DWTS fans do NOT want to see previous winners on the All Stars (What’s the point?) The ‘Stars’ should all be good dancers who finished in second place, and if there aren’t enough of those, use the ones who finished in third place.
I personally am not excited about the All Stars Season; I prefer a regular season with Stars comparable to Season 14, which was a competitive season. I will watch the show, especially if MelB dances with Maksim. If Mel cannot do the show, I would like Kirstie Alley to dance with Maks, because I love her!!! Thank you for allowing me to express my opinion.
Would rather see Tony with Chynna
Team Geta ( gilles and peta)
@Christy: I saw that too. I don’t think both would do the show at the same time becuase both would want to win and they need their humongus family and fan bases to vote for them but as long as its not donny I’m good. he seems fun and nice and can definately sing but either the man has to switch to decaf or he really needs to calm down.
Why wasn’t Cheryl Burke listed in the floating pro and celeb list? I want to see Cheryl And Gilles dancing together again as much as I want to see Anna and Evan and Melb and Maks.Gilles tweeted to Cheryl on May 22 U are the best. On May 15 Gilles retweeted from a fan Cheryl Burke and Gilles Marini HOTNESS #dwtsall stars! I am hoping tptb do not screw this up. Cheryl is very popular and has more followers than any of the pros.
if there is some switching going on…i would love to see these pairings…although some of these definitely wont happen b/c it would be too many great dancers in one season
anna ralph
peta gilles
chelsie mario
maksim mya
derek mel b
tristan nicole
karina evan
Maks and Mya would HOT.
I also think Mya and not Nicole was the biggest ringer ever. She was a dancer and taught choreography… No other celeb had that in their resume.
@Diana – Cheryl isn’t on the “floating” list because she wasn’t part of the top seven female pro dancers.
“On May 15 Gilles retweeted from a fan Cheryl Burke and Gilles Marini HOTNESS #dwtsall stars!”
……that was me
Love love love love Gilles!
I like Peta and Gilles or even Kym and Gilles. Kym hasn’t ever had a smokin hot partner (David is the cutest of her partners IMO) in the Gilles or Mario sexy category. I kinda think Joey Fatone and Chelsie would be cute together but I would like her and Mario together too.
I think John O’Hurley with either Peta or Kym would be great!
William Levy would be amazing!!!!!
He is a great dancer!!! (=
Nicole S.
Jennifer Grey
Julianne Hough
Ralph Macchio are some others I would love to see!!(=
@Love – We have just “Freed Willy”, lets leave it that way.
Nope, Peta do not have the sensuality of Cheryl that is perfect for Gilles. She is good with athletes. Neither Kym don’t have the sexy acting of Cheryl. No one can convey the passion and sensuality that Ms. Burke has in dancing. These pros all have strengths and weaknesses, but everything about Gilles is Cheryl. Cheryl is very special for that reason.
Marianya, why is Cheryl not part of top female pros? She got the best record and most famous pro? She is the best top female professionally and popularity. What did i miss? Cheryl, Kym, Karina are the top 3 female pros in that order.
Er, to YOU, Mel.
@Mel – This is post is part of a series of posts that I am working on the data for based off of whom the readers would like to see.
I took the SEVEN female professional dancers that polled highest from an earlier post: http://www.puredwts.com/2012/06/04/dwts-season-15-all-star-season-pick-your-pros/
So based on poll numbers, readers preferred seven other female dancers above Cheryl… that’s why I didn’t include Cheryl in the above post. That’s the nature of polls based on popularity… Cheryl may be a strong pro by the numbers but she lost her luster in the past few seasons.
Kirstie is not a good dancer and sahould not be considered t