PureDWTS Season 19, Week 7 – Power Rankings
Three cheers for an opening pro dance that I actually enjoyed! Thought it was cute how they worked in a Halloween theme. At the very least, it wasn’t a bunch of female bumping & grinding & hair-flipping…or Pitbull. 😯
So Len was back, and as I kind of predicted – he was grumpy, and Julianne kind of reverted back to being the level-headed judge. Carrie Ann is still the airheaded judge; I can’t even really remember anything Bruno said. Overall, I don’t feel as though the quality of judging improved much with Len’s return – so I’m fine if he doesn’t want to come back next season. Hell, I don’t really care if ANY of the judges come back next season 😉
Kinda had an inkling that Antonio was toast the minute the judges started laying into him for a dance that really wasn’t that bad, in my opinion – it was probably Antonio’s best, and though he’s still kind of an awkward mover, he seemed to smooth things out quite a bit better this week. But I’m guessing that he just wasn’t connecting with viewers – I felt like we never really got to see the real Antonio. Wish he would have given us more of a peek into his work or family life.
1.) Bethany & Derek – Bethany was given great scores and great choreography this week, but here’s the odd part for me: in both her individual and team dance, there seemed to be moments where she just wasn’t…fully present. It’s hard to describe, but it’s like she went into autopilot both times – not sure if she’s just really tired or burnt out, but she just didn’t seem as invested as she was in her tango last week. Thought the concept and setting of her paso was great, and Derek gave her some great choreo in their team dance – but she just didn’t grab the bull by the horns like she normally does. She wasn’t bad by any means – she was just not as dazzling for me as she usually is. Maybe it was just this week and having to learn two dances – hopefully she’ll be back to 100% next week. But she can leave the Maleficient/Queen Amidala hair – wasn’t loving that.
2.) Alfonso & Witney – I have to commend Witney on giving Alfonso a really solid, pure rumba – definitely a good idea for Len’s first week back. I think the stripped down staging worked well to showcase just how skilled Alfonso is – and I really enjoyed that this week, we got to see how great he is at partnering: he really was there for Witney every step of the way, which is something I look for from the guys I see doing rumba. The rumba is the woman’s dance, so it’s really the guy’s job to deliberately blend into the background a bit and just “be there” for his lady. And Alfonso did just that 🙂 Another thing I also love about Alfonso’s dancing: he’s a little guy that knows how to move BIG. One of the few things Carrie Ann said tonight that I agreed with was that Alfonso really knows how to stretch his arms and legs and really extend nicely. So well done, Alfonso & Witney. 🙂
3.) Sadie & Mark – As I said on Twitter – I see we’re back to Sadie getting underscored and nitpicked. Really makes one wonder if she’s getting a TON of votes…especially since this dance wasn’t nearly as bad to me as some of the judges were making it seem. Did the staging distract from the dancing? Maybe a tad, but I actually thought parts of it were genius – LOVED the section where Sadie was facing the zombies and doing work with her skirt. Thought she maybe had a little too much of a willowy-ness to her carriage, which made the paso look a bit funny on her at times, but overall she handled it pretty well. Definitely did NOT deserve any 7’s – I would have given it 8’s across the board. There was definitely content in it – saw lots of paso basics. Still love Sadie 🙂
4.) Lea & Artem – Here’s the thing about Lea: she’s got a lot of natural talent, and the potential to be a really great dancer on this show. She herself just needs to believe it 🙂 I think that’s the only thing that really held her back in her Argentine tango tonight – she seemed to lose a bit of confidence at times, and what could have been a really sharp, impactful step often came across as a bit soft & uncertain as a result. This was a good Argentine tango – with the potential to be GREAT. Saw some nice leg lines, and some moments were she was really committed to the dance. She just needs to let go and enjoy the experience. Stop worrying about Alfonso, Bethany, Sadie, etc….just do YOU, Lea. You’re good…believe it 🙂
5.) Janel & Val – After they finished this dance, I said on Twitter “I bet you anything Len complains about lack of steps in hold.” And sure enough, he did – while I actually enjoyed the overall production of the dance and didn’t really mind the PLL theme, I did find myself saying “Wow…this is a LOT of open work.” Would have liked to have seen a bit more done in-hold, but I didn’t hate what I saw out-of-hold. I also found it to be a bit stop-and-go, which kinda interrupted the flow of Viennese waltz – I think if Val would have upped the in-hold work by about 30% and resisted the urge to stop and have “moments”, he probably could have gotten a 9 out of Len. The 7 was Len basically saying “I’m back, bitches!” and making an example of Janel & Val.
6.) Tommy & Peta – Oh Tommy – he needs his tea breaks to get through rehearsal 😛 I’ve gotta say – Tommy seems to have really brought out the best in Peta this season. I was a pretty vocal critic of hers, not sure that she could hack it with a partner that wasn’t as naturally able-bodied or spry as she has gotten in the past. But I think Tommy has brought something out of her that we haven’t really gotten to see yet: she’s just enjoying the experience for what it is. Love the dynamic between these two, and the way she just loves Tommy, flaws and all. And this was actually a respectable effort for the quickstep – sure, it didn’t have a ton of bounce (76-year-old knees, y’know), but Tommy was pretty good in-hold, and seem to be having a good time. Glad Peta kept it simple for him while still making identifiable as quickstep. REALLY glad he didn’t go home this week 🙂
7.) Mike & Emma – Honestly, I didn’t really think it was Mike’s time to go until this week, when I saw how stressed out Emma was getting trying to teach him the jive. As I told someone on Twitter – the reason I think Emma keeps getting partners that aren’t so naturally good is likely because she does so well with them – look at Bill. Look at Billy Dee (had he not dropped out, I think he could have gotten the votes to last another week). And really – did anyone think Mike was gonna make it this far? Sure, he hasn’t really improved a ton – but I think Emma has helped endear him to the audience and showcase the (few) dance skills he does have naturally. But watching this jive was really kind of painful, y’all – Mike just seemed so lost, and Emma was just trying in vain to backlead him. Granted, the song was terrible – and it seemed more like a polka than a jive – but I’m afraid Mike has just plateaued in this competition. It’s been a good run – but I think it’s his time to go. Still love these two – just think they’ve reached the end of their journey 🙂
Thoughts on the Team Dances:
Ok, here’s the thing: the judges seem to score based on how in-sync the couples are on each team – that seems to be the one factor that really determines the score. That being said – the team that’s most in-sync is not always the team that’s most entertaining to me. And that was the case tonight – while the choreography was clean and cool and edgy and well-executed on Team Itsy Bitsy, it almost seemed a tad robotic to me. Maybe it was the song that did it – but I just found myself saying “Ok, from a technical perspective, that was great – but I just don’t CARE about it.” Seemed like each couple (with the exception of Mike & Emma, who I’m guessing were pressed for time and just rehashed their Argentine tango from last week) kinda did the same thing for their individual section. Was really hard for me to get excited about Itsy Bitsy, although I will say that Lea was 100% the MVP – for someone that was front & center for a good part of the dance, she had a lot of pressure on her shoulders to get every single step perfect…and she did. I only wish she had had that same confidence for her Argentine tango 🙂 While Team Creepy may not have had choreography that was as difficult or had Itsy Bitsy’s synchronization, I found myself more entertained by them on the whole – everyone just seemed to be having such a good time, and I loved how every couple’s individual section was tailored to them: Antonio & Cheryl were doing lifts (smart, cause that’s what he’s really good at), Alfonso & Witney were doing kind of a hip-hop jive (also what he’s really good at), Sadie and Mark were doing their quirky duck moves, and Tommy & Peta were goofing around and going steps that were quintessentially Tommy 😛 I guess the best way I can describe the difference between the two teams is this: Itsy Bitsy was more of a “one-size-fits-all” display of incredible synchronization, while Creepy was more of an offbeat carnival of varied delights. I think Creepy was underscored by about 2 points, though – the lack of synchronization was NOT 4 points worse than Itsy Bitsy, and it was really only Tommy that was out-of-sync.
So those are my thoughts…what are yours? Which team dance did you like better, and why? And who’s on the chopping block for next week?
Just excellent again, Court! You rock and I love your dance expertise always!! I also LOVED the opening dance.
Ok, here are my rankings…
1. Derek and Bethany – Just when I didn’t think they could blow me away more this season, they do so again. I had a total total “moment”. I loved how theatrical this dance was…so powerful, full of muscle, and strong. Bethany never lost character once. She is so into it all now. Just absolutely breathtaking and the dance of the night in my opinion.
2. Sadie and Mark – Another dance of the night that gave me a moment!! The Walking Dead meets Thriller and, of course, Len doesn’t get it. *eyeroll So creative and theatrical. Mark’s choreography is off the hook again (I’ve became a huge fan) and Sadie is just amazing. I just love these two and I don’t see why they don’t get more credit?
3. Alfonso and Witney – Such a pretty dance. All of their spins so angelic and beautiful. I loved all of the content and detail. Just lovely.
4. Janel and Val – It was a beautiful dance. I really liked Val’s choreography. However, I agree with Carrie Ann how she needs to get tighter with some of her leg work. She flings around too much. I also agree that it needed more holds. It had the verge of a “moment” but, just not quite.
5. Antonio and Cheryl – This is where I would have placed these two if they had made it. This dance was spellbinding, mystifying, romantic, and full of power. He gets better and better each week. They can take that to the bank and be proud.
6. Lea and Artem – Well, once again, I wasn’t that impressed. I thought this Tango lacked emotion, intensity, character, confidence, detail, and power. I agree with Julianne, how they need to relax.
7. Tommy and Peta – For being 76, he really did good again. He did lose steam a couple of times and maybe he made some mistakes, but, I loved it. He is always full of charm, heart, and class and meets any challenge the best he can and more than most would at his age. *Tommy, hang in there. You can do this and what’s more, you defy ageisms!!
8. Emma and Michael – I don’t care what the judges said, they were entertaining and their heart was totally in it. I loved it and them.
The Team Dances: Team ItsyBitsey won it for me, but, I really loved both of them so much!! Well done!!
Totally agree with your assessment of Tommy & Peta. 🙂
Honestly, Tommy killed that quickstep relative to what I was expecting. Compared to scores he’s gotten for other dances, I think he deserved a bit higher than the 28 that he got. But when you have Janel and Sadie getting 7s he of course seems overscored. That’s what sucks about this show really only having a 6 point scale for the most part. Not enough differentiation.
Lea is very underwhelming. That was fine but she should be doing better than fine. I didn’t think it was that sharp. I know everyone here has Janel pegged as the first shocking elimination, but I wouldn’t be surprised if it was Lea.
Loved Bethany and Derek’s Paso, suuuuper fun to watch. Maybe would have thrown in another 9 but it was great. Also love how this was another week where they looked like they were in trouble and they pulled it out. Derek magic?
Was mildly impressed by Antonio compared to weeks past but he didnt do anything for me, glad he went home.
Michael was terrible, he didn’t even deserve those 5s but we know how this show works. The comments were rough though, not sure if all that was necessary to say (true, but unnecessary). He needs to go.
LOVED Janel and Val tonight. No BS drama, just dancing and I thought the theme and the outfits (yes, I thought Janel looked good) were killer. Okay there wasn’t a ton of content but a 7??? No.
This just didn’t work for me, I agree there was too much focus on the theme and it didn’t feel enough like a paso for me. I know I just got finished saying I didn’t care about that for Janel and Val, but it’s just about what I connected to. Totally a personal preference thing. Didn’t deserve 7s either though. Mark’s face though, and Corky’s tweet — yikes.
My rankings:
Bethany
Alfonso
Janel
Sadie
Lea
Tommy
Michael
And for team dances, I thought Team Itsy Bitsy wiped the floor with Team Creepy and that’s coming from someone who was rooting for Team Creepy. Tommy was a little clumsy and Antonio’s part was boring. Lacked polish.
Oops my last little piece before my rankings is regarding Mark and Sadie lol left out their names.
I agree with Emily that I think Lea might be the shocking elimination instead of Janel. She has had two off weeks (IMO) and I just don’t know if she has the fan votes the way Janel does with the PLL crew. Next week is going to be hard to predict because the team dances changed some things around.
I thought Bethany’s dance was great. I didn’t notice that she faded in and out, perhaps because Derek did such a great job with her. Was it a 10 compared to the others? That was my only question mark, but I think she is finals bound, which I wouldn’t have said a few weeks ago.
I didn’t fully appreciate Alfonso’s rumba the first time I watched it so I tried it a second time and loved it. Bruno typically annoys me so I either tune out or fast forward, but his comment about sliding in movement resonated. His feet were a little off IMO and the costume didn’t do anything to lift the routine. Still tops though. I never tire of watching Alfonso.
Sadie really got screwed IMO. I had to rewatch hers too, and I loved it. I think the judges nitpicked about production whenever they wanted to justify lower scores. I would have given 8s and one 9.
Those three are still my picks.
I’ve actually been considering that Lea might go before Janel (but not much before). I haven’t run the numbers yet, but Mike’s 20 is going to be tough to overcome, even for Mike. And while it’s not all about fanbase, people keep forgetting that Lea was in an iconic movie series which is MUCH more in line with DWTS demographic that Janel’s TV show is. By a lot. This season, Janel’s tv fans really don’t amount to all that much when compared to Back to the Future, Nascar, Bethany’s fans and Fresh Prince. On a season with THAT competition, you have to be getting the general audience behind you and I’m not sure Janel is doing that. So, I’m thinking it’s likely a draw right now between the two women. I’ll have to run the numbers before I logic out who I think is going this week.
Last night was overall a wonderful dance night for me, except that the judges were too harsh on some couples. I could not get CAI giving Antonio a 6. I didn’t get the 7s from Len and CAI for Sadie. An 8 from Len for Janel would have been appropriate, too. For me 6s would have sufficed for Michael and he’d still be at the bottom of the leader board.
I agree with your rankings, Courtney. However, I liked Bethany’s hair–so Halloween, hehe. I did think along the same lines as you after watching the team dances. The two teams brought different flavors to the table and enjoyed both, so I initially thought that there would be a tie. My jaw dropped when all the judges whipped out the 8s for Team Creepy. While I am happy that Derek gets to keep his unbeaten team dance record, I didn’t think the other team should have been scored that low compared to Team Itsy Bitsy.
I also echo your thoughts on Lea–girl, just believe in yourself. I saw that fierceness and dance-attitude in her solo in the team dance more than in her AT. Also, I enjoyed Janel’s solo in the team dance much more than any of her other dances. In that moment, she and Val just danced.
Thank you for this rankings post, Courtney!
My rankings:
1. Sadie & Mark. Their performance was my overall favorite where I enjoyed everything about it -dance, song, concept, costumes. I had so much fun watching it and it was so underscored. I wouldn’t say it deserved 10s, but some 9s.
2.(tie) Bethany & Derek. For me the concept was my favorite part of their dance so I understand some of the criticism that it overshadowed the dance a little, but still great.
2. (tie) Alfonso & Witney. Gorgeous dance and I loved the song. Not a fan of Witney’s makeup though but that’s beside the point.
3. Janel & Val. This was my favorite week for them and I think it’s because they finally put the dancing first over their pseudo-showmance. It was a nice homage to PLL and very enjoyable to watch.
4. Lea & Artem. As I write this I am totally blanking on their dance. Oops?
5. Tommy & Peta. Don’t remember much of this one either, but Tommy while entertaining looks the same to me every week.
6. Michael & Emma. Go home.
Well my rankings go like this:
Bethany & Derek: As I’ve said before, Derek remains the king of the Paso Doble. It was just such an awesome dance! Lots of heat, intensity and passion. I actually saw Bethany very committed to this dance (more so than in her Team Dance) and she looked like she was giving it her all and the end result was pretty spectacular. Can’t say enough how much I loved it!
Alfonso & Witney: This is probably my favorite dance that they have done. Of course their Jazz was iconic and great but I don’t count that one. The Rumba seems to be the hardest dance for the male dancers but he made it look like a walk in the park. And I agree that one of the best things about it is the way he was always there for Witney and the way he cared for her. It was pretty amazing. My only complain? Ella Henderson being right in the middle of the stage. Would have allowed them to use the floor a bit more but whatever. Oh and also.. Witney looked GORGEOUS.
(TIE) Sadie & Mark and Janel & Val: I really enjoyed the concept of Sadie and Mark’s Paso Doble. I too saw a lot of content in that dance so I don’t know what Len was talking about. The only things that were missing for me was a bit more energy and “fire” from Sadie. She just didn’t attack it. Maybe it was because of the character she was playing though. Still loved it though and it definitely did not deserve a single 7. Janel & Val also performed what to me was their best dance. No showmance in the training video, no showmance on the dancefloor.. so that was great. Yeah they weren’t in hold a whole lot (if at all) but they still had a pretty cool concept and the dance overall was great, imo. A 7? Yeah… I don’t think so.
Lea & Artem: Lea used to REALLY be one of my favorites back in like.. Week 2. I don’t know what’s happened because lately she’s been kinda middle of the road for me. I agree… I think it’s because she’s not believing in herself! She’s just such a great dancer but isn’t giving it her all out there. She’s holding back and if she keeps doing that then I don’t see her reaching the finals (and boy do I REALLY want her to…). I did like this Argentine Tango though. Choreography wise I think Artem could have done something more impactful but nevertheless… a good dance.
Tommy & Peta: I didn’t think he was going to pull off that Quickstep but I’ll be damned! Tommy delivered a Quickstep! This man is 76 years old and has the energy to do a Quickstep? TAKE NOTES AMERICA. Lol. I loved this dance. Probably my favorite of Tommy’s. And I gotta say.. Peta is doing some of her best work this season. I am so happy to be seeing this side of her. Love the partnership between these two and don’t want them going home just yet.
Michael & Emma: I feel for Emma because I know she’s really trying to get Michael to dance but the man’s just not.. doing it. I couldn’t really watch their Jive.. It was kinda painful :\ The terrible song didn’t help them one bit also. Sigh.. I think it’s Michael’s time to go..
Team Dances:
In my head they both tied. Team Itsy Bitsy had the AMAZING synchronicity but Team Creepy was SUPER entertaining. I just think Team Creepy got the better song to do a much more entertaining dance with. Team Itsy Bitsy got a great song but you can’t really do something “fun” to it. I still loved both teams. I think they all deserved 9’s across the board. 😛
Kinda glad Antonio went home this week to be honest. He just really didn’t have that great of a personality and as much as he seemed to have been improving.. his dances were still very lackluster.
1 Alfonso witney loved it alfonso was great and witney was a great ghost
2 Mark sadie enjoy it loved the choregraphy totally underscored
3 Bethany and derek i liked the paso but for the first time in a derek number i got distracted by the others i just didn’t know where to watch
A tad overscored for me
4 Janel and val its was not a traditionnel viennese waltz but i liked it
5 Tommy and peta i liked it i thought it would be a mess but i was impressed
6 Lea and artem i dont know why i just think lea moves are not fluid plus i dont like artem so it doesn’t help
7 Michael and emma it was a mess i feel really bad for them
Not the best show for me i enjoyed team creepy far more than team itsybetsy was kinda sad when they lost
I totally agree with your ranking Courtney. Not so much to add.
For Beth. Honestly when Len said the dance was lost in the production, I was mad. Others are very lucky he wasn’t there weeks prior.
For Sadie. And we’re back to hosing them. I’m so mad. I loved Mark’s concept. It was so good. And to say there wasn’t any paso in the dance, does he need glasses? There was content. She should have gotten at least all 8s.
For Tommy. Considering everything, it was a great dance and Peta is great with him. I like him but he needs to go after next week.
I think Lea would have been much better with another partner. It’s been 3 weeks now that I just don’t connect with her dance and she’s been in my top since the beginning. Artem needs to do something and fast or she could go. The AT was very well danced, but I didn’t felt it, she looked like a robot for me. I’m worried she could be eliminated too early.
I also think it’s Michael turn to go next week. His jive was a mess, and I felt sorry for Emma watching this. We’ll see if his fanbase can get him past Tommy.
I also agree with team dance. I actually found team creepy much more entertaining. The concept was genius. Tommy was out of synch but that was expected. Even if I agree in technical aspect, they were under the other team, that didn’t deserve a 4 points difference.
I was very impressed with team Itsy Bitsy, Lea was so great in it and Michael kept up very well. It was clean and sharp. I wanted more. I also had a problem with the song when I learned of black widow, it grew a little on me after this dance.
1)Sadie and Mark: This is number one this week for me for three reasons. 1) Fun. It was a bit taken over by the Halloween theme but you know what….it’s Halloween and a fun time of the year so they had fun with it. 2)She LOVED every minute of that. 3)Those costumes lol. Mark really looked ready for the Walking Dead.
2)Bethany and Derek: I loved this (as I did Sadie and Mark and Alfonso) and her hair was wicked cool. I liked them better last week though.
3)Alfonso and Whitney: So first off CONGRATS! Saying that, clearly we can see why he has a baby on the way. He was the last person I expected to bring sexy to the rumba and he brought it big time. Underscored.
4)Lea and Artem: I liked it. It was solid and got great scores. Great costuming. Great mood to it. Saying that, all the puzzle pieces either click together perfectly with this couple (as seen through their jive, foxtrot, this week etc) or don’t (last week) and that worries me. I want to say that it’s Artem’s fault but I’m not sure if she places a lot of pressure on herself too.
5)Janel and Val: Well they had dun with their windows (very annoying I might add) and she definitely enjoyed the dark tone of it lol but that’s better than them showmancing it up. I agreed with Len. For some reason this dance reminded me of something Maks would do more than Val though.
6)Tommy and Peta: So this is the first dance he has done that I didn’t love, which is sad. I want to say that I agree with you that this is a whole new Peta and I love it. She really seemed to love this dance especially this week.
7)Michael and Emma: What can I really say that hasn’t been said already. It was painful to watch at times. Looking back at all he has done on the show so far, he has had highs and lows but through it all Emma has done what she does best: keep spirits up and that’s what I love most about her.
Team Dances:
1) Team Itsy bitsy: Janel and Bethany: WOW. Michael: Who knew he had that in him?! Lea: Showed her skills PERFECTLY.
2) Team Time Warp: Fun. Sadie and Mark stole this in my opinion with Alfonso a close second. Tommy was a hoot and a half. Antonio could lift so easily and I wonder why Cheryl didn’t use that to her advantage in their salsa and Allison overlooked it in their Bollywood.
Much as I like Michael, that Jive was horrible. The song was too fast and doesn’t have a meaty enough beat to grab onto in order to make the Jive steps pop.
I didn’t like seeing both him and Emma so stressed out and defeated in rehearsal either. He should try to be more like Tommy. Obviously there are steps that Tommy simply can’t do, but he handles the situation with a steady, almost Zen like attitude that seems to rub off on Peta.
I just hate seeing likable celebs and pros so at a loss and unhappy.
Viennese Waltzes should sweep across the floor with a controlled, steady elegance. I didn’t see any of that in either VW last night. And would it kill the show to actually use a proper classical Waltz song? I think I would drop dead in shock if I ever heard Schubert or Strauss for a VW on the show.
I don’t really see Back to the Future holding a lot of weight fanbase-wise. I think Lea is totally garnering more support from the general DWTS watchers because her and her journey with Artem is far more relatable to the a how’s core demographic than the nonsense Janel and Val have been throwing at us every week up until now. And we know that in the long run that resonating with the core audience will generally keep you around longer. But when it comes to prior fanbases, I don’t at all think that Lea would have more Back to the Future fans pulling for her than Janel does PLL fans. If she did, I think we would have less of a debate on our hands.
I still think Lea may be the first to go though despite everything that I just said haha because I don’t think were quite far enough for the power of PLL’s fanbase to wear out. There are still a ton of contestants left so even though I imagine Lea is getting more “core” votes than Janel, she still may not be getting enough to matter since many more of those core voters are likely throwing support at Alfonso, Sadie, etc.
I really enjoyed both team dances, for different reasons. Thought the scoring for Team Creepy was a bit harsh. Would not have minded if the teams would have tied.
I really wish Lea would attack her ind dances the way she did in the team dance.
Poor Sadie I think she got the shaft. Her Paso was not her best dance, but not 7 worthy either.
Dear NASCAR Nation: Stop. Please Stop. Michael needs to go. I know he tries but he’s not good and it just isn’t fair that he’s still there. Thank you.
Dear TPTB: Please! Can’t you see that four judges do not work? In most cases, all four of them don’t have the time to talk and only three can give critiques and then they cut to commercials. Four judges didn’t work on American Idol and it sure as hell doesn’t work on this show. Get rid of Carrie Ann. Thank you.
The highlight of the night for me was seeing Alfonso Junior in the audience. He makes my night! Love that little dude…
Once again I find myself underwhelmed by the dancing. But I would have to choose Alfonso as the best of the night yet again. It was nice seeing him bring the pace down and he danced the rumba beautifully. I’m not a fan of rumba but this was a pretty decent performance.
This is going to sound crazy but my second place team was Tommy. I thoroughly enjoyed his Quickstep and – what can I say? – he makes me smile!!
Third place was Sadie and Mark and I’m sorry that they were underscored. Why don’t the judges like her? Shout out to Mark for his creepy eyes. Ick!
I appreciate that Val and Janel seem to have put the romance nonsense on the back burner and just danced. It was enjoyable.
As for the rest….I just didn’t care for any of the dances. My mind wanders when I watch these couples. I mean what happen to Lea? I thought she’d be a real contender but she seems to have no confidence in herself lately…
With regard to the Team dances, my preference was for the Creepy team. I loved the music and I found that performance fun and delightful. OK maybe it wasn’t perfect but I don’t care!
Anyway – I seriously hope Michael gets the boot next week. I would’ve rather have seen Jonathan still there than Michael. I just embarrassing now…
Courtney, I agree with all you said. Michael was very hard to watch and his time on the show should be at an end. I’m glad Antonio is gone, he just never seemed invested in the whole thing like he should be and needed to be. My top three for the finals right now, in no particular order, are Sadie, Alfonso and Brittany.
I enjoyed Team Creepy’s dance better, it was very entertaining, loved the costumes and how each couple did their part to their own strength areas. But it didn’t surprise me that Team Itsy Bitsy won.
I wouldn’t mind if Len just stayed in London and didn’t come back next season. There were so many times he was just mean when he didn’t need to be. Judging is about critiquing a dance, but it can be done respectfully. He leaves, keep it to 3 judges, 4 is just too many in my opinion and someone is always getting cut off because of time anyway.
Who leaves Monday? It should be Michael and I would be shocked if it was anyone else. But for the sake of argument, if he manages to get the votes and stays, I would so enjoy seeing Janel go. Lea is a possibility too, but she’s more likable and I see her staying over Janel.
My Rankings:
Sadie
Alfonso
Bethany
Janel
Lea
Tommy
Michael
I’ve become a huge fan of Sadie and Mark this season. I find myself looking forward to what Mark comes up with for her. His coreography and costumes have been on point and Sadie seemed to really love her dance last night. She did NOT deserve a 7. I would have been okay with 8’s but a 7? No way. It was obvious Mark was unhappy with those scores and he had a right to be. I can’t wait to see what he does for her with contemporary next week. I feel like they keep getting the short end of the stick with the scores. It makes me wonder about how many viewer votes they are getting.
I liked team creepy more for entertainment value but the judges were correct that Tommy was not in sync with everyone else. (Everyone else looked great together though.) I was kind of bored with the other team dance, but I think the music choice kind of turned me off.
Another thing- why do they need four judges when they don’t all have time to talk? They should just go back down to three and have have another stand in judge when Len can’t be there.
Don’t know if anyone thought the same, but Janel & Val’s Viennese Waltz kinda reminded me of Corbin & Karina’s ‘Game of Thrones’ one from Season 17. Maybe a lot more on the performance and the theme of the specific show, but not enough traditional VW and not enough in hold. Loved both dances as performances, but not as Viennese Waltzes.
It seems that I’m only down with Janel and Val when they’re talking about death. Hahahaha
I really like the dances this week but it wasn’t the best week to bring Len back since Halloween night is all about stage shows and dramatics
I will say, if mark had calmed a little on the concept…. I think Sadie would have had a better grasp of it. I honestly think paso would be harder for her than rumba and while I appreciate marks attempt, it was too much
Halloween is one of my favorite times of the year, and having the theme on DWTS can either lead to great performances or big messes. Some of the dances either left me wanting more, or left me UN-amused.
1. Alfonso & Witney: In my opinion, this was one of the best dances of the night that happened to be underscored. It’s really rare for the man to do Rumba well, and Alfonso made everything work. And I loved his little announcement in the sky-box.
2. Sadie & Mark: I don’t know what the judges were smoking to give this dance 7’s and 8’s. I got the concept, the content was there, and I enjoyed every second of that dance, so the judges can suck it. This is another example of Mark’s choreography getting nitpicked and low-balled.
3. Janel & Val: I thought this dance was severely underscored. I thought this was one of her best dances since Week 3, and the judges rip her for not having enough hold, which is a load of BS.
4. Bethany & Derek: I did not get this performance at all. Too much messing around with the production, and not enough dancing. Not to mention over-scored. Even though she was dressed to suit her actual personality, I DO NOT like Bethany, and I never will.
5. Lea & Artem: I loved their performance very much. Another dance that was under-scored, and the judges were nitpicking when there wasn’t really anything to nitpick. I thought this deserved a couple 10’s.
6. Tommy & Peta: I’m amazed by how far he’s made it. I find him very entertaining, and I thought his Quickstep was his best to date. I’m looking forward to what he has in store for next week.
7. Michael & Emma: The judges should have cut him a break this week. The man is 6’5″, so of course he isn’t going to able to have any bounce in the Jive; however there wasn’t much Jive in the dance anyway.
My thoughts on the Team Dances-
#TeamItsyBitsy: The performance was fine, but I thought it was too serious (probably because of the song). Not to mention, Bethany looked a tad bit uncomfortable during her individual part. Janel and Lea’s parts were awesome, and Michael surprisingly held everything together.
#TeamCreepy: I LOVED THIS ROUTINE FROM START TO FINISH!!! I got so many nostalgic feels from the song, and I felt like I was actually at the circus. I wanted this to get 37 points, just to see how Derek would react. Haha
I’m not shocked to see Antonio & Cheryl leave. I was getting really bored with them, so it’s not a total loss.
I find it very interesting that Derek made Lea the center piece of the team dance. It’s unselfish and just interesting that he did that. I’d like a peek inside that mind, please. 🙂
Poll the audience that is watching DWTS and find out how many loved Back to the Future and how many have even heard of PLL. I think the results would shock some of you PLL fans in a huge way.
If Janel manages to hang on longer than Lea, it won’t be their respective fanbases that do it. Considering that the producers have given Janel contemporary to Romeo and Juliette?? Yeah, pimpage is alive and well.
If you think Derek would do anything more than shrug and smile at a loss, then you’ve not been paying attention, Ryan. But since we didn’t find out…neener neener. 🙂
Wait – you hated Bethany’s dance because of all the production, but loved Janel’s dance even though it had little V. Waltz content (and most of her dances had more production than all of Beth’s put together). And you don’t like beth and “never will.” Glad you’re so upfront with your bias there, Ryan.
Alfonso was the best of the night, but I also really liked Janel and Sadie.
Loved, loved #Team Creepy, it was a much more fun dance. I don’t care that they were not in sync, I always just look for the fun element. So they were totally robbed.
Heidi, I was thinking that it really was generous of Derek and Bethany his letting Leah get the center of the team dance at the beginning. I have noticed that Derek loves synchronicity, but he also loves symmetry in the figures he presents. As Michael and Emma had to be at the back due to his heisght, I think Derek chose to have the two brunettes on the same line, and that left only Leah to occupy the front. I may be totally wrong, of course, but I always try to find the symmetry in things, so I thought that was the case.
I love that Derek made Lea the centerpiece of the beginning of the team dance! I thought she killed it too! I wonder if Derek saw what so many other people are seeing – that she needs to believe in herself – and gave her that. No matter what his reasoning, it was a very cool thing to do and I think she lived up to it. Looking at her side by side with Bethany and Janel, she totally holds her own. Loved that team dance! Both team dances were a lot of fun.
I knew when Len gave Derek crap about the drums that Mark was going to get a full on lecture about a graveyard full of zombies, but 7s??!! Really? Ok then. I don’t get to worried about her scores, because I think she is killing it in votes and underscoring her will only serve to motivate an already highly motivated fanbase. I think she can win the whole thing. Barring an unfortunate injury the top three will be Sadie, Alfonso and Bethany. Any of those three can win it all!
I liked, but did not love, Lea’s Argentine Tango. 🙁
It’s time for Michael to go. That was painful to watch. I guess we will now find out the true voting power of NASCAR fanbase. Or whether or not they will be merciful and recognize when it is time for the party to end.
For the first time I have doubts about how much farther Tommy can go. Love him, but it is only going to get tougher.
I totally want to throw Sasha in my fridge for the next party I have. That was pretty funny.
Lea was wonderful in the team dance formation. Once again I wish for her to be with another pro, because if she’s eliminated early I’m laying the blame on Artem. I did NOT care for that Argentine Tango at all compared to what I think she’s capable of. At this point I think even Tony would have been a better pro for her.
Tommy did wonderfully, all things considered. I can’t help but agree that Peta has been a revelation this season, and it was touching to see her get emotional about Tommy. Also I LOVED LOVED LOVED the bodice of her outfit for their QT, especially the color.
I liked Bethany’s Paso a lot, thought she did well and the concept was cool but I do think it was a tad over scored. Still, definitely one of the better dances of the night.
Alfonso did a great rumba, and now I hope we see more ballroom out of him. I want to see him partner more because I think he’s capable of really bringing elegance and smoothness to those dances.
I thought Sadie and Mark were grossly underscored. Yes she lost some of her attack in the concept, but she certainly didn’t deserve anything less than 8’s. I actually loved the dance though, and I adore Mark for just going all in with everything. He seems to be having a blast with her, but understandably frustrated with their scores. I have a feeling she’s killing it in the votes, but if the judges keep this up the Sheeple of the general audience will start to buy into their scoring.
I liked Janel’s dance a lot, but I agree with the lack of hold. Also even though I’ll take “bad girl” Janel any day over “showmance” Janel, she just irks me and she’s such an attention whore. She always seems “on” and that’s a quality that just aggravates me.
Poor Emma. What a dear. I love the song, but the fact that they’ve given that for a jive twice now to two slower-moving celebs, cmon. It deserved its scores, but I was happy for them to do so well in the team dance. I do hope it’s Michael or Janel leaving now that Antonio has gone.
I liked both team dances equally, for different reasons. I do think the synchronicity of Itsy Bitsy deserved slightly better scores, but not by four whole points.
I enjoyed this episode although it’s clear the pressure is getting to many stars and pros. My theme for the week is the distractions – see comments below.
My rankings:
Alfonso and Witney – might be my favorite rumba ever. He’s twice her age and yet it was romantic and mature without going too far. Such beautiful movement throughout. Witney is one heckuva choreographer. The distraction was the singer in the middle of the floor.
Janel & Val – thought the idea, music and waltz really worked well together. Could there have been more in hold? Yes, but it was still a waltz. These two have more chemistry when she’s planning to off him – leave the showmance behind! Distraction was the doll.
Lea & Artem – I love her legs which are a big part of AT. It was crisp and if a little too clean and lacking simmer, still great. Distraction was the pace – thought the music (Necessary Evil is a cool song) could have been a tad slower.
(Tie) Bethany & Derek and Sadie & Mark – neither Paso was completely right for me. I didn’t quite get the concept of Bethany/Derek’s dance, though they are beautiful in hold. Distraction was her hair (I agree with Courtney)- shouldn’t be a factor but even Derek made fun by grabbing her “horns.”
Sadie & Mark had a great concept, but CAI was right that it did not fit the paso. Loved the switch to the long skirt and the use of the troupe in this number. The distraction here was the little girl character.
Tommy & Peta – I have finally succumbed to his charms and love the softer side of Peta. She should never leave him on his own however. Tommy himself is the distraction – it’s got to be hard on the old guy.
Michael & Emma – whole thing was an uncomfortable distraction. Not even a Halloween theme! Sad to see the wonderful, positive Emma struggling. If he stays next week over ANYONE else left, I might have to stop watching (at least his dances)!
As for the team dances, I think Courtney’s comments are right on the money. Synchronization does not equal cohesion. Team Creepy was more cohesive and fun. Really thought there’d be a tie here.
this week on dwts was wonderful, except for the fact that more and more I realize that who will take home this trophy will be Derek and Bethany do not understand how she gets such high scores, Sadie guess as best dancer she. To my eyes it looks like a dance bethany just does not flow and the soil in her group made it even clearer.
My fans from the very beginning is to alfonso increasingly he surprises me and this week was no dirente, I am not a fan of rumba … but just loved this dance, witney is wonderful. I like him because he can dance, he has swing, it’s nice to see him on stage.
I also like Sadie and I love the choreography mark this season
Lea reminds me of what Amy Purdy says, that she knows people who are physically whole but who are more disabled than she is due to their mental component. Lea is a lovely person, but her “meekness” is irritating to me. She’s a grown ass woman and should require more of herself. I’m sorry that this experience has not (yet) boosted her confidence. About her dancing, she’s a bit bow legged and her feet seem always to be further apart than they should be. I noticed it again last night when she did turns, her feet are quite wide apart. I’m really surprised that no one has ever mentioned keeping her feet close together. To me it makes her dancing seem quite clumsy, but I know I am way in the minority on this.
Love Mark, love Sadie and think they were slightly hosed, but Sadie looked lost. I think that having her portray fierceness in the paso would be quite a challenge. There may have been too many other people/props with which she had to compete in order to be “heard.” Don’t think she was strong enough for that, hence, seemed lost.
I think the staging of Bethany and Derek’s dance was phenomenal. They had me from the first sight of those hood trains. Happy for their scores. Looking for a quantum leap from Bethany.
The judges? Well, the situation reminds me of this restaurant critique: “The food was terrible — and the portions were so small!” I think prior to every dance they should do a rock-paper-scissors to see who will sit this one out.
Not a ranking so much as just my opinion. Loved the theme tonight and everyone seemed to get into it.
Sadie and Marks was a little overproduced. I found that my eye was drawn other places besides Sadie and I did not like her costume.
Mike is nice and funny but this is not a comedy competition but a dance competition – he needs to go.
Someone’s post said that Lea is getting the 50 year-old and BTTF fans. I am both and on team Alfonso all the way, as are most of my 50 something friends.
I really think the only reason Janel gets votes (seriously how many PLL fans are there?) are the die-hard M&M fans that are just voting for Val.
My favs were Bethany and Alfonso. Team dances a tie.
Thoughts on the dances:
My favorite performance of the night was Bethany’s — I really enjoyed the drama and the performance value. However, there were definitely a few moments where she looked lost. I was hoping for a little more paso content as well — I actually think that Derek may have gotten just a little too caught up in the concept and the drums with this one, as a lot of the performance focused on the drums. I do think it was overscored. I’m surprised to say this, but she’s the first partner of Derek’s in the seasons I’ve seen that has been a little overscored. Or maybe I feel that way because Sadie and Alfonso are being underscored. It was still my favorite of the night, though, and she looked beautiful in that lovely gown.
Speaking of Sadie, WTF is going on with her scoring?!?! She’s consistently churning out performances that are both entertaining and technical, and besides maybe two or three weeks (out of seven!) she’s been terribly underscored. I don’t understand it. Sure, this wasn’t a traditional paso, but it was certainly unique and fun, and worthy of 8’s and 9’s. I’m really loving Mark’s choreography this season.
I would have to say that my biggest disappointment of the season has been Lea – she’s unquestionably a good dancer, but she’s not at all great, and I think she has the potential to be spectacular. I think it’s Artem – please, TPTB, get rid of him and put in someone who’s a better teacher. I *love* Derek and Beth together, but I’d also love to have seen him partner Lea – I think that under his expert tutelage, she could have been another Jennifer Grey. Oh well.
Tommy and Peta… I’m just so impressed with both of them. Tommy has done so well for a man of his age, it’s unbelievable. And Peta has proved to me to have some substance as well as style. I think that she tends to emulate her partner a little bit, so I really hope TPTB give her non-sexpot guys with nice personalities going forward, and give Karina or Cheryl the “sexy” guys. And please, Peta, wear more gowns like the one you had on last night – it was gorgeous!
Between the two teams, I vastly preferred Team Creepy. I thought Itsy Bitsy’s choreo was very repetitive, and the hip-hop annoyed me – I was hoping they’d do more of a tango/jazz. That said, they got a crap song. I didn’t see the sync issues that everyone else has with Creepy’s performance, and it was just so much more unique and interesting for me. I might be biased, though, since my favorite couples were on it 🙂
Yeah it wasn’t her best dance and while I felt Mark has been good choreographing for her, he was showcasing himself more here. This is one of mark’s better choreo seasons but sometimes his concept overtakes what looks good for his celeb. Same thing happened with Aly and Chelsea too. I know she is underscored at times but his attitude about the scores don’t help. I am more confident Sadie will win because of her fan base and people just like her. While she is popular the underscoring can make it seem like a surprise win.
I also saw throughout the season how many people are “inspired” by Derek’s choreo including Mark. His contemporary like rumba with Sadie even costume wise reminded me of Derek’s past rumbas. But Val’s VW was so close to Derek’s psycho tango. The ending, at least. That is a memorable dance. Iconic for dwts IMO but if Suri or KB on afterbuzz go on about how creative Val was, well, take it as a compliment for Derek.
But that for Bethany was amazing and they should take it on tour. I see her performance improving. People forget she is also young like Bethany and her journey has been great to watch.
Actually, I think synchronization and cohesion are pretty damn synonymous in this instance. If you liked Team Creepy better, just say so, don’t try to make excuses for why. Own it.
“Inspired” is a good word for it, Melissa. 🙂 Even some of Tony’s work from earlier in the season was very reminiscent of what Derek has done in the past – I think it was with Kellie.
I am glad I’m not the only one who liked Team Creepy better. I loved the carnival theme, the mime movements, the energy they displayed, the dazzling individual dances, the dynamic power of the number!
Yes, Team ITSY Bitsy had the precision of a drum and bugle corps. And I loved their movements as human spiders. But it was just that, a one size fits all. It was amazing of course.
I was so hoping Creepy would win the team dance.
But, having said that, I love all of the team dances. And the camaraderie that they share in performing them,
I want the a Trio Dances. I love and miss them!
I agree, Sadie was underscored last night. I don’t think her dance was equal to Tommy. And as for Michael I’m surprise by his Nascar fans. I have never thought they will be pulling for him big time. I do know though that Nascar is owned by the Hendricks who are very family oriented, christian family just like Sadie’s. I’m afraid when Michael gets eliminated some, if not, most of his fans will vote for Sadie. My top 3 (in no particular order) are still Bethany, Alfonso, Sadie.
I agree with your rankings, Courtney.
I thought both team dances were great, but I am biased towards Team Creepy. I wish the two teams could have tied, but I understand that because in the judges’ minds they are ranking the two teams with their score (giving a ‘9’ to the better team and an ‘8’ to the other), there would automatically be a 4-point difference.
I also wanted to add that I think Sadie was the MVP of Team Creepy. Her dancing was really full-out and precise (moreso than her Paso, I’m sad to admit) and she gave a lot of personality. Every time there was a camera shot was on her, she had a great facial expression. She looked like she had a lot fun working with the other couples. 🙂
I have a question — My friend, who doesn’t really participate in forums like this type but has watched the show for years always makes comments about Witney’s choreography being choreographed by other pros (Karina & Sharna) — Do you know if there is any truth to this or if pros actually do help other pros choreograph certain dances?
I didn’t fully agree with her because I do think Witney is fully capable of coming up with a great routine herself so I just wanted to ask 🙂
I believe witney choregraph herself and shes really talented
I don’t think there is a pro who has time to choregraph for an another one
Especially when karina and sharna where contestant if that was the case they would give alfonso a killer jive and still having there own partner
I believe every pro choregraph their routines
Plus if they were so giving they will have choregraph for allison because some of her choregraphy were not so good
Being in sync is hard, especially when you have someone like Michael Waltrip, who, I think it’s safe to say is by far the worst dancer left on the show at this point in the season. That said, I appreciated what Derek did with that number, the opening sequence was FIERCE! Agree that Lea was the MVP of their team dance. I don’t really see how else they could’ve choreographed that number, it doesn’t really fit another theme, imho.
Team Creepy’s performance was good BUT when they all danced together spread out all over the floor, it was a bit messy. I agree with Courtney though and would’ve given them at least a 34 total overall.
I’m just glad Derek’s record remains intact, especially if this is his final season…that remains to be seen. With that guy, ya just never know. LOL. LOTS of people love to hate him. Saying how they are fixing it so that he and Bethany win, Julianne is only a judge because of Derek…sigh, it gets tiresome reading all of the negativity towards Derek. No point in trying to talk sense and logic with those people though, I’ve tried and it’s pretty pointless :/
Hating derek is the easy thing to do
The judges underscored sadie it’s derek fault
Come on he doesnt have anything to do with it
I have to say dwts facebook page has become the i hate the houghs page
I don’t agree with julianne and she some time really annoys me but she doesnt deserves the hate shes getting you can say you don’t like her but it goes so far
Derek will always be my fave male pro (even tho witney has become my fave pro of all time )
So i really am tired of hearing the same complaints he super talented deal with it
He hasnt hurt you
At the end of the day its a tv show
Sorry for the rant i got upset after going on the dwts page
Ya know, I’m not the least bit religious, but I’m really bothered by the assumption that just because someone is conservative or religious they will automatically vote for the religious conservative people left on the show. That strikes me the wrong way. I just don’t like to believe that most people are that narrow minded. Like those could be the only votes they could be getting. Like they are some power voting block (clearly not).
There have been lots of rumors of Sharna choreographing for other pros – but that came mainly from her disgruntled boyfriend. Who knows how true it is. All the pros have gotten *help* at one time or another, especially when they are handed something really different. Even Derek, who is arguably the best choreographer on the show.
As for Whitney specifically? I think she largely does her own thing. The choreography seems too fresh to me to be a product of another pro on the show.
LOL, Kelly. I saw several comments the other night where Julianne always gives her brother a 10. As if no one else gave him a 10 and that’s all she ever gave him. Stupidity on that level is pretty pointless to argue with.
Frankly, looking at what Julianne actually SAYS – she’s complemented Mark, Artem and Val on choreography. Has not said a WORD about Derek’s work until this past Monday. I think she actually goes out of her way to avoid saying too much to him unless it’s a criticism. And really, I don’t blame her. And I’m sure Derek doesn’t need the stroking.
Regarding religious conservatives voting for certain contestants, my sister is an extreme right, born again and whenever I ask her who she likes on the show she mentions contestants like Candace or Sadie because “I like their values”. So I just breathe deeply and remember that her viewpoint is just a tiny percentage of who votes on the show.
I believe the general voting public simply votes for who they like to see on their TV screens each week, regardless of race, religious beliefs, sexual orientation or age. And thank goodness for that! Work hard, be nice to people and likable and entertain me, That’s my criteria.
I’ve noticed that Witney definitely has some signature moves in her dances that she’s used last season and this season, so I think it’s hers, but like Heidi says, everyone gets help at some point.
I’ll admit I was hesitant about Julianne being a judge because of her relation to Derek (wouldn’t have wanted Maks either because of his relation to Val) but she’s proved to be a great addition. I love that even when she enjoys a performance she still tries to give the contestant something to work on so that there’s always growth. She’s refreshing and often a better judge than the other 3.
I’m a little late, but I didn’t have the opportunity to watch the show before (Europe here!).
Derek and Bethany: Wow, wow, wow. It took my breath away. I LOVED the beginning, when they were shrugging with their shoulders and then heads. Awesome! I could go on and on about how amazing it was, but I’ll just sum it up and say that it was a masterpiece that only Derek Hough is able to create.
Alfonso and Witney: I don’t know what, but something about Alfonso just bothers me. I think that he is an amazing dancer, but I don’t know… He just does nothing to me. Sometimes I have a feeling like he is trying too hard, that all he can think of is that he wants to win and he is forgetting to have fun, too. It wasn’t a very memorable routine for me and all I could see was Witney, but I know that they were dancing rumba, so it’s not really his fault.
Sadie and Mark: Mark is crazy, I have to say that haha 😀 I mean…he is crazy. 😀 The theme was great and Len is just nuts. I’m not a professional dancer and I could see a paso in that routine. Was that Sadie’s best dance? Far from it, but those 7’s? C’mon. I would give them 8’s across the board. But Mark was so pissed, that I felt really bad for him.
Lea and Artem: Lea is fading in my opinion. It wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t anything special. And that’s it.
Janel and Val: I have to admit that I find Janel less and less annoying each week haha 😀 I didn’t really get the story in their dance, except for the beginning and the end, but there really wasn’t enough in hold. Val should know better, especially because Len was back.
Antonio and Cheryl: I don’t even remember their dance. Enough said.
Tommy and Peta: I mean, to do a quickstep at 76 and it wasn’t even bad? Amazing! And Peta was never really my favorite pro, but I have to give her credit this season, because she is doing an incredible job and I thought it was so cute when she had tears in her eyes when they were talking to Erin.
Michael and Emma: Yikes. I love Emma and I felt for her, but that really wasn’t a jive.
TEAM ITSY BITSY: Their sync was on point. And I didn’t really get CAI’s comment about Derek repeating himself. The only freestyle that was similar was maybe in season 17, Foxing Awesome. MAYBE. But with that song, you coudn’t really do anything but hip hop and I think they did amazing! Kudos to Michael, too.
TEAM CREEPY: I totally agree with scores. Their choreography was MUCH more simple (I can’t blame them, having Tommy in the team, but still).
I wonder…is it Lea that’s fading, or is it Artem’s choreography?? Let’s face it – he’s from SCD which is a COMPLETELY different show from DWTS. It’s much more traditional, for one thing. You don’t have Derek (and Mark) pulling crazy shit out and putting it on the dance floor. While I don’t think Janel is that great, Val is putting together some interesting routines for her. He’s not reached the Derek/Mark level yet, but he’s way ahead of Artem. And Whitney’s killing it with Alfonso. So, I wonder if it’s the choreo that’s lackluster, and not Lea herself. I do think if Lea had been with another pro, we’d be seeing a different dancer at this point.
In the ongoing saga of the Derek/Lea friendship…at the end of the show in week 6, he was teaching her some dance steps. Looked like AT frame.
I will say that I think it’s that Artem’s choreography is boring, but Lea also does not dance with much conviction. I think BOTH of those things could be helped by a different pro, though. For me she will always be a “what could have been” type contestant.
I think some of Lea’s decreased enthusiasm might be due to her rib hurting her. It happened the week she was with Val. That was her last really “joyful” feeling dance. Maybe she has a low threshold for pain and it’s taking a toll?