DWTS Season 24, WEEK FOUR – LIVE BLOG (Spoilers)
Most Memorable Year…usually the night of rumba and (poorly done) contemporary. Be sure to check the “Who’s Dancing” post as the running order has been updated…and it ain’t lookin’ good for Nick, dang it. Not sure what they have against him.
Oh and CAI said she wants me to come on DWTS and dance with her. LOL. I think she really wants Derek and got me by mistake. 😉
Okay, these intros are SOOO scripted it ain’t even funny. I think it was Normani and Nick that gave it away – neither are actors so there you go.
Normani was a darling little girl. 🙂 Hi grandma!! Okay, that was a pretty long package – we should assign someone to time them to see who’s getting hosed.
Pretty pink dresses. Len shouldn’t like this Rumba since it has no softness to it at all. Too hard and staccato. And then there’s that lift – almost like he said “fuck it…too hard to keep the foot on the ground”.
Did Len just admit that he was going easy on Normani because she’s been traveling?? Sounds like it to me…and that’s BS.
Sorry judges – it wasn’t that good. It wasn’t pretty – it was strong and powerful but that’s not what I expect to see in a rumba. You better call that lift, CAI – it was so freakin’ blatant.
Oh goodie, they gave one of the Harmony girls a mic. Someone take it away. STFU Val. Jesus. We’re now 16 minutes into the show and there has been ONE DANCE. Who tries to claim that Val and his partners never get pimped.
That 9 was pretty generous. I agree with the rest of it.
Now, a Bachelor commercial. 😀 Come on Nick, I saw rehearsal footage and you were doing good hip action.
Who’s body are we in love with here? I’m thinking Nicks. 😀 Is CAI gonna call the lift of Vanessa? Hope not.
Agree with Julianne – he did very well with that Rumba. I liked the Choreo better than Val’s – by a lot. Still a bit too hard in spots. Have to be honest, I missed the dress bit with Vanessa, I will have to rewind.
Bet they still give him 7s even with the claims of his best dance yet. Len, you stingy old goat.
Nancy – this will connect massively with the audience, IMO, so they put her in the 3rd spot to lessen the impact. Miscarriages plural. That’s rough.
Dang…another lift! And this time right in the middle of an (extremely sort) dance. I mean, wasn’t that dance shorter than the other two by a mile?? Beautiful, romantic dance, though. She’s a beautiful woman too.
I like Julianne’s hair tonight…
Great score! Love Emma creeping up on Nancy to give her a hug. 🙂
Love you, Mr. T. You are awesome. And how amazing does Kym look even in rehearsal?
This song makes me cry every damn time. :::sob:::
Massive improvement by Mr. T!! His best dance yet. Love him.
Mr. T is the first celeb tonight to not get an Erin interview – not cool. Val opens his fat mouth to expound along with 5th Harmony and Mr. T gets nothing.
Heather is so….flat. And I’m not buying her crying either. It’s like her Glee Character.
ANOTHER lift – what is that? All dances but one so far? This was choreographed by Maks – only a Cbro puts that much running and stair climbing in a dance. Her dancing was good, but the choreo was sub par. Of course they drool – but she is a PROFESSIONAL DANCER. Yes…I will be repeating that every single week.
Hmmm…they are gushing quite a bit over a dance that was kind of a non-event. Wonder if she’s having trouble with the votes.
Oh come on, seriously? Hugely overscored.
Lindsay’s dress is gorgeous. Davis is doing great job with this dance! Needs to tuck his bum. I didn’t see Lindsay leave the ground either, so it is possible.
Shut up, CAI – dude is a baseball player and I enjoyed his dance much more than the professional dancer’s. I liked Len’s comment – no idea what he said, but I liked it.
So far, Mr. T is the only dancer to not get Erin time. I wonder if that means anything. I guess we’ll see.
Oh boy, David is going to get all the votes tonight since they played the dance live at the banner raising.
Oooo Rashad, you handsome, handsome man. Even cute as a baby. Damn, his brother is handsome too!!
Okay, now I’m crying. That’s what a real man looks like.
And with that, Rashad should be back on top. Best dance of the night, by a mile. Most emotional dance as well.
Fantastic job by Emma Slater. Best contemporary dance since Derek and Kellie.
Well deserved 39 – fantastic!!
Rashad is the second person tonight to get no Erin time, but he did get a lot of Tom time. The show doesn’t seem to be running long either.
Is this a cha cha or a bunch of posing? I keep forgetting Erika is even on this show. Really CAI? Fantastic? Len’s got it right – same ole same ole indeed.
Oh great, Gleb picks up the C-boy habit of grabbing the mic and talking. Just what we need – for all the russians to blend together it to one mouthy, indistinguishable blob.
Ugh. Like we don’t see enough of Ginger Zee.
Simone got hosed on the package. Too short, not enough emotion. I still cried, but I sensed a heavy hand in the editing booth.
Beautiful dress. Beautiful dance…and I’m crying again at the end. She kinda got hosed with a V. Waltz because of the technique required…but dang. Great job again.
Bonner’s package just made me cringe. Ouch. Decent dance, I wasn’t overly impressed. Sharna is choreographing a lot of stopping and starting. It was good, but no better than 8s in my opinion. Gotta agree with Len.
I think the producers should be kicking themselves by not having Rashad going last – his dance was far superior and much more emotional. Dude is going to win this season barring serious manipulation…I’ve been saying it for two weeks now.
Okay, here we go….
Jeopardy – Mr. T and Kym
Jeopardy – Erika and Gleb.
Leaving us tonight is….Mr. T and Kym.
Totally bummed. Court and Vogue called it, I said Erika first, then Mr. T.
Watch out next week Erika.
Another prediction for next week: Rashad, David in the last half hour because they killed it in votes tonight. Normani also in the last half hour because the general audience forgot she danced and she’ll need some help.
Wasn’t impressed. Girl can sing no doubt but I just am not wowed by her.
I appreciate that normani achieved her dream and all that but other than her family stuff (which let me see her real personality/greater insight) the rest kinda just made me go “I get it fifth harmony is a tight group…unless ones name Is Camilla lol”. The singing I could have lived without to be honest. The taller one has a gorgeous voice though. The dance I actually liked so kudos to Val on that. I’d give that a 7 easily. I agreed with Len but loved the emotional aspect the dance for sure. Yeah so I guess this was a good week for her….for once I wasn’t iffy on one of her dances.
CAI is defining a lift? I think she forgets what it means when Heather is on the floor. Either way, Normani, and Val were okay? I was more distracted by Fifth Harmony than their dance
That was a beautiful dance by Normani. Loved it. I know nothing about dance so I’ll defer to the experts on it not being rumba-y enough though.
Rolling my eyes at Inconsistent lift police CAI again. Reading the definition? Someone’s defensive!
Normani can sing, but I thought the rest sounded terrible and distracted from the dance which was only ok for me.
Normani’s Story – great, glad to know that she is very fortunate for her opportunities. Very much a dance from Normani (confident and strong) .. Torn, 5H did a great job with the song, I felt like it took away from Normani a bit. Technically – more Cuban motion, it was a little stiff for me. Loved her dress.
5th Harmony girls kind of suck as singers but the dance hmm I’m with Heidi I didn’t like it Len was right
I actually liked the way they incorporated 5th Harmony- I was worried it would overwhelmed Normani’s performance but it didn’t IMO. Overall, though, I thought it was one of her weaker dances and the focus on the girl group as her mem. year (even though it makes sense) took away from me really learning more about Normani as a person. I still feel like I know nothing about her.
The lift gave it away for me right away that Val is just not playing by the rules ????? What else is new and his rumba style, definitely, is typical Val-hard with little flow to it-I agree with Len’s comments.
Now I see how they fit the group singing into the show-jeez shut up Val!
No way that rumba deserved a friggin 9!!! Yeah right!!! ???
Well at least one of the judges might actually judge them fairly. Yeah, that rumba was staccato and sharp, and that’s just not what a rumba is supposed to be.
But seriously Julianne, get your head out of your rear end and actually judge them based on content.
And yeah, they’re not going in the traditional “pimp spot,” but how is Fifth Harmony performing/having Normani sing during the performance NOT pimping to the extreme?
I really like Normani and she has an amazing voice and is a great dancer but when I see rumba’s I like to see a bit more softness (I always go back to the rumba with Corbin and Karina for that)
I hope Val takes Len’s word and does more with content because I think she has the potential
(also I used to love 5H on XFactor so it’s a throwback seeing them, although some of their fans are a bit extra — like any teen fandom)
Man, I really liked Normani again. In fact, do I dare say she might be my favorite of all of Val’s partners?
Nick and peta were definately interesting this week. Liked thebdsnce could have lived without the whole video package lol. I personally love his fiancée and her level headedess. She evens him out. The dance though was his best yet. Saying that I’d give that an 8.
And way to go, Nick. I didn’t think he would be very good in the beginning. I love that he is proving me wrong. Yay
Don’t watch every year but I really liked Mya and Dmitri. I loved their Rumba and their Tango
Nick is the bachelor – we get it. I loved Peta’s dress. I loved the concept or real aspect of his journey. They’re right this was his best. If he would have finished his lines a bit, I give it an 8. Comment about the Bachelor commercial in the blog – High five, spot on!
Not really a Nick fan, but I thought he seemed in control and his spins (turns?) looked really good to my untrained eye. Peta looks gorgeous tonight. Love her dress and that color on her.
Normani and Val- That was rumba? Hmmm Good on CAI for calling the lift.
Nick and Peta- Well let’start with it was a rumba I’m not crazy about Nick or the Bachelor in general so maybe that’s why the dance didn’t do much for me but he did a pretty good job those scores seem fair.
So, you call out Nicks lift but don’t deduct? I disagree. No lifts in Rumba. Rules are rules. But hmm…maybe Nick is a goner?
I agree that Peta was smart with her choreo this week and even how to use Nick’s assets and in incorporating his fiancé at the end.
Doubt Nick is leaving. And I think that if we complain about calling Derek’s lift when the dance is over, we shouldn’t complain when she gets it right.
Nancy brings out the best in Artem. She is amazing. I’m so glad that she agreed to do the show.
Nancy and artem hit a home run this week in my opinion. Loved every second of that. I’d easily give that a 9. Everything I loved. I’m convinced it’s an ice skater thing.
Wow! Nancy. Her story, and certainly a conversation we need to have more often, not just miscarriages but all mental health. This foxtrot was beautiful – technique, content, story. My gram and I were in love with her at the Olympics and I’m in love with this team now. Can I be Nancy when I grow up? I also really want her dress!
Nancy’s dress was beautiful the dance was beautiful. She is becoming on of my favorite contestants.
OMG I loved Nancy’s dance!!!! I thought it was flawless!! It flowed beautifully!! And I did not expect her story to be about that AT ALL!! For me, that’s something I can, definitely, relate to-made me cry…?????????
I don’t think Nancy’s dance was particularly short but *shrug.* So touched by her story too. Glad she shared it. Saw a few baubles but otherwise a gorgeous gorgeous dance.
Even Artem looks touched listening to her speak with Erin.
I love Nancy and can relate to her feelings on miscarriage. Beautiful dance and I love Nancy and Artem together. Pure dancing, no gimmicks. She seems effortless.
I can totally relate to Nancy. Took me almost 4 years to conceive my son. Then a miscarriage in ’09 Beautiful dance!
Wow Nancy’s story really touched me. And her dance was beautiful! She is getting some votes from me tonight!
Completely off subject…..but did anyone notice who was in the audience while Normani and Val were getting critiqued by the judges? I’m almost certain I saw Jonathan Roberts and Heather Mills (season 4)
Crap there was a lift in Nancy’s fancy?! It went by so fast and it was Sooo pretty I didn’t notice it ?
Mr t had me in tears. After everything (and mods I have great news for you: she had the margins tested and she is officially cancer free so my mom beat cancer) I’m an emotional wreck. So I’d easily give that a 7.
LOVED Nancy’s dance, and you’re right, Heidi, that story is sure to make an impact.
I think that if this is Mr. T’s last week, he will have gone out on a high note.
I can also relate to Mr T as a fellow cancer survivor. April 26th I’ll celebrate 5 years cancer free & my son turns 13 on that day . I’m blessed
It is so nice to see Kym on the floor again. That dance was so full of emotion. We’re tearing up in my house
God bless him he tried Sooo hard and I, actually, thought he led Kym pretty well throughout the dance!
BTW who is the young man they keep showing in the audience? Relation to T? ?
Kym is so, so good with him. I really don’t like the song Amazing Grace – I loved that version, Love Kym’s dress. great scores, great story, great music, great dance. No secret, I love them. His faith is inspiring and this notion with the choir was also a perfect tribute.
#Vin #KellyK ?????????
Mr. T. There are no words. I just reallly hope he some how manages to make it through tonight. If not, I am happy to have watched him on this show.
Excellent news, Vin. So happy to hear it.
Nancy and Mr. T’s dances were beautiful to watch. Mr. T might not be the best on the show, but I would rather watch a dance like that than what Normani did. I’m holding out hope he doesn’t go tonight.
And KellyK, that’s wonderful! I’ve had 3 sister in laws have breast cancer, so I understand what it means to you to hit that mark.
Yeah, a huge one, Anonymous – not a choreographed one like Val’s though. Clearly an accident, I think.
Nancy and Artem- She is one of the most consistent dancers this season. I would not be at all surprised to see her in the finals. Beautiful dance and Artem is really doing some good choreography.
Mr. T and Kym- Very simple probably not enough content but beautiful none the less and he definitely accomplished the goal of making it about his faith.
Yeah… sympathy 7s for Mr. T – he’s outta here.
I’m calling it right now, if Mr T survives tonight’s elimination, he’ll get through next week’s as well with that dance. I’d be worried for Nick and Nancy’s safety next week with these awful running order slots. Hopefully people are voting for them. Nick had his best dance tonight and Nancy has been one of the surprises of the season for me (in a good way).
Hmmm CAI didn’t catch that lift did she? Can’t remember her comments now-oh well Nancy’s scores were pretty good….
Where do I get heather’s jumpsuit?
Heather….now this is what I’m talking about. She is better without maks. This was easily a 9 for me. Finally got to see that umph/personality out there:)
KellyK congrats on being cancer free and having a teenage son after some struggles!
Glad to hear that Mr T and Nancy did well. Love those two and their partners.
Val and Normani are getting special treatment again!!!??? Thank goodness they are in the beginning so I can forget about them. Hoping they will get the Sabrina early exit.
Can’t wait for Rashad and David!
Heather doesn’t bug me as much maybe because she makes me laugh with her sense of humor. And she’s entertaining. And Maks has calmed down so much since the baby! Just don’t want her to win.
This was my least favorite of the dances so far, and yet the judges rave. ugh can they be anymore fake?
Ewwww Len thought it was lovely? I thought it was hectic and frenetic NO JOKE-I agree-you could, definitely, tell Maks choreographed it-way too many steps, lots of traveling around and he picked her up for God’s sake! Isn’t that a lift?! ???
I am emotionally destroyed in the best way by Mr. T. I kind of expected him to be a funny grumpy grandpa initially. With a heart of gold to be sure, but certainly didn’t expect this level of sweet, humble, pious gentleman. He touches my heart.
Heather’s dance was cute. One of my favorite songs. Particularly was tickled by the beginning and end. But not particularly memorable. Feel like it’ll get lost in the shuffle.
And I guess no one gives a shit about the lift rule tonight. I’m almost glad. It’s like it’s forcing CAI to be consistent.
Hi yall, ive been a lurker for a couple seasons now, but have never commented. I was curious if we knew for sure there was an elimination this week? Havent there been some seasons where one week there wasnt an elimination? Im asking because i thought i heard tom say to vote for mr t so that he would be safe next week. I dont have dvr so I cant rewind and listen again but when i heard that, my first thought was that Mr t is safe this week, so possibly no eliminations?
@Heart Thank you! I see Jules & Derek 4.28. Imma tell them my cancer story. I splurged on the 1K Supreme VIP ticket cuz I have a darn good reason to celebrate 🙂
Sorry my computer froze in the middle of my comment. I was referring to Heather’s dance. I just get nothing from her and the judges make me extremely annoyed.
Forever Young makes me emotional too. The women’s dresses are so pretty tonight. David makes me so happy when he dances. It’s always just pure joy.
Loved David and Lindsay’s video but the dance wasn’t a standout for me to be honest. Not my fav from him. I’d give that a 7.
David looked a bit bent in the knee. Not his best dance. Let’s see how the judges score. But I love him,
I love Lindsay’s choreography!! Soo beautiful!! Thought he was a little heavy-footed in the beginning but then he found his balance and lightened up and he did well!!
David Ross is living proof that there are nice guys out there. I enjoyed his dance and believe he will be around for awhile.
The image of Len speaking baseball should be a gif lol. That was just so happily unexpected and hysterical to say the least. Love love love how the cubs played the dance at wriggly too.
Heather and Alan- MEH I guess the scores don’t surprise me WHATEVER but that was NOT the best dance for me. And I know Tom was kidding but Maks producing GAG
David and Lindsay Nice dance 8 sounds right
I liked Heathers dance, but not as much as last week. She performed it well it just wasn’t my favorite choreo. The beginning with her husband was cute though.
David was quite skippy in his waltz. Love his story though. What an amazing last career game. Cute kids.
Jeez my mom just texted me and said WTH Erika looks like a “____hooker”! ????????
Wondering the same thing about Mr. T Heidi-no interview with Erin and they were kind with their scores-is he going home tonight? ??
I’m feeling all the feels tonight. My dad fought in Vietnam. He was closed off from us & became an alcoholic. So again, I can relate to Rashad. Beautiful dance!
OMG I’m balling over here ??? his story and his dance was soooo touching and emotional….
Beautiful dance from Rashad & Emma. Awesome lifts, great emotion. Made me cry.
I’m now crying. Rashad is a beautiful man that has his priorities right. A truly beautiful dance. He better get at least one 10.
Rashad Emma just wowed me. Easily a 10. If only there was an 11.
I am speechless. I don’t cry very easily but wow, that dance was truly something special and such beautiful choreography by Emma.
Rashad’s vulnerability on the show is what makes him so special and a beautiful dancer. This is one of my favorite partnerships in years.
I feel for the couple that has to follow that. Rashad just cemented himself as the front runner to win this season.
Really Len? You just couldn’t have given the guy a 10? ?
I’m speechless,,,
YAY Rashad & Emma got the first 10’s and an almost perfect score!! Well deserved. Moving backstory.
David’s dance was pretty but the judge’s critiques were on point. Glad to see him do a serious dance though. Looking forward to seeing him for many more weeks.
Rashad…that was a whole other level. The emotion. The beauty…39 indeed. They better make the final. Still tearing up!
Rasha and Emma-My pick to win it all. That was magic.
They always say that, Houston – elimination or not.
Rashad’s dance is one of my favorite contemporary dances ever done on the show. The excellent dancing, the incredible choreo, and his story of selfless love. He really is the entire package.
With regard to David, I got at least half a dozen texts from friends/family at Wrigley telling me about this video stream. People went wild for it. Such a classy move by the Cubs.
Thunderstorms rolled through just as DWTS began. With all the thunder and lightning my reception wasn’t great but I did enjoy Nancy’s dance. I missed Mr. T and Heather since there was a tornado warning and the TV station went to the weather until 9, but I don’t think I missed much. I really wanted to see Rashad tonight and I am so glad I did. That was so beautiful!!! Emma did a wonderful job choreographing. These two are still my favorites.
Rashad needed to come back from last week and he is an amazing contemporary dancer. That was one of the greatest contemporary dances we’ve had on this show
Erika could have had a moment and she went for it. Liked it. I wouldn’t give it anything higher than a 7.
Erika is just a non-entity to me. She has no story. She only got where she is because she’s a pretty blonde. She SHOULD go home now! Bye Felicia!
No pimpage necessary. Emma and Rashad have it all. That was pure magic.
I, actually, thought she sounded more genuine, in her package, than she has ever sounded but that was not a Cha Cha LOL Come on Gleb-enough is enough!!
Eryka can go anytime
Did Ginger REALLY need to speak? Cmon. Time filler? I wanna hear CURRENT contestants not 3rd place PIMPED contestants from 2 seasons ago.
Your wish is my command. I had to PVR tonight and just started watching. I’ll time the packages, dances and time with judges and Erin.
I’m wondering why so much attention to Normani – are her votes less? That was a very athletic Rumba and I prefer one that is in more control and slow. Oh well, we will see her in the finals. I hope Nancy is in the finals – she’s improving every week and seems so nice and grateful.
I still don’t get how Erika made it? She made it because she is a housewife? What else does she do? I didn’t watch the dance. Needed to switch the laundry and this seemed like a good time. I don’t think I missed much.
Simone did start that dance crying-I don’t know how she got through it one piece!! I agree-it was her best dance yet!! Just beautiful!! Great choreography by Sasha!! ?????????
I’m in awe of Simone. Any style and she does well. She nailed it this week. I’d easily give that a 10. Between her, mr t, Nancy and rashad I really am seeing more special than the norm when it comes to athletes.
Did anyone completely forget about Bonner? I honestly thought we were done
I kind of felt they rushed the judges’ comments after Simone’s dance. I thought it was beautiful and I feel like they didn’t comment on her story like everyone else’s
To think what Simone’s life may have been like had her Dad not taken her in. Would she still be the best gymnast of all time?
Beautiful dance. So much emotion. Great job by Sasha on the choreo
Beautiful dance from Simone! Her package was posted by People mag earlier today. Same exact package we just saw!
This show got me like…….damn dusty house :'(
Loved Bonner’s package-so raw and honest and true to him-I hope his dance redeems himself this week….
Sorry, Simone, no 10’s for you because you had a dance that required actual technique and rules and can’t do lifts.
That’s why Rashad’s dance irked me because how do you compete with other dances that need technique and can’t rely on 5/6 lifts.
It’s good dance, but it feels like cheating when you get that style on this theme week against someone doing a Waltz or Cha Cha.
I f I wer to compare Simone and Nancy because a lot of choreography looked similar lots of under over arms etc I think Nancy has much better flow and yet Simone gets scored significantly higher
Lots of smoke and mirrors and still not a lot of good dancing
I loved whatever that was in the beginning with 2 Bonners-really cool!! He was pretty smooth in the dance!! I thought he did well-I agree with Julianne-anything standard ballroom suits him best!
That is a lot of bs for Bonner
Queen Emma has been overlooked far too long. She is killing it this season. No more crappy partners for her. I want them in the finals so bad.
David is great, but I thought this was one of his weakest dances. I have a feeling his fanbase will take out a few favorites this season. Kind of sad in a way.
Very sad that Mr T is leaving over Eryka boo his
Major bummer 🙁 Erika? You’re on notice! Ya needs ya go!
I am Sooo friggin bummed to see T and Kym going home:(((( Sooo undeserving, I don’t care what the scores or votes say….?
Bonner and sharna were just kinda there for me. Was expecting more. As for mr t: I am forever a fan and he is a class act. Rock on sir.
Loved Simone.
I think I expected more from Bonner and Sharna, particularly for going last. I think the song/tone was wrong for the story and thus took out a lot of the emotional resonance. And the dance was just okay. Great for no experience, but Rashad stole the show. 8s were correct.
I would’ve preferred to lose Erika over T, but I’m not shocked to see him go. Glad he went out on a high note too. Bless his heart.
Sharna looks very pretty and Bonner very handsome. That’s all I have to say about the 2 of them.
So sad Mr.T is going home. Wish it was Erika. Too bad.
My votes are going to Nancy and Rashad tonight.
Thank you for this thread, Princess Heidi.
Not surprised Mr T went
Erika Heather and Nick can be the next ones to go and I won’t be the least bit disappointed
The rest are so awesome I’ll be fine with whomever wins
David had an “off week” but I still very much enjoyed his dance. I am pulling for a final four of David, Simone, Rashad and Nancy.
I don’t think David actually had an off week – he danced very well, IMO.
I don’t see Gramps taking out Rashad or Simone. Everyone else is fair game though. But his technique needs work. Erika should go next week, then Bonner or Nick, order matters not. Erika has no story..no personality. She’s sexy & has a Lamborghini whoop-de-do!
I dunno, Casanova, I think Simone had the superior dance tonight and it was largely due to choreo. I think Sasha did better than Artem.
Nancy, Mr T, Rashad, Simone. These four won the night for me, all of them amazing. So good to see pros treated awfully by the show for years prove what they can do with capable partners. So happy for all of them. Rashad is taking that trophy home bar some serious manipulation.
I agree, Matt, but not Rashad’s fault. Nature of this show for quite a few seasons now, unfortunately. Luckily, Simone isn’t in any danger this week and she will likely get contemporary when the competition is much tighter.
Mr. T didn’t cover the spread, JD – he might have gotten more votes, but not enough to get past her.
Thanks, LisaC – I’ll be curious to see what you come up with.
David was overscored. I would’ve given him (8,7,7,7) for his not-so-smooth Waltz.
Mr. T was also overscored, but he was leaving anyways so they let him leave on a high note. It was definitely his time to go. I just feel bad for Kym leaving so soon.
I absolutely loved Heather’s Cha-Cha, but after 19 seasons of CAI repeating herself, why oh why put that unnecessary lift? Keep at least one foot on the damn floor, please.
What do the producers have against Simone? She’s still one of my favorites, and the one i’m voting for.
Nancy,Rashad,Mr.T and Bonner had me in tears. Just beautiful. I’m disappointed that Mr.T left before Erika but I’m happy he left on a high note with dancing his best dance tonight
I don’t even think Eryka is sexy, I think she was very stiff on that Cha Cha. She dresses a certain way, but sexy is from within. This was more like costume porn, but not enough dance. Marks were generous.
It wasn’t an off week for David, that’s how he dances, technically not very good, bum out, hoppy, but to expect anything more just doesn’t align with what we’ve seen from him so far. I did expect something more emotional, however. It for me didn’t connect on that level. Marks were as expected.
Heather’s cha cha was good, but did I really care? I think the package was deliberately shallow because if she also did an emotional backstory it would be difficult to not give her high scores. Marks as expected.
Normani’s Rumba wasn’t good. Val is getting by on fumes right now and it’s unfair to those who are really working technique. Yes she does stacatto well. What else can she do? A deliberate lift is just an fu to the judges. Not cool. Marks all over the map. I agree with Len.
Nancy and Artem were very sweet, I loved the routine, saw the lift and held my breath thinking they were going to get docked. Apparently they either didn’t see it or ignored it because unlike it being deliberate, they weren’t going to give her higher than an 8 anyway. Except for Len. Thanks Len. Marks were low if they really believe she’s a frontrunner then mark her that way.
Rashad was great. This guy can emote like no one’s business. His ballroom and latin need work, but this contemporary should give him a lot of style points this week. The show is more than contemporary, but he’s the best contemporary dancer this show has had. Marks were high, but he deserved at least one 10
Bonner was given a lot of praise for basically doing what he always does, but he just knew to hide his bowed legs better this week. He looks good in hold when he just stands there, but his footwork is all over the place. There really isn’t much flow to his dancing, but Sharna has figured out how to fly around him. One point below Nancy? GTFO
Simone and Sasha got 9’s across the board. Now I don’t think that’s completely out of line, and yet that was supposed to be a VWaltz, and this does not have the proper flow of a great VWaltz. It felt more like Foxtrot choreography.
Nick’s Rumba choreography was the corniest piece of garbage I’ve seen this season. Gleb choreo on steroids. However, when he started to dance with Peta he wasn’t bad, and did have some decent hip action. Marks were reasonable.
Next week I do hope Eryka leaves. I don’t like the downgrading of Nancy so I worry for her as an early boot.
Is it just me, or did we hear nothing of Maks’ injury tonight? They have been ramming it down our throats for the past 2 weeks and being dramatic about when will Maks return to the ballroom, now all of a sudden nothing? Makes me think that either he’s out for an extended period of time, or he will be back next week, but they will play the whole will he or won’t he dance all night ending the show with the 2 of them dancing in the pimp spot and probably getting the first perfect score of the season.
To be fair this theory is based on no facts, just my own cynicism and the fact that Heather is so flat that I truly believe the Maks injury saga is the only interesting thing about her “journey” so the producers will milk it for all it’s worth. But we shall see…
I think tonight may have been the nail in the coffin for any hopes Heather had of going to the finals and maybe even the semifinals. She really needed to connect strongly to the audience tonight, but her dance seemed like it would probably be one of the ones that gets lost in the pack of stories like Nancy, Mr. T, Rashad, and Simone.
Love Emma, I have enjoyed her with all her partners. Her smile while hugging Rashad after the scores was absolute pure joy – so happy for her to have the opportunity to have Rashad as a partner and show us more of herself through this partnership. Rashad is a great role model, I hope kids at home are listening to all parts of his story.
I too was expecting a bit more from Bonner and Sharna but I did enjoy the dance. I can’t imagine how difficult the last year has been on him, so kudos to him for daring to dance in front of millions of people so he can tell his story.
I am enjoying getting to know Nancy better, she is wonderful.
And David has been a complete surprise for me, tonight was not his best dance but his personality just pulls me in.
I think Emma and Rashad’s dance had me crying as much as Bindi and Derek. Just gorgeous. And I’m loving Artem with Nancy, he seems so happy and at ease.
What a good show we had tonight! My favorite dances were Nick and Peta’s, Heather and Alan’s and Rashad and Emma’s. Loved Nick’s rumba and I feel that tonight we got Peta back! Tonight was my first time voting for Heather. But tonight everything (the package, the song, the routine, the production) touched my heart. And Rashad and Emma… Wow just wow! Emma looked beautiful as always but I was floored by how well he danced. I voted for them 20 times! Simone’s story and package were beautiful but that routine didn’t moved me as much as the others. And Sharna and Cowboy B. were great tonight but not enough to move me to vote for them.
On a separate note, I just wanted to say how much I miss All Access. The show’s just not the same without it and those Facebook live interventions are just blah. I miss Dominic’s silliness. I wonder why they got rid of it. IMO, It was a bad move.
I felt bad for Bonner that none of his family was there.Ty Murray,his girlfriend and another guy from PBR were there but what about his family?If my son had gone through what he has, I would be front and center when his story was being told.I know they interviewed them for the package but it is not the same as having family there.
First off gotta just say that I was so happily shocked to see miss Chelsie Hightower back in the ballroom. I miss her and I hope someday the production can swallow their pride and ask her to come back. Also shout out to the camera man who caught Emma’s eye roll during Normani’s dance (??) post interview with Erin.
I absolutely agree with PH when she mentioned Len’s critique, it did sound an awful lot like he admitted to using kid gloves if you will with Normani, and to all the Harmonizers out there: if you want to see your girl in the finale you all better come together now and vote. We’re almost halfway through the competition and notoriously young stars with a young fanbase tend to get less and less votes as the more time goes by. I personally think it’s laziness, they think “oh I can just vote next week”, but what if there isn’t next week? Normani isn’t going anywhere yet, but consider this a warning Harmonizers ?
I have to disagree with the judges as far as Nick is concerned. I felt like there was more of a disconnect between Nick & Peta. Vanessa & Nick’s bit at the end of the dance definitely provided enough proof for that. Technically speaking though, Nick had the better Rumba, more content, more control, more Nick.
Nancy could win this, I cannot express how much I get this overwhelming feeling when she is on camera. She’s such a classy lady too boot with more to her. She just has such a way with presenting herself to the public eye, and personally I feel that’s a commonality all past winners of this show (except Rumer Willis) have demonstrated.
So sad to see Mr. T go home tonight, but on a grand scale he’s been one of the more impressive older celebrities to Grace this show. He’s had both steady improvement, and inspiring poise. I’m gonna miss him! ?
Heather is at this point just hovering above a shark tank by fishing line. Pardon the metaphor, but I’m just over her (I think). Her dancing is so great it’s almost boring, like give me a damn sense of dismay because a style is too outside her range. I say bring back the week with absolutely unique styles like Bhangra and Polka, and then I might be able to come to terms that Heather is trying.
David Ross is the biggest surprise for me tonight, might not have been the strongest dance from him, but he’s got such a huge heart! Going forward though I would say he should definitely be more aware of his partnering with Lindsay in ballroom. The only thing that separates him from Rashad I think (and to somewhat of an extent Bonner) is his ability to lead Lindsay.
Rashad was great tonight, but I fear his too cool on camera attitude might fade him into the woodwork.
Erika isn’t afraid to admit that she doesn’t want to change herself, and I appreciate the message her dance sent but Gleb should take this jeopardy shot as a wake up call.
I didn’t know Simone was adopted, but it really shows her character as the fighter she is. This dance should’ve gotten one 10 though.
Bonner is becoming non event for me and Sharna’s stop and go choreography isn’t helping that. Quite surprised Len didn’t bring down the hammer a bit more, but he’s not Heather so I can see why he wouldn’t.
Who is the guest judge next week and who is he replacing?
Normani – Sweet personal story with her grandma. Moves beautifully but I didn’t see those key Rumba hip movements that I have come to expect. Fair overall score. I just feel no connection to her.
Nick – Personal story is reality gag for me. I found the make-out session with the girlfriend very awkward. I would have given all 7’s.
Nancy – Love, love, love Nancy! So heartfelt. She’s my favorite person on the show & I really want to see her in the finals. She’s so real, kind & relatable. And I love Artem with her.
Mr. T – Love his faith. He’s so lovely. Another one that made me tear up. One of my favorite songs ever. Oh good, I was hoping for all 7’s.
Grandpa Rossy – Loved the change in style, very dapper. And I’m just a big fan.Go Cubs! Footwork a little choppy at times but I don’t care. Love him! Thrilled he got 3 8’s!
Rashad – Major tears with his Dad. Such beautiful choreography. And such a treat to get to see Emma do more with her skills & a star partner. I want to see them win the mirrorball.
Erika – I said “same old, same old” as I was watching & Len thought so too. Huh, I thought that was over scored.
Simone – She’s amazing. I knew this story from the Olympics but what an honor to get to hear it form Simone and her parents. It’s so nice to see there’s still good in the world.
Bonner – One heck of a comeback from that injury. His best dance. That really suited him. I don’t know how many ballroom dances are left for him to do, but I hope it lasts.
Loved seeing Ty and Chelsie in the audience!
Bye Mr. T. It was a pleasure getting to know you.
Also slightly concerned that Heather’s getting all the ballroom and Latin out of the way early. When the time comes she’ll get Contemporary and Jazz which will piss me off if they wait until the endgame to ensure that she’s at least making the quarter finals.
So by my count, this is the fourth straight week that Simone has not had a post-dance interview with Erin. Now, I much prefer that her parents got on instead, but Normani got an Erin interview plus her girl group there too. Really, someone should tweet Tom and Erin that we are noticing.
So sad to see Mr. T leave but so uplifted to have seen him the last few weeks. He gave heart to a show that is vapid way too much to be enjoyable sometimes.
Hilarious to see Heather vigorously nod her head and say her dance was sooo hard to learn! Yeah, just because you say it, doesn’t mean I buy it Heather.
Did Tom say something about the week after Disney week? I might have just heard wrong, but I thought I would ask.
This overly produced, manipulated, show that I have watched for many years & is wearing thin could really redeem itself for this one season for me by giving me Emma, Sasha and Artem in the final 3. And that it would be well deserved because they really do have the right partners at the right time, would be amazing.
I thought I understood the scoring on this show, but I’m all goofed up again. I’ve started to compare by judge and can’t seem to understand the ‘grading’ that is done. On pure dancing, David’s dance was good, but not great. Nancy’s dance was MUCH better, but Julianne and Bruno both gave her the same score. Her emotions were better, overall performance was better, but still only one point. Is she being punished for having choreography background from skating? They call him the old man, but David is eight years younger than Nancy.
@MariaD Yes! I would actually watch live vs. catching the dances on You Tube where I end up fast forwarding most of the judging and skybox.
I have no idea what they’re pulling on Nancy and Simone, but something is definitely going on, and I may have to look for Erin’s bit with Valmani just to see Emma’s reaction ?
My thoughts on the events, in the order of the dances:
Normani (Val): Well, they certainly pulled out all the stops to make this as memorable as possible, didn’t they? Going first, Fifth Harmony performing the song, with Normani singing before she danced? Definite pimping going on here. A sweet MMY story, but ultimately not terribly memorable or heartstring-pulling. The dance itself wasn’t terrible, but it was definitely too staccato/choppy for a rumba. Didn’t really see why the judges needed to praise it so heavily. Honestly, CAI’s “lift policing” generally annoys the crap out of me, but I’m glad she did it here, it was SO blatant! And where the hell did that 9 come from, Bruno? What are you smoking? Overall, a decent dance, but I don’t think it’s going to do her any favors in winning over the general audience.
Nick (Peta): Wow, did they get screwed by TPTB this week or what? Going second – already a crappy position – between the pimpage of the first dance and the very emotional/heartwrenching package that Nancy had. It didn’t help that they had the same dance as Normani. I’m also prone to distrusting the “I found love” spiel from the Bachelor/Bachelorette, because it so often falls apart. Overall, I think it was one of his better dances, and I think he’ll be safe for a couple of weeks. I sincerely doubt he’s going home before Erika, but after that he may be in danger.
Nancy (Artem): Nancy was already one of my favorites this season. I love her attitude, and her partnership with Artem is ADORABLE. I’m also glad she managed to avoid bringing up the Tonya Harding drama and still managed to have a memorable package. That package had me near tears (and I am not a big crier). And I think it’s a story that a lot of people can relate to – who doesn’t know somebody, or been somebody, who has gone through a miscarriage? I loved their dance, though I did see that lift. Glad they didn’t notice though, or at least didn’t care, because I think it would have been an excuse to dock her score below Normani’s, and I think she did a clearly better dance. I was a bit peeved with Bruno’s comments about her frame; where was the nitpicky criticism while you were flailing about Normani’s stilted rumba? The running order certainly didn’t do her any favors, but I think her story and the dance, especially the former, will make up for that to a point. I don’t think it put her in any danger. I think Erika’s next on the chopping block, and it wouldn’t surprise me if Nick was close behind her.
Mr. T (Kym) I think this was a good dance to go out on, though I think this could have bought him another week if he’d made it through. I think the 7s were mostly because the judges knew he was going home, and wanted to send him out on a high note. I liked Mr. T, but I’m not surprised to see him go.
Heather (Alan/Maks): I think the package was sweet, but again, not memorable. Marriage in and of itself is not very memorable, at least compared to the other stories tonight. I liked her dance, but it wasn’t demonstrably different than any other dance she’s done, quality or emotion-wise. Cha-cha’s not really the most memorable dance, and she’s already done the fun/energetic dances. Plus the messing around before they started was annoying. And are lifts allowed in the cha-cha? Cause that was BLATANT, and not called out. A very good performance, but not likely to score her any points with the general audience.
David (Lindsay): I think he handled this dance well, and I certainly like it better than the Magic Mike dance he did last week (can we please stop with those?). And Lindsay managed to keep her feet on the floor! Idk what CAI’s issue was, I’d have been fine with straight 8s. Them playing his dance at Wrigley Field is certainly going to help him get votes, and he was already doing just fine in that department.
Rashad (Emma): A memorable story, a great dance, and a good attitude. Recipe for success. I think Rashad is definitely doing better than TPTB thought he would, and I think he’s got real staying power. I’m good with that. I’d rather not have Heather make the finals, with how obvious of a ringer she is, and I’m honestly okay if he knocks out Normani too. I’m glad Emma FINALLY has a partner that has a chance.
Erika (Gleb): Meh. That was my reaction. I’m also still wondering how she “made it.” There’s no mention of a singing career, or a career of any other kind. And the dance seemed like a lot of stopping and going. Another pro that had a dance that did absolutely no favors for her, and I think it might have been the nail in the coffin.
Simone (Sasha): I agree with Heidi on Simone kinda getting hosed with the dance she was given, but I think she still pulled out a great dance. Another heartwrenching package – I’m glad she’s got parents that love her now. And the “muscle memory” comment was great. Pretty fair scores I think, and she’s in no danger.
Bonner (Sharna): Bonner has honestly been a bit of a non-event for me this season, and this foxtrot didn’t change that. It was good, and an improvement, but not stellar. Idk why he had the pimp spot, it probably would have been a better idea for Rashad or Simone to have it. He’s probably safe, at least for now.
Not a bad night, and I’m cautiously looking forward to what everyone does for Disney Week. But please, no more holographic gazelles.
Finally finished watching.
That chacha had pure Maks choreo written all over it. I barely even noticed Alan it could have been Maks dancing as well. Obv I dont 100% know but it’s weird how after so many seasons you pick up on little choreo bits the pros always dabble in.
Rashad and Emma stole the show for me. And WOW Emma is really making her celeb shine and her dance skills as well. She dances like a piece of silk fabric blowing through the wind! Beautiful!
Rashad & Emma were the best tonight and I am rooting for them to win this season!!
I think there was way too much fabric in Simone’s dress and it sort of swallowed her up. Her costumes should be closer to her body.
Could I have a little fan help?
Has Emma ever had a perfect score? I was watching with a friend and neither of us could recall one that would be hers alone. (not a trio/group dance) Thanks!
This year could do it, and well deserved.
Thanks, Lisa – I will probably do a post on it later, or include it with my Numbers post.
I think you have the expression wrong, Nick. If the producers ever asked, Chelsie is the one who would have to swallow her pride, not them.
The problem with Heather is that a dancer that good needs a choreographer that is out of this world. Who comes up with dances so amazing that you can overlook the fact that she’s a professional dancer. That person doesn’t currently exist on DWTS.
As always, SueB, they don’t score the dancers in comparison to each other, only according to their own expectations of that dancer. It’s fine until about week 5 or 6…problem is, they tend to keep doing it all the way to the end.
…and one other thing, please.
Does anyone else think energy is not translating well through Heathers pelvis? Possibly an anterior tilt? Her Cha Cha just looked odd to me.
Something Mark Ballas once said, sticks in my brain. “It’s a reality show, not a dance competition” SHRUG.
I’m completely over Nick and his reality show drama. His face sucking scene with his girlfriend was in absolute poor taste. Much like every comment that comes out of Brunos’ mouth.
So much uncomfortable-ness. The show has run it’s course, I’m finished watching. I’ll get my dance fix from watching YOUTUBE.
So I was able to watch 4 of 5 of my fave couples’ dances on YT. I don’t know if it means anything, but David and Lindsay’s dance hasn’t been uploaded to the DWTS channel yet. Nancy and Artem are a good team; loved their Foxtrot. Mr. T and Kym–aww, they made me misty. Kym created a wonderful dance for Mr. T. Rashad and Emma–loved them even more! Can we have more Rashads and Emmas in this world, please? Then there was sweet Simone. So happy that she found a loving and supportive family. I think Sasha choreographed a very nice dance for her. I just didn’t like the top part of her dress.
Mods, looking forward to your rankings and numbers posts. Huge thanks for all you do here!
@ Lady Ebet: I’m also jonesing for some All Access! So sorry it is not around this season. I do not watch non-public, or Facebook, content.
I can’t believe the first 16 minutes of the show were devoted to one contestant… or can I?
My mr paused his video game to watch Mr T, and we didn’t have a dry eye in the house. I also enjoyed his classy, upbeat exit.
All my love and votes went straight to Emma and Rashad <3
What do the producers have so vehemently against Simone? If aNY body has aNY ideas, i’d love to hear. I asked earlier, but never got an answer. As far as the producers go, they need to be taken out and stoned!
I don’t think the producers have anything against Simone. Constant late running orders, her Viennese Waltz last night whilst beautiful, was out of hold a lot yet wasn’t called out by Len. I think her treatment has been just fine to be honest, in fact I’m starting to think TPTB are seeing a Rashad Simone final two as a favourable outcome with Esha as their partners.
Rachel, you may not like the producers, but, “taken out and stoned”? That’s going too far. Please, settle down with that that kind of talk. Anyway, I agree with M8. I think they just want a little more from her. I also think she will make the finals.
All Val cares about is Val, even if he’s trying to make it look like he cares about his partner. Kym cares about her partner and knows when to shut up and let her partner do the talking (and I mean ALL the talking) and let it be about her partner. Val needs to get lessons on class and humility from Kym.
I have no idea what Len said to David either but that was funny. Haha!!
Erika and Jules looked like twins last night!
I thought I was going to cry when Rashad ran to his dad and hugged him after the dance. Tom was always rushing people when producers yell in his earpiece but I’m glad Tom backed off and let Rashad take time to be with his parents, hugging them.
I know some people still don’t like Bonner but I’m hoping last night helped people respect him more. That was a serious accident! His Foxtrot may not have been outstanding but I’d say it was an improvement from his Charleston. I think Bonner is now beginning to get a little more confident in his movement and trusting Sharna more. If this continue, he could make it farther than I originally thought.
Can we make Maks producer so he can get Alan as pro on the show?
Yeah, I’m still finding Ericka forgetful. I would’ve rather see her leave than Mr. T. I was convinced Bonner had a great chance was leaving last night but after that Foxtrot and if he keeps it up, he could last longer but again, Ericka is still forgetful to me. Next week, I think it will be Ericka unless Bonner wrecks his dance again, getting horrible scores. As we know, scores matter quite little and after last night, Bonner will probably get lots of votes and be safe next week too. Mr. T should’ve stayed even though he wasn’t a great dancer. He’s just a really nice guy.
What an emotional night! Did anyone run out of tissues before 10pm eastern time? Haha
I’m so afraid that Nancy is going to get “Sabrina’d” and end up in 7th place. I have this feeling the producers are doing a gender balance. I mean Bonner 3 pts higher than Nancy?
@Roy Sabrina’s elimination was not about the producers doing their best to get her out. Her problem was that most of the people who were here fans (or had even heard of her, for that matter) were pre-teen girls, and that sort of fanbase really doesn’t line up at all with the viewing audience of DWTS. Nancy, on the other hand, is likely remembered fondly by many of the middle-aged women who are the majority of the viewing audience. She’s probably getting a much larger share of the votes than Sabrina was.
Just watched the YouTube video of Heather’s dance. That choreo just didn’t make any sense!!! I really liked the choreo for last week’s tango; comparatively, this week’s cha cha fell super flat. Shame.
I came on here to see if anyone knew who choreographed it, and I’ve learned that Maks choreographed it. Shocker.
Power rankings are up: https://www.puredwts.com/2017/04/11/puredwts-season-24-week-4-power-rankings/
Jen, I kinda agree with you. I hated that part and thought it was so cheap. I have nieces who watch the show and the amount of raunch and lack of clothing is getting a bit too much. I’m trying to decrease the amount of sexual innuendos my neices are exposed to through pop culture…not increase it.
M8, a final two with Sasha and Emma and a one of the fam folks as a third is what I’m seeing in the eyes of TPTB as well. I don’t think they initially wanted it to be that way, but I think the voters/viewers have spoken and hopefully TPTB bs plans of having Maks or Val win are being ruined.
My Final 4 hopefully:
1. Emma and Rashad: I’d like them to win actually.
2. Sasha and Simone: 2nd would be awesome
3. Normani and Val: ONLY because I actually like Normani.
4. David and Lindsay
If that’s how you feel, Jeh, fine – but don’t keep posting here unless you’re actually watching. We don’t need your opinion repeated 500 times.
Back in Sabrina’s time, we didn’t have NEARLY the producer manipulation that occurs now. It happened, it just wasn’t as rampant. Sabrina’s problem was all about her fanbase.