DWTS Season 15 – All Star Cast Wish List
So what I’m going to do is start with a series of polls: namely you get to choose who YOU want to see from every season of Dancing with the Stars from Season 1 all the way to Season 14. The polls will be up for a few days… and once the polls are closed I will personally draw up how the top celebrities did in their season in comparison to the averaged data from all the seasons.
At the end of all the chosen celebrities I will create a mock elimination post and hopefully by then we’ll know who would REALLY be cast and I will do attempt to do the same for the casted celebrities – hopefully – before the show starts in September again.
Excited? Well you better be… soon you’ll have an example in the form of Mario Lopez and later of Mel B since they are the only two that we know of that has been approached for the All-Star season. If they end up being top in the poll of their respective seasons, wonderful! If not, well then those are freebie posts for you š
EVAN LYSACEK AND ANNA TREBUNSKAYA
how about season 11? I’d pick Kyle.
All the seasons should be there. Just click refresh on your browser.
I loveee Carson, but I do not want him on. He is a bad dancer and I want to see great dancing.
I voted for Jack in Season 14, but quite honestly, I’d rather have no on from Season 14. I feel like it’s too soon.
Marianya, thank you for doing this. I know it might be a lot to ask, but do you think we could get a poll of who we do NOT want to be on?
I chose:
Kelly Monaco
Lisa Rinna
Joey Lawrence
Joey Fatone
Mel B
Jason Taylor
Lance Bass
Melissa Rycroft
Kelly Osborne
Evan Lysacek
Audrina Patridge
Ralph Macchio
Carson Kressley
Maria Menounos
@Violet – That’s almost too much to try… since there have been so many celebrities in the past 14 seasons. I’ll see what I can do.
Geez, that was hard. A few of the seasons I had multiple choices and I couldn’t decide…
This was fun! Thank You! š
Thanks, Marianya. I understand if it isn’t possible, or course!
I voted for one each season, but it doesn’t really reflect how I feel as some seasons had a few I’d like to see back, some maybe only one. Still interesting to see how it comes out.
@Jess – I was thinking about doing multiple choice, but I think I like forcing people to choose.. don’t worry, you all would get a multiple choice poll after a week of this one.
I liked having to choose one from each season. It ended up being easier than I thought it would be.
I’d actually really like to see Chuck Wicks back. He was eliminated right when he started to do well. Put him with Peta! Oh! That would be amazing.
Er, I don’t know. I found Chuck to be really blah. I wasn’t surprised when Julianne cut him loose. š
on some of the seasons it was really hard to decide on just one celeb. When in doubt, I went with who I would like to see dance/compete again vs. someone I grew to love on the show (Chynna instead of Carson, for instance; or Gilles instead of Ty)
I would love to see Carson again and again and again, but Marianya made me choose only 1 (smart girl, that Marianya, otherwise what a mess this poll would be LOL)
I voted for:
Joey McIntyre
Tia Carera(only one I remember from Season 2)
Sara Evans (because she had to withdraw due to personal reasons/to deal with a divorce and put her kids first)
Joey Fatone(okay I admit I just want a Backstreet boy or *NSYNC person on the show)
Sabrina Bryan(she was gipped during her season)
Marlee Matlin
Misty May-Treaner(she had to withdraw due to injury I say give her a second chance)
Giles Marini(do I need to explain this one? can we say sexy eye candy?)
Loius Vito( he was cute and looked really cute with Chelsie, but if not him then Aaron Carter to shut my 10yrold inner child up)
Erin Andrews(or Evan Lysacheck since both were gipped during their season and they deserve a second chance)
Kyle Massey
Ralph Macchio(another star who was gipped)
Carson Kressley(but if he cannot do it then I guess Nancy since she would most likely get Tristan again and the show needs more “luck of the Irish”)
Maria Menounos(or Roshon Fegan or Melissa Gilbert I will take any of those three)
Some are the stars I remember, others were gipped during their season, and some I just want back so I can see the pro again.
Thanks Marianya! š
I did not vote for any past winners – even the ones I really liked. Some things are best left in affectionate memories.
I agree that some seasons there were lots who I would like to see again and some seasons where it was tricky to find one. Agree that Season 14 is just too soon for celebrities to return.
Also – it really depends on who they would be partnered with. Some celebs didn’t do well with their pro partners, but I think had potential to do better with another dancer’s teaching approach.
Anyhow, thanks so much for doing this. Really good to have something to think about during the off season.
So after i voted i saw how the voting is going. Ouch for some of them. I felt bad for Buzz Aldrin and voted for him (kinda felt obligated since he is antional treasure). so that explains why he hasa vote lol. besides that i voted for the strongest dancers that haven’t won (except for season one and season season 13……voted for j.r. and kelly)
sorry *national
I thought I submitted a post earlier but I don’t see it. Hope I’m not repeating this..
I picked someone from every season. IMO it would be cool to have one contestant from each season for the All Star Season.
I definitely voted to have Maria Menounos return w/Derek!-hopefully~~ She said she’d do it in a heartbeat if asked by the show. Plus I’ve said this before, I’d love to see how she would do on the w/o injuries. She was a true competitor and fun to watch. How about Mario & Maria — like an Extra showdown.
Also would like to see Kelly Monaco, Mya & Toni Braxton return..
Hope they pick some good contestants, this has the potential of being great if they put it together right.
i would love to see an extra showdown but i don’t see hows that is possible with both host on the show it’ll be hard for the show to report their segments. Maria also said in interviews after the one of the dwts shows she doesn’t think extra will give her the time off for another season that is so close to each other
I mean both extra hosts on the same season i can’t see them letting both Maria and Mario competing on the same season due to how big of a commitment they’ll need to have towards both shows
Jeff,
I understand what you’re saying they do have two other co-hosts though. Wishful thinking, I suppose. If I had a choice it would be Maria again. I just loved her partnership with Derek!!!
I wanted to choose a top 12 for my wish list, but it was just too hard! I tried to narrow it down as much as I could (and didn’t include seasons 13/14 because I thought it was too short of a time ago to bring those contestants back) while including both good dancers and fun personalities and these were my picks:
Stacy Keibler
Drew Lachey
Emmitt Smith
Monique Coleman
Jerry Springer
Apolo Anton Ohno
Sabrina Bryan
Mel B
Marlee Matlin
Misty-May
Cloris Leachman
Gilles Marini
Ty Murray
Steve-O
Mya
Pamela Anderson
Brandy
Kyle Massey
Kirstie Alley
Again regardless of the time off between season 14 and season 15 Paul Lee ABC President said at least 1 couple will be from season 14 at the abc up fronts back on May 15th
Dee Dee they other 2 are correspondents and Maria and Mario are the host of Extra.
I may have voted for some past winners in this poll that I would like to see dance again, however, when it comes down to showtime, I probably won’t cast any votes to previous contestants that have already won.
Dee Dee check out this link to the extra website and you will see that the sole hosts are Maria and Mario while the others are correspondents to the segment http://www.extratv.com/page/about/
@ Sandy I’ll probably do the same cuz i don’t want to see a celebrity win the trophy more than once as long as they have a few 2nd and 3rd place finishers on the show as my feeling is it is the pros job so i don’t care if a pro wins more than once but a celeb is doing it for the publicity even with past winners i do not think anyone will 100% have it in the bag
I don’t like when the contestants are on daily shows.. example, Sherri, Maria, Mario.
There is no one on Season 14 that I care to see dance again. They were great but they will have barely hung up their dancing shoes. As far as Season 1… Did anyone even watch that season? Does anyone care? Seems like ages ago.
And I am so sick of hearing about Sabrina Bryant, but I have a feeling thats all were are going to hear about. Sabrina… blah, blah….
uff I think I’ll do the polls several times. One considering that the celebrities will come back with their respective pros. Other considering that they will be re-pair with diferente pros.
At some point I’m most excited with the idea of some pros returning to the ballroom, such as Jonathan, Dmitry, Louis, Edyta, even Alec!
Jeff,
Thank you, yes I know they are correspondents. Just ignoring the fact-lol Wishful thinking on my part.
BTW, you can call me Dee!
Who I’d love:
– Tony- Stacey Kiebler (season 2)
– Edyta- Joey Lawrence (season 3)
– Karina-Mario Lopez (season 3)
– Maksim- Mel B. (season 5)
– Mark- Sabrina Bryan (season 5)
– Corky- Cloris Lechman (season 7)
– Cheryl- Gllies Marini (season 8)
– Chelsie- Louie Vito (season 9)
– Louis- Kelly Osbourne (season 9)
– Lacey-Klye Massey (season 11)
– Anna- Carson Kressley (season 13)
– Derek- Maria Menounos (season 14)
Who I think we’ll get:
– Kym- Joey Fatone (season 4)
– Lacey- Lance Bass (season 7)
– Chelsie- Ty Murray (season 8)
– Cheryl- Gillies Marini (season 8)
– Tony- Melissa Rycroft (season 8)
– Louis- Kelly Osbourne (season 9)
– Mark- Bristol Palin (season 11)
– Karina-Ralph Macchio (season 12)
– Maksim- Kirstie Ally (season 12)
– Anna- Carson Kressley (season 13)
– Derek- Maria Menounos (season 14)
– Val- Sherri Shepard (season 14)
I don’t think they pull Kiebler now that she’s dating Clooney and (crazy I know) I think Kate passes due to bad blood with Tony. That leaves Bristol; we’re not getting away without Bristol and Kate. I don’t think Mario Lopez agrees to dance with Karina again because of their engagement/ split, and I think they go with Maria Menounos as the Extra host. It’s not so bad a cast; ‘NSYNC dance off! I’d just be sad to miss Kyle, Sabrina and Mel B.
–
oh and fyi I totally meant season ( 8 ), not seas 8). Not implying that season 8 was super great or anything (my favs season 5 )
I think that the format of bring one celebrity from each season is kind of restricting.
You should just overall bring the best celebrities from the show, because there might be a season with two really good celebs, and this format limits it.
An example is Season 5- where both Sabrina and Mel B. are really good contenders.
Seasons 3, 5, and 9 had very hard choices for me. Sabrina vs Mel B? Joey vs Mario? Yeesh. I want all four of them! I went with Natalie for Season 9 just because I thought she left too soon and wanted to see how she’d develop. But Kelly was my favorite that season, and I wouldn’t mind at all seeing her come back.
I chose:
Rachel Hunter
Stacy Kiebler
Mario Lopez
Apolo Anton Ohno
Albert Reed (he won’t last but he was relatively entertaining)
Shannon Elizabeth (for the drama of course hehe)
Misty May Traenor (deserves another chance)
Gilles Marini (not with Cheryl)
Natalie Coughlin (totally robbed and I think due to having Alec)
Evan Lysacek
Kurt Warner
Ralph Macchio (Also robbed due to judges WTA)
Carson Kressley
Katherine Jenkins (although season 14 could be too soon)
Seasons I think we could do without/not choose from:
Season 1, 6 and 7 (though Misty does deserve another chance), and probably 13, carson was the only entertaining one that season
Fun polls. Could not find one person to vote for on Season 9. Tells you how much I liked that season š
I also realized how easy it would be to have an all boy band competition….
Oh, that was too fun Marianya. Can’t wait to see the final results. My dream would be to see Joanna Krupa come back, but, I doubt that will happen.
After next season,
I hope they consider doing an All Star Champion Season. I would love, love, love to see Nicole return. She was AMAZING with Derek! Looking at a few of their videos a while ago. She was just incredible.
Thanks again for this listing… Interested to see the results.
I really really really really want to see Anna with Evan again!
I voted for:
Rachel
Stacy
Monique
Laila
Sabrina
Marissa
Toni
Lil Kim
Mya
Nicole (don’t think winners should return but I really liked her)
Brandy
Kirstie
Chynna
Katherine
I tweeted Mya recently asking her if she wants to return and she messaged me back saying yes, as long as they’re interested she’ll do it.
I have no idea what thread to put this in…and you guys may have seen it, but I haven’t noticed it on the site. Holy Moly I want to do this! I’m at work right now but I’m so trying to figure it out when I get home.
http://tv.yahoo.com/news/kym-johnson-and-tristan-macmanus-preview-the-new–dancing-with-the-stars–game.html
I hope the link works.
Sandy, I am very sick of hearing about Sabrina as well. She really wasn’t all that I don’t necessarily think anymore that people assumed she was safe. I think maybe they just didn’t like her. There were better choices that season for sure – like those who ended up in the final two. š
Actually Violet, we posted on the DWTS game about a month ago;
https://www.puredwts.com/2012/05/01/dancing-with-the-stars-keep-dancing-on-line-game-launches-worldwide/
Kelly, yay…love Mya!
whoops, sorry! I thought that it was weird I hadn’t seen it here. I don’t know how I missed it, b/c I visit the site at least once a day.
Still can’t wait to try it!
I chosed:
Season 1 — John O’Hurley
Season 2 — Stacey Kiebler
Season 3 — Mario Lopez
Season 4 — Apolo Anton Ohno
Season 5 — MEL B!!!!!!
Season 6 — Marlee Matlin
Season 7 — Misty Mae-Treaner
Season 8 — Shawn Johnson
Season 9 — Kelly Osbourne
Season 10 — Nicole Scherzinger
Season 11 — Kyle Massey
Sesaon 12 — Chelsea Kane
Season 13 — Carson Kressley
Season 14 — Maria Menounos
If I could choose the cast for the All-Stars it will be:
The Women:
Mel B and Maksim Chmerkovskiy
Kelly Osbourne and Louis van Amstel
Shawn Johnson and Mark Ballas
Sabrina Bryan and Derek Hough
Mya and Dmitry Chaplin
Stacey Kiebler and Tony Dovolani
The Men:
Gilles Marini and Cheryl Burke
Apolo Anton Ohno and Julianne Hough
Joey Fatone and Kym Johnson
Kyle Massey and Lacey Schwimmer
Mario Lopez and Karina Smirnoff
Carson Kressley and Anna Trebunskaya
[…] are their 12 celebrity picks which is interesting in comparing them to our numbers polled in our Dancing With The Stars All-star Cast Wish Post taking place at the moment. Some of the same celebrities are winning in our polls and some are not. […]
Looking at TV Guides wish list I do agree with some of them but others i don’t care to see again like Marie Osmond she wasn’t that good and Melissa Rycroft too. I am sorry to say but I think Tony can’t choreography a freestyle for his life. Both of the ones he did were not good. Then they put in stars like Mel B who have commitment to the X Factor Australia and doubt the show would pay for air every week to and from australia and that would cut in to her rehearsal time.
We should get the voting data to the DWTS producers! I bet having this data would make for a much better show!
@John: I agree. the info would help them out big time. Plus, if it convinces them not to get Bristol and Kate back I’m all for it š
Lol! Help them??? If the celebrity can’t do it for whatever reason; there isn’t much you, fans, or TPTB can do.
I doubt Kate will do it. I think Chaz, Bristol, or Nacy will fill the controversial category.
Plus, they already have a poll on their website. They know who the public want.
Evan Lisacek & Anna Trebunskaya!<3
Interesting, but I am seeing a lot of peoples lists being heavy on the ladies and light on the men.
I am not sure where to post this but I just read online the next season of strictly come dancing could be its last http://www.people.co.uk/celebs-tv/celebrities/2012/05/27/bruce-forsyth-predicts-simon-cowell-will-dump-alesha-dixon-102039-23874877/
I find the season 13 poll interesting. Most/all of the other seasons see the concentration of votes towards those who progressed the farthest (winner through about 5th place, on average). However, season 13 sees two contestants– Chynna and Carson– who were eliminated in the first half of the season, as the top two from that poll. This definitely shows that they should be considered for the all-star season. Chynna for a second chance and for her good dancing skill, and Carson– I don’t need to explain that one!!!
Don’t want any winners back this time; but if they ever did a winners only show, I’d love to see a face-off between Kristi & Nicole. They were both so heavily favored in their seasons, it would be nice to see how they’d do with real competition.
The juicy stars, for me, are the ones that add spark and pizzaz to what’s basically a fun-oriented show.On that criteria, pure spark & zzaz, that would be Kirstie Allen, naturally, spark plus Maria Menounos,YES!, Jennifer Grey, for both spark and good dancing, much underestimated & fun Mario Lopez,and for suave sophistication Gilles Marini;Carson K can’t dance squat, but adds LIFE, Ralph Macchio’s endearing, if 2 fro one season are allowed, el B was a hot, hot dancer, also Nicole the ringer perfet, and Brooke who probably can’t because she is a hostExquisite Kath is a bit boring but worth it, though I’d prefer Maria.For pure spunk and bravado, Ricki Lake, ost iproved dancer.
That was fun and thank you for doing this. I noticed in Season 14 Katherine Jenkins was leading with Maria next. I would like to see Maria get another chance without the injuries as I thought she was definitely the most improved. Since someone made a comment that the producers said someone from that season would be back I wonder if they have already decided it to be Katherine. I know they were hoping for a female to win again and since Katherine came in clearly out front I just wonder. Depending on who the rest of the cast is I would hope that it would turn out to be a good competition filled with great dancers and not someone who would be a shoe-in to win. Guess we will just have to wait and see.
I think that there shouldn’t be any season 14 stars. It would be way to soon. Honestly, I would be fine having anyone except Maria. I absolutely hated her. If she is back on, I will not watch the show.
Heh – I think Maria was Derek’s best partner to date. Loved her.
I agree, Heidi.
i wonder if derek doesn’t come back for season 15 and they invite back maria, if she would do it.
Yes, I agree, too Heidi and Violet. I have really enjoyed Derek with al lhis partners and just watching the way he adjusts and the dynamic they bring. Nicole was fun cause he could really stretch the choreography and you could tell they got along well. But with Maria there was a whole new “comfort level” shall we say, and ease and sense of fun. It was the most enjoyable, natural pairing I’ve ever seen on the show. Also loved seeing her improvement and her appreciation and amazement at what he could get her to do. I would LOVE to see her come back healthy for the win.
I agree Heidi, Violet and Mimi regarding Maria. She is who I voted for to come back. Mimi I totally agree with everything you said about watching Derek and Maria each week. To see her healthy and win would make the season worth watching for me. Otherwise I am not fond of the All Star idea. If it were true All Stars that might be better, but for me some of these names are not what I consider All Stars at all.
[…] case you’ve missed it… last week, there was a post with polls asking you – the reader – to choose one star per season that you’d love to see […]
I can see Maria being with Tristan if Derek doesn’t come back as she revealed in an interview if she didn’t have Derek she would want to dance with Tristan
Well I don’t see Shawn Johnson competing in the All-Stars, she will not be competing in the London Olympics this summer. She is retiring from gymnastics due to a previous knee injury.
I was wondering about that too, Sandy. I tend to agree with you that we likely won’t be seeing Shawn on the All-Stars season. Which is a shame, I liked Shawn. I didn’t pick her in the poll, though, because I liked Melissa better.
I know it’s not “Dancing with the PROS” (although for me, the pros are the “stars”), but what if they had our usual twelve pros and brought them each back with one of their previous partners (preferably not a winner, but one who was a good dancer or placed pretty high)? That would also solve the problem of casting All-Stars who might have had the same pro partner (that is, if the show plans to have the All-Stars with their same partners in the first place).
So, for instance:
Derek–Maria M, Jennie G, or Joanna K
Dmitri–Mya
Louis–Monique C, Lisa R, or Kelly O
Mark–Sabrina B, Chelsea K, or Katherine J
Maks–Mel B, Laila A, or Erin A
Tony–Stacy K, Melissa R, or Audrina P.
Anna–Evan L
Chelsie–Roshon F
Cheryl–Gilles M, Cristian D, or William L
Karina–Mario L, Mario B, or Ralph M
Kym–Joey F
Lacey–Kyle M or Lance B
It is hard to pick just one from each season. There are some seasons I don’t want anyone back and there are a few seasons there are 2 or 3 I would love to see again! Great poll!! š
[…] case you missed it, last week I posted all the celebrities that have graced Dancing with the Stars with their presence and asked you – the reader […]
I’ve voted for Roshon and have noticed that his vote count remains at the same 336 regardless of my vote. Is there something wrong with the vote counting?
Ah, nm, I see it says you’ve already counted my vote. Is that to say that we’re only allowed to vote one time?
@Diane K – The purpose of the above set of polls is to narrow down the field just enough for a final poll to choose an appropriate “Top Twelve” (six male/six female celebrities)
I really loved the way Chaz gave it his all. I would love to have him back on DWTS.
[…] last two weeks of polls – Choosing favorite star from every season, then choosing your top twelve – Choosing the top twelve professional […]
I’d love to see Carson, Kirstie, Maria, Erin and Chynna come back. Other than that … I really hope they don’t bring back any winners. It just seems kind of pointless. Either all winners or no winners, IMO.
I agree with Athena. They should start with a level playing field. To mix together MB winners with non-winners would be giving the winners a great advantage and that would just make for a terribly frustrating season. In all fairness, I’d like to see those who didn’t win get a shot at a MB since the winners already have theirs.
Yup, I agree, I will not cast one vote to any of the previous winners.
my top picks would be jennifer grey drew lachey melissa rycroft sabrina bryan audrina patridge gilles william levy maria sara evans chad ochocinco and jennie garth and helio