Your All-Star Dream Cast If A Reunion Is In The Works For Dancing With The Stars Season 20

The Sherri Shepherd post and the comments in it, have me wondering about a Dancing With The Stars Re-union or All-Star cast for the 10th Anniversary next season. If this is what producers are planning (and note that nothing is confirmed on this yet. We’re only speculating and discussing the possibility for fun), who would you like to see return for it? Read on before you answer…

Sandy mentioned that an “All-Stars season would only work if the entire cast was evenly stacked. NO past winners mixed in with non-winners, and NO original pairs mixed in with new pairings.”

In the new Pros Wish post, Heidi mentioned the same and that unlike the last all stars and making it more fair for everyone, they should “pick all NON-Winners OR ALL winners. Not a mix of both” and “if they go with Non-winners, then they shouldn’t go lower than 4th place.”

So, thinking on Sandy and Miss Heidi’s scenarios(can we only hope TPTB are thinking on the same lines?) and for fun (in case they are), who would you like to see dance if a Re-Union or All Star cast if something in the works for Dancing With The Stars Season 20? In other words, what would be your All-Star Dream Cast picking only from the “original pairings” and/or from “only winners” and/or only those couples who have placed 4th or higher? Don’t pick anymore than 13 couples. Meet you in comments with my picks!!

ETA: Lori was so gracious enough to put a quick list of top 4 contestants from all of the seasons for us which you could read below for easy referencing. She did not include Season 15 since that was the previous All stars.

*Kelly Monaco/Alec Mazo*
John O’Hurley/Charlotte Jorgensen
Joey McIntyre/Ashly DelGrosso
Rachel Hunter/Jonathan Roberts

*Drew Lachey/Cheryl Burke*
Jerry Rice/Anna Trebunskaya
Stacey Keibler/Tony Dovolani
Lisa Rinna/Louis VanAmstel

*Emmitt Smith/Cheryl Burke*
Mario Lopez/Karina Smirnoff
Joey Lawrence/Edyta Sliwinska
Monique Coleman/Louis VanAmstel

*Apolo Anton Ohno/Julianne Hough*
Joey Fatone/Kym Johnson
Laila Ali/Maksim Chmerkovskiy
Ian Ziering/Cheryl Burke

*Helio Castroneves/Julianne Hough*
Mel B/Maksim Chmerkovskiy
Marie Osmond/Jonathan Roberts
Jennie Garth/Derek Hough

*Kristi Yamaguchi/Mark Ballas*
Jason Taylor/Edyta Sliwinska
Cristian DelLaFuente/Cheryl Burke
Marissa Jaret Winokur/Tony Dovolani

*Brooke Burke/Derek Hough*
Warren Sapp/Kym Johnson
Lance Bass/Lacey Schwimmer
Cody Linley/Julianne Hough

*Shawn Johnson/Mark Ballas*
Gilles Marini/Cheryl Burke
Melissa Rycroft/Tony Dovolani
Ty Murray/Chelsie Hightower

*Donny Osmond/Kym Johnson*
Mya/Dmitry Chaplin
Kelly Osborne/Louis VanAmstel
Joanna Krupa/Derek Hough

*Nicole Scherzinger/Derek Hough*
Evan Lysacek/Anna Trebunskaya
Erin Andrews/Maksim Chmerkovskiy
Chad Ochocinco/Cheryl Burke

*Jennifer Grey/Derek Hough*
Kyle Massey/Lacey Schwimmer
Bristol Palin/Mark Ballas
Brandy/Maksim Chmerkovskiy

*Hines Ward/Kym Johnson*
Kirstie Alley/Maksim Chmerkovskiy
Chelsea Kane/Mark Ballas
Ralph Macchio/Karina Smirnoff

*JR Martinez/Karina Smirnoff*
Rob Kardashian/Cheryl Burke
Ricki Lake/Derek Hough
Hope Solo/Maksim Chmerkovskiy

*Donald Driver/Peta Murgatroyd*
Katherine Jenkins/Mark Ballas
William Levy/Cheryl Burke
Maria Menounos/Derek Hough

*Kellie Pickler/Derek Hough*
Zendaya Coleman/Valentin Chmerkovskiy
Jacoby Jones/Karina Smirnoff
Alexandra Raisman/Mark Ballas

*Amber Riley/Derek Hough*
Corbin Bleu/Karina Smirnoff
Jack Osbourne/Cheryl Burke
Bill Engvall/Emma Slater

*Meryl Davis/Maksim Chmerkovskiy*
Amy Purdy/Derek Hough
Candace Cameron Bure/Mark Ballas
James Maslow/Peta Murgatroyd

*Alfonso Ribiero/Witney Carson*
Sadie Robertson/Mark Ballas
Janel Parrish/Valentin Chmerkovskiy
Bethany Mota/Derek Hough