PureDWTS Season 18, Week 2 – Power Rankings
Hopefully everyone has had enough time to sleep off the whiplash you likely got from watching last night’s show – because seriously, kids, I don’t think I could have choreographed a sh*tshow that was sh*ttier than this show 😯 I felt sorry not only for the couples for a) not knowing when they were going to be dancing, and having to be prepared at a moment’s notice; but b) having the double elimination hanging over their heads all night. Oh, and then there was the partner switch-up tweeting, too, which was haphazardly thrown in without a whole lot of explanation or clarification. If the producers set out to turn last night’s show into the television equivalent of K-Mart on Black Friday, they succeeded – it seemed like total bedlam on the set last night.
I guess Erin improved only slightly this week – although I don’t really know if it was that she improved or that I was just waiting to get blindsided by more twists and turns and wasn’t really paying attention to her to begin with. I do agree with the fans on one thing: she will NEVER look as good in those dresses as Brooke did. WTF was she wearing last night? A discarded leotard from Beyonce’s “Single Ladies” video? And my god, Erin (or whomever is pushing this stupid Jeremy Miller nonsense), just STAAAAHHHHP. Both Cameron & Danica have clearly moved on, and let’s just say Ben Seaver hasn’t exactly aged gracefully…if you’re expecting a catfight over that doughy, average-looking washed-up actor, you’re going to be waiting for a very, very long time.
As for the eliminations – can’t say I’m too surprised about Diana & Henry. I would have liked her to stay a bit longer, but I kind of wondered about both she & Henry’s respective fanbases – I doubt they would have been able to stick around for more than a week or two. As for Sean & Karina – I’m honestly a bit shocked about that one, because I seriously thought Karina had the fanbase to at least pull her through the first few weeks, and I thought Sean was starting to finally open up. Apparently he mentioned something about getting into an argument with Conrad & Co. over his rehearsal package last week during his elimination interview on GMA this morning (with the implication being “If you fight with the producers, you get sent home!”), but we’ll probably never know for sure if it was the votes that sent him home or Lord Conrad’s delicate ego. I’d be lying, though, if I said I wasn’t THRILLED that Billy Dee & Emma get to stick around for another week 😉
1.) Charlie & Sharna – Another really strong showing for Charlie this week, and I think I’m convinced that, as long as he keeps up with the momentum he’s had so far (and Sharna tightens up her choreo a bit), they will win this whole thing. I was impressed with the amount of control he had – he was slick & tough without falling into the amateur pitfalls of gritting his teeth or having an unnaturally stiff frame, and he seems to just GLIDE through the steps effortlessly. If I had one complaint about his actual technique, it would be that his steps seemed a bit large – I don’t think it affected the overall integrity of this routine, but it might be something he needs to reign in on dances like the Viennese waltz, where he’s not going to have time to take huge steps without getting off-time. Also, another slight choreographic “tsk, tsk” to Sharna this week – it seemed like this tango was a bit “pose-y”: step, step, step, step, POSE! Step step step, POSE! I would have liked a bit more continuity. I actually didn’t mind the breaking hold – that rule has been enforced so subjectively over the past few seasons, I honestly didn’t think they’d get called out on it; but because they’re front-runners, they’re going to get needled. Anywho, it was probably my favorite dance of the night, and I’m curious to see him doing some Latin in the coming weeks 😉
2.) Amy & Derek – Amy seemed to get a bit more comfortable out on the floor this week, and we saw some more daring steps from she & Derek as they seemed to get more comfortable with what she can & can’t do on her prostheses. I thought this was a fun, energetic routine – a nice mix of some Charleston, Lindy, and east coast swing, with a few signature “Derek” moves thrown in. They seemed to fumble a bit on the famous “pretzel arms” move that Derek is fond of, but that seemed to be the only bobble in an otherwise pretty clean, entertaining routine. I daresay they probably ended up delivering a more clean, on-time routine than Meryl & Maks, which was surprising, but I think they were probably wise to keep it simpler and cleaner than run the risk of trying to throw in a bunch of tricks with the potential to get fumbled like Meryl & Maks. Overall, very cute and impressive, and I think these two are going to continue to prove they’re contenders this season.
3.) Meryl & Maks – I’ve gotta be honest – I don’t think either of the routines we’ve seen from these two so far are as impressive as they could and SHOULD be. I’m not sure if lackluster choreography is to blame, or a lack of focus on technique, or a lack of focus on character – but I haven’t really been able to feel invested in this couple so far. Both their cha-cha last week and their swing this week have been good – but not great. I think this week was actually a bit of a backslide for them, as they seemed to lose timing more than once and some of the lifts and tricks seemed a bit messy. It was still better than what we saw from a lot of the other couples, yes, and overall, I would say it was “cute”; but I wouldn’t really call it mind-blowingly good or proof that they’re contenders right now. I think I was just overall left wanting more. Wish I had more to say – I like them, but I don’t LOVE them…and I think there’s definite room for improvement.
4.) Danica & Val – Anyone else getting a bit of an Elizabeth Berkeley vibe off Danica like I am? Just a bit too obsessive, and seems to create unrealistic and hard-to-reach expectations for herself? If so, then I’m not sure Val’s got an easy road ahead of him this season, because Danica seems a bit high-maintenance – it’s only week 2 and she’s already shedding tears during rehearsal? Ooh wee. She handled her samba quite well – but here’s what’s bugging me: she was handling the hard parts of it (the samba rolls, the characteristic closing of the thighs that even Zendaya never seemed to master) like it was a piece of cake, but is still doing amateurish stuff like whiffing her arm extensions and not finishing lines. If she’s trying to feign newb status as a dancer, then she’s got it backwards 😛 She’s a good dancer – I’m just having a hard time understanding why she can handle difficult steps easily, and is having such a hard time doing easy stuff. I’d also just like to see her RELAX and not put so much pressure on herself – that was part of what seemed to turn me off to Elizabeth last season: the perfectionism.
5.) James & Peta – A definite step up for James this week, and unlike last week, I actually believe now that he’s excited to be there. I think my favorite part of his salsa was his enthusiasm – he seemed genuinely invested in it, and looked like he was having a great time. Peta didn’t hold back – this was a pretty jam-packed routine with lots of tricky lifts and stunts, and I think James handled it pretty well…a few missed leads here and there, maybe, and a couple bobbles when executing a few of the lifts, but I’d say it was a pretty damn good effort for it only being week 2. I’d caution Peta to not get tempted to throw the kitchen sink into every routine – this did seem a bit hectic, even though I thought they handled it pretty well. I think their chemistry also improved a great deal this week – after the awkwardness of last week’s rehearsal packing and a rather strained foxtrot, I would say this was a big step up for them. And while I said last week that I think Cody would be the entertainer this season and James would be the technician – I’m starting to wonder if James might be the whole package, underneath it all.
6.) Cody & Witney – I think this week was more of a “two steps back” for these two, as I’m starting to see some potential problems with this partnership that didn’t seem evident last week. First of all, I think Witney is struggling to maintain a balance between being Cody’s partner and Cody’s pro – she knows the rules and is trying to abide by them, but isn’t quite sure how to “put her foot down” with Cody. I think she’s handling Cody better than Lindsay handled Victor, but there’s still room for improvement. And then there’s the fact that I think Cody is trying to drive the bus – some of the “suggestions” he was throwing out were contrary to what Witney was telling him they had to do, and he didn’t seem to care. I’m beginning to think our friend Cody is not used to hearing the word “no”. 😛 Cody didn’t seem really excited to do the tango, and it was a bit evident by his body language throughout the dance – a few bored expressions, some lazy posturing, and then the moonwalk thrown in at the end (yet another thing that makes me think of Roshon) just kind of left me feeling he was subliminally telling us “Screw the tango. I do what I want!” This may have just been an off-week for them, but I’m hoping that Witney can take back the wheel next week, and Cody will recognize her authority as the pro and start to fall in line.
7.) Candace & Mark – I know I leapt to Candace’s defense last week when some were accusing her of “throwing her faith in everyone’s face”, but after this week, I just have to groan and hope that she’s gotten it out of her system – because now I’m tired of hearing about it. I have no problems with someone not wanting to dress in skimpy clothing due to their faith; I have no problems with someone not wanting to grind up on their partner due to their faith. But I just feel like Candace wants to avoid being “sexy” altogether – and if that’s the case, then why did she sign up for DWTS? A certain degree of “sexiness” and “suggestiveness” are characteristic of quite a few of the dances. I guess I’m just hoping she kind find a balance between being true to her faith and still delivering entertaining performances. As for this rumba? It really felt more like an extra contemporary routine to me – especially since the music wasn’t a strong rumba beat. Not a whole lot of basic rumba steps in this one, and in the little bit of real rumba she did, she never seemed to shift her weight properly – she seemed to get a little too front-weighted. I guess I’m going to give Mark a little bit of a free pass on this one, as they saddled him with a crummy song and a partner that refused to be sexy in quite possibly the sexiest of all the dances. Not a particularly strong showing, but hopefully they bounce back next week…
8.) Drew & Cheryl – I’m a bit ashamed to say that I don’t really remember a whole lot about this jive – maybe I was still trying to make sense of the double elim, maybe I was fidgeting with Keyhole, maybe I was just not very impressed…but relying on my notes, apparently it was pretty cute, but Drew (like most newbs to the jive) could have probably picked his feet up a bit more and he lost time during the swivel steps. Overall, I’m liking he & Cheryl’s partnership, but what worries me is that, when I’m rattling off the list of couples in my head, they’re almost always the last ones I think of. They’re not doing terribly, but they’re not doing great – and their chemistry isn’t explosively good or bad. I worry that they’ve already become a bit of the “middle of the road” couple this season, and we’re only in week 2. Hopefully they can make a splash in the coming weeks.
9.) NeNe & Tony – NeNe pleasantly surprises me once again, and actually handles her jive better than most of the partners Tony has had in the past few years. Like James, I think what I appreciate most about her dancing is her commitment to it – she always seems like she’s having fun and is really invested in the dance she’s doing. Was her technique perfect? No, but I think she still gave it a good effort. One complaint: why was NeNe allowed to wear…umm, bedazzled Keds? While Candace was told by the producers that she had to wear ballroom shoes for her rumba. I get it, NeNe is tall – but they make short ballroom shoes with only about a 1.5″ heel. Just starting to get sick of the double standards on this show – so-and-so can wear sneakers, but this other person can’t. It seems minor, but it seriously bugs when you think about the advantages/disadvantages it affords certain couples. But anywho – not sure that NeNe has the juice to go all the way this season, but I have enjoyed her journey so far.
10.) Billy Dee & Emma – If you’re here to chastise me for being happy about Billy Dee staying “over a better dancer”, do us both a favor and just SPARE ME…I got enough flak on Twitter last night. Once again, for me it’s not really about Billy’s dancing – I was just glad that a guy who seemed pretty sad about “looking like an old man trying to dance” during his package got to feel loved by the audience enough to stick around, even though he can’t move the same way he did back in his heyday. Yes, his tango was basic; and say what you will about him having an “unfair advantage” by being allowed to use the troupe members in his routine (do you really think it gave him THAT much of an edge? 😛 ); but I thought it was a decent effort and an improvement over last week. I doubt his fanbase is going to carry him a whole lot further, especially since his scores don’t seem to be improving – but I’m just glad he wasn’t the first out. 🙂
The “Rivalry Scorecard” for the week:
Charlie vs. Meryl – Charlie again, for just being overall cleaner and more into the character of his dance. Running total: Charlie 2, Meryl 0.
James vs. Cody – James, for being more invested in his dance and handling complex choreography reasonably well. Running total: James 1, Cody 1.
Danica vs. Candace – Danica, for handling a pretty difficult dance reasonably well, and not getting hung up on things like wardrobe & goo-goo eyes. Running total: Danica 1, Candace 1.
So who are your faves and least faves from last night’s show? Let us know! And keep an eye out later for my first update in my Twitter Switch-Up voting analysis. 😉
So before I start, I am going to say that I liked Diana and Henry’s dance. Same for Sean and Karina. Erin was better this week. Her and the Growing Pains guy was so awkward but so funny.
1)Meryl and Maks: She wowed me. Kudos to Maks for that choreography.
2)Charlie and Sharna: He showed that he is the real deal. I doubted him last week slightly and thought he would be a one trick pony but wow this was awesome.
3)Drew and Cheryl: Was he the best? No. But, he was so much fun to watch. Pure Joy!
4)Candance and Mark: It was good. A little bit of a contemporary dance but I liked it.
5)Amy and Derek: Didn’t like it as much as last week.
6)Danica and Val: Where this sexy side came from is beyond me. She went from jittery and overexcited last week to nailing it last week to this. Good for her!
7) James and Peta: Overscored but good.
8)Cody and Witney: Yeah, so many things I disliked but I loved how he added his own flair to it. That song was my major issue…not a tango song at all in my opinion. The costuming was good. The choreography was good but foretable. The only part I really remember is that moonwalk.
9) Nene and Tony: Yeah, fun but overscored.
10) Billy Dee and Emma: Love this guy but he has to go.
Good job, Court. Ok, here are mine:
1. Sharna and Charlie – Wow, were these two not amazing again? I couldn’t take my eyes off of them. I loved how Charlie got completely into character with Sharna. And Sharna wowww, she was just breathtaking again. Beautiful, emotional, powerful, sharp in all the right places! 28
2. Maks and Meryl- Fast, furious, explosive, cute, and just plain fun!! I loved the throws and the difficulty in this dance too. “Fly on Girl” is right! I also love happy Maks this season. Well done! 26
3. Derek and Amy – Omg, they were unbelievable again. So quick and such creative choreography by Derek. She was so breathtaking again too (she reminds me of Madonna in “The Next Best Thing” era). I loved her costume, hair, makeup, everything. Derek always knows how to dress and feature his partners. I want more! 25
4. Cody and Witney – I really dig these two. I continue to love that James Dean way to him. I liked how he added the moon walk to their dance too giving it his own spin. I am impressed with Witney’s choreography skills too. 24
5. James and Peta- He seemed a little messy again and seemed to fly around like last week, but, I love how he just runs with it all and has fun. I also like he and Peta’s connection which comes out in their dancing. They play off well from each other. 24
6. Drew and Cheryl – Wow, these came out like gang busters. Drew was fast and furious. About 3/4 of the way through, he started to get tired, but, for the most part though, well done and totally entertaining. It seems Cheryl always has her partners ready to go. I love his trust in her too. They have the likability factor and they make me smile. 23
7. Danica and Val – I liked her sleek and sultry movements. However, there are times her legs were lost and stiff in the turns. I wish she’d put more depth into her dances and emotion (more on them below). 23
8. Candace and Mark – It was ok, but, right from the start, I felt a lack of connection and the emotion seemed sort of fake much like Danica. It’s like both she and Danica are trying too hard. Also (and this is what I wish the most), I wish both of them would concentrate more on their partners and not the audience when they dance. 23
9. Billy Dee and Emma – Awww, I loved Emma’s heart in their package. So sweet and so adorable. As for their dance, Emma did all the work which is understandable being he’s older. But, if they stick around next week, I hope we see him doing a little more. He needs to believe in himself too. 15
10. NeNe and Tony – I thought she was just awful. I’m having a really hard time liking these two. I still can’t believe they beat out Sean and Karina. Oh well. 15
1. I agree Charlie’s tango was the best dance of the night 26
2. Amy and Derek’s Swing was easily better than Meryl and Maks 25
3. Meryl and Maks’ Swing…not as good as Amy/Derek’s I would’ve expected it to be better but it wasn’t. You’d think an Olympic Ice Dancer would have timing down better? 24
4. James/Peta DID NOT like Peta’s costume–I don’t think they cut the budget there did they? 23
5. Danica/Val–got that Samba Roll PERFECT…still not sure if she’s sandbagging or what but the crying thing? I agree very high maintenance. 22
6. Candace/Mark–I stick by her for staying true to her beliefs and convictions…can still make the dance sensual without oversexualizing it. Which I don’t think Mark did with that choreography. So that’s out of the way. Hopefully for her Most Memorable Year next week, she won’t choose the year she became a Christian. 21
7. Cody/Witney–it was ok, not great but OK 21
8. Drew and Cheryl–not bad for a Jive–he lost steam at the end 20
9. NeNe and Tony—wouldn’t have minded seeing her leave last night. Was that a Jive or another hip hop routine with a few kicks/flicks mixed in? 18
10. Billy Dee and Emma–another horrible routine. I get that he’s 77 but he needs to put a little more effort into it, sorry rioters. I hope it’s his final week next week. 16
One elimination was right, one wasn’t. Sean shouldn’t have left. It should have been NeNe or Billy Dee.
Drew/Cheryl – They make me smile. He’s having so much fun and Cheryl is having another good year. She seems so much happier than in the past. That jive was fun to watch.
Danica/Val – It’s no secret that she has dance experience and they’re trying to hide it for some reason. But watching her cry when it’s only week 2? Sorry, I don’t buy it. I can’t get behind them.
Billy Dee/Emma – He made it through this week, but he doesn’t dance. He has a great attitude and I love Emma, but she can’t be doing it all every week.
Meryl/Maks – What can I say? She’s good and she’s not going anywhere. And it’s nice to see Maks having fun. That was so great! It made me smile. I just don’t get how it’s only one point better than Danica’s.
Diana/Henry – I’m sorry to see Henry gone so early, but I figured that would happen when they said double elimination. Their dance wasn’t that exciting and I don’t think she would have made it through much longer.
Candace/Mark – Please Mark, do something with that hair. That said, that dance was beautiful. No, it wasn’t much of a rumba, but I liked it. I enjoy watching Candace and want to see her go far in this.
Amy/Derek – This switch thing better be for only one week, because I want to see Amy with Derek. That was fantastic. I liked that they stayed on a small stage rather than trying to move around the regular dance floor. That worked out much better for Amy. Derek is pure genius.
James/Peta – It’s obvious they want him around for awhile. They’re so so for me.
Charlie/Sharna – I like this pair. He’s not going anywhere either.
NeNe/Tony – I’m sorry, I don’t like them and I can’t get behind them at all.
Sean/Karina – He was growing on me. When I read that he got Karina a place closer to the studio, I thought that was so sweet. He shouldn’t have been the one going home.
Whitney/Cody – Like James and Peta, they’re so so for me. He seemed hunched over a lot. But he has the twitter teens behind him so he’s not going anywhere. It’s annoying seeing all the posters in the audience.
I’m predicting Billy Dee and NeNe in the bottom two with a toss up as to who leaves. It’s going to come down to whoever has the larger fanbase.
Since it appears the derek/amy will not be a team captain if they make it to the team dance, it will be interesting to see if family picks family or Derek with first pick. Does 10 out of 10 trump family?
I thought Meryl and Maks were the best of the night. Some of those lifts were insane so I imagine that is why their timing was a little off, as Bruno rightly said. In ice dancing, they do difficult lifts as well but the girl doesn’t get thrown across the ice.
Charlie and Sharna were great too but I just didn’t see him getting into character. He looked very uncomfortable and stiff to me. Having watched him skate for years, I’ve seen him do a lot better. I think he should have been a point behind Meryl.
Amy and Derek just wow. The choreography is incredible! And I was every bit as entertained by them as I was by Meryl and Maks.
Drew and Cheryl–I remember the costumes but not the dance. I do think their respective fan bases will carry them though no matter how badly he dances.
James and Peta–OK
Danica and Val–I was underwhelmed by the samba but I know this is a trouble dance for a lot of celebs. She seemed to handle it better than most.
Candace and Mark–The dress did not seem very understated to me and as I said in the other thread, if you’re saving it for your husband and not going to get into character, why are you an actress? Why kiss your co-star in a tv movie then? They should have pulled a Kurt Warner and had her husband in the package telling her it’s ok to let it go for the rumba.
NeNe and Tony–I had the same thoughts as everyone else about the sneakers. Also, the dance didn’t seem very jive-like to me.
Cody and Witney–I’ve forgotten the dance but not the costumes
Billy Dee and Emma–He needs to go unfortunately. But I give him an A++ for effort! 🙂
I have a feeling they are saving Meryl’s jive for Derek and it will be all 10s that week.
Charlie and Sharna are by far my favorites and so far they are the best skilled couple but I just wonder if he’ll get the votes. Will he and Meryl split the vote with maybe Meryl beating him out because of Maks’ fan base? I just worry about them being a “surprise” elimination right before the finals…really hope not though!
Another night full of surprises. I’m really disappointed by how they did the elimination. Having Diana & Henry eliminated in the middle of the show was bit tacky, and very rude. I had a feeling Sean & Karina were going to be eliminated. But other than that, there were some very entertaining dances last night.
1. Charlie & Sharna: Once again, he has proven that he is a fantastic performer, and delivered a killer Tango. I thought breaking hold really brought out his inner bad boy. If he keeps up this standard, he’ll be in the finals for sure.
2. Amy & Derek: What the heck? How does she keep impressing me? She really is a fantastic dancer. When she said her legs could potentially fly off, I couldn’t help but laugh. Aside from that, I thought their Swing was fantastic, and a tad underscored. I thought Len would at least give them a 9.
3. Meryl & Maks: I saw where the mistakes were made, and I’m a bit shocked by their score. Based on what the judges said, I thought Bruno was going to give them a 7. A few times I thought Maks was either going to drop or break Meryl. The costumes were also very adorable.
4. Danica & Val: These two nailed it this week with their Samba. Danica really needs to let go more during rehearsal, and not worry so much. Luckily, Val is a nice guy and is always there for his partners no matter what happens.
5. James & Peta: Most of the dance looked a bit spastic, and out of place a few times. The only thing hot about that dance was Peta. Carrie Ann really needs to stop giving high scores to the guys that undo their shirts, especially to those with airbrushed abs.
6. Cody & Witney: He is getting there. At times he looks very awkward and lanky. It’s really the technique that still needs work. The reason why he was in jeopardy of leaving was because he danced during the second hour of last weeks premiere, and the pubescent fans didn’t have the chance to vote for him last week. The same thing might happen again next week. You would think his 6M+ Twitter followers would back him in the voting.
7. Candace & Mark: This was HUGE step back from last week. There was little to no Rumba content, the song didn’t suit the dance, and it was too Contemporary. She needs to be careful about what she says in the packages. If she keeps speaking about her faith, it might get her voted off in the next few weeks.
8. Drew & Cheryl: The important thing about this dance is he had fun. There was a lot of content in the dance, and they look adorable together. I can’t imagine seeing them split up for a week.
9. NeNe & Tony: From a technical point of view, there was a lot of struggling with the footwork. From a performance point of view, she got the crowd going. I think we might see some great things from them in the coming weeks.
10. Billy Dee & Emma: Whoever is voting for them needs to stop. There was no excitement from him, he barely moved, and he still got 5’s. The dance looked more like 4’s and 3’s. The way the dances are looking, Emma is doing all the work, and Billy is just standing there.
Top 3: Charlie & Sharna, Amy & Derek, Meryl & Maks
Bottom 3: Cody & Witney, NeNe & Tony, Billy Dee & Emma
Possibly going home next week: Billy Dee & Emma
Drew & Cheryl: I also don’t remember their dance so much. Think I was still gathering myself from everything they threw at us at the beginning of the show. I do remember he kept up rather well with a fast dance. It was fun and entertaining so I did like it.
Danica & Val: Her crying was really just plain pathetic -_- That being said, the dance was good (shocker..). Like Courtney, I get an Elizabeth Berkley vibe from Danica. I think Candace will outlast her…
Billy & Emma: I like him… I really do. I do not like his dancing though. Part of me wishes he would have gone home last night, but part of me is also happy that HE is happy to still be around. I don’t think he’ll improve much (if at all) so I think next week he might be gone /:
Meryl & Maks: I liked it a lot. She did have a few mistakes and lost her timing a bit but it was really fun. And well, in my opinion, I kinda liked it more than Amy’s. Perhaps just because there was a lot of tricks that made me go “Wow!!” and that’s always fun for me. I think her and Maks are looking better together every week.
Candace & Mark: Yeah this wasn’t that good. I must say though she did look gorgeous last night, however that didn’t feel like a rumba to me. I’d call it a ContempoRumba, as someone in another post did. I hope she can open up a bit more and at least shows A LITTLE bit of a sexy side when she has to do other latin dances. I do want her to be around longer than Danica though.
Amy & Derek: She is just so gorgeous. She looked absolutely stunning in her outfit. The dance itself was pretty awesome too. Shame about that little mistake but other than that, she did great. Not sure I liked then staying in one place so much (hope it isn’t a regular thing they are going to do) but overall I liked it.
James & Peta: These two are just hot and steamy together. Their chemistry last night showed more than last week for sure and I overall liked the dance a lot. He did make a few mistakes but other than that, I enjoyed it very much. Great song choice too!
Charlie & Sharna: I knew they’d be penalized for breaking hold, but whatever. I loved their Tango. It was hot hot hot. Sharna looked gorgeous in that dress. Now I do think that Charlie has had a bit of an easy two weeks with two dances that have been right up his alley. I hope next week we see him do something out of his comfort zone (like a Cha Cha or a Samba) … pretty sure he would do great in that as well, though.
NeNe & Tony: I said it once, and I will say it again… I like NeNe, I hate Tony. The Jive was alright. It wasn’t anything special but I agree that she is having the time of her life and I enjoy seeing that she is happy to be there.
Cody & Witney: Well that was kinda… bad. His posture was pretty terrible. I do have to say that I kinda felt for Witney pretty much being called too short for Cody by CAI. I think, though, that regardless of their height difference they could have still pulled off a good Tango but his frame was just all kinds of weird and it did look like he did not even want to do the Tango. We’ll see how he does next week… I’m still iffy about these two.
Sad to see Diana and Sean go.. I liked Sean’s Slasa as it showed a lot more personality and I am glad we got to see Diana’s Cha Cha (though it wasn’t really good). Kinda was hoping it’d be Billy going instead of one of these two but it is what it is.
Thoughts for the week:
That opening number was much better and should have been the season opener.
Camera work has to be pretty bad when EVERYONE is noticing how bad it is. They must have gotten a new crew, it doesn’t make sense otherwise.
I am liking the band though, I think they are doing a great job. Singers are more consistent so far too. Jury’s still out on Erin for me.
Well, Tony and Maks are already being rude to the judges. It’s only Week 2 guys. And the judges can be annoying but they weren’t incorrect on their remarks to you this time guys!
Wish we really knew what the deal is with the shoes rules. Are the producers really being THAT unfair, allowing some to do whatever and insisting on others to do it by the book?
Badly done producers on Diana’s exit. She’s a huge fan of the show and you treated her like crap. Glad she got to dance, I think she did better than week 1 too.
I’m sad we can’t vote for eliminated pros to dance in the switch week. I am definitely thinking, especially with the double this week, that there will be no elimination the week after the switch dances. It seems like that is the only fair way. And I doubt ANY of the celebs will opt to stay with their ‘new’ partners, due to how bad it would make them look to their former partner or how it would affect the other celeb who wants their old partner back.
As for the dances:
Favorites: Charlie & Sharna, Amy & Derek, Meryl & Maks
What can I see, I thought these 3 couples were great tonight. Still looking forward to seeing how Sharna and Derek push their partners to their fullest potential as the season goes on. I did see the few issues in M&M’s dance though, not exactly sure what was to blame there, but I still found it highly entertaining. I love watching her face as she performs, always have on the ice too. I hope Maks can keep kicking his choreo up a notch each week.
Also enjoyed: James & Peta, Sean & Karina, Danica & Val, Candace & Mark
I still enjoyed Candace’s dance. The dead arm bothered me more than the contemporary feel. Many celebs in the past have gotten away with not-quite-rumba rumbas. I do think she embodies the characters of the dances well too.
I did enjoy Danica & Val’s dance more this week. I definitely have to agree that there was too much in their dance that showed signs of significant previous ballroom experience. Plus, IMO, her breakdown in the package also seems to prove that point. I feel since she knows she has a decent amount of prior experience, she should be better at this point than she is. Experience doesn’t have to bother the viewer, everyone has their own opinion on that. I generally like to watch ringers. It’s just my opinion that having significant ‘actual ballroom training on wood in a dance studio’ is too much to be on this show. You might not be an newbie at performing or dance of other forms, but you should be a newbie at ‘actual ballroom training on wood in a dance studio’. Again, just my opinion.
Wish we could have seen more of Sean, he fully commits and has some natural talent; it would have been interesting to see what Karina could have pulled out of him.
James turned it up a notch this week. Hope Peta can do him justice. Brant also had potential last season and got better and better. I don’t always have faith in Peta to get her partners as far as they should go though.
Was just ok or didn’t care for: Cody & Witney, Drew & Cheryl, Nene & Tony, Billy Dee & Emma
Cody & Witney have a lot of potential, I hope they can live up to it.
I have nothing much to say on the rest. And he’s a great man, but I hope Billy Dee goes next week.
Now we know eliminated celebs cant come back, my pairings (though I know one couple will be going home before the switch) of these:
Meryl & Derek
Amy & Mark
Danica & Tony hehe
Nene & Maks
Candace & Val
Charlie & Emma
James & Witney
Cody & Peta
Drew & Sharna
Billy Dee & Cheryl
I think I’m still hungover from last night’s trainwreck of a show and it’s giving me a jaundiced view of the dances. So in an effort to maintain a positive tone, I’ll stick to the performances I really enjoyed and let the rest slide into history.
Charlie & Sharna — These two are just a pleasure to watch. Charlie is so comfortable partnering and he’s much more expressive than I thought he’d be. My one concern is that Sharna better make the switch from creative choreo to cover up bad dancing (Andy) to creative choreo to highlight the abilities of a major contender. Len gets into judging ruts very easily. He’s leaning toward nitpicking these two (the way he did Derek/Shawn). If Sharna gives him another opportunity next week, he’ll be down on them for the rest of the season.
Meryl & Maks — I love the way Meryl handles Maks in rehearsals and gently pokes fun at him. She’s not in the least intimidated. This was a fun, high energy routine the likes of which we haven’t seen from old-man Maks in a long time. Maks may be on YouTube ripping off other pro’s choreography, but it’s better than what’s he’s been coming up with.
Amy & Derek — They pulled off this swing routine with amazing style. Amy is a natural dancer and performer. Another outstanding piece of choreography and costuming from Derek. I hope they figure out a way to get Amy moving around the floor more.
Drew & Cheryl — I just like these two. His energy and enthusiasm are great. As a result I enjoyed their performance a lot more than several others who were technically better.
For Week 3, I hope TPTB are content to let the switch-up be their main drama generator and don’t throw anymore curve balls at the couples during the show.
Drew. Not the world’s greatest dancer but I love that he’s having fun and that we have engaged Cheryl again. I have no problem with them sticking around for several more weeks.
Charlie. Great dancer but I just wasn’t feeling it tonight. I wasn’t buying the whole dark, mysterious mood. So Len is taking off two points for breaking hold? I hope he remembers that all season.
James. The poor guy. He’s this season’s hot piece of meat and CAI is as annoying as ever. I enjoyed him a lot more this week than last when I thought he seemed stiff. Why is it every season there has to be some nice, good looking guy who would like to be taken seriously and he’s pushed into the objectification role?
Sean. I knew he was toast last week after the sloppy seconds tape was played and I kept seeing “Hello Clarice” comments on the internet. I think he’s a smart, clever guy but I also know he has done a LOT of jerky things and there was something scary about waiting for him to explode. Personally I thought his dancing was awful last week but I think it was his personality that sealed his fate. He was better tonight and I think he should have stayed over Billy Dee, but I’m sure we’ll still see lots of Karina so I’m not too upset over his elimination.
Billy Dee. I love Emma. I want to see Emma. Billy Dee was just painful for me both last week and tonight. I think it would have been kind to let him go home. He’s feeling old and I feel bad for him.
Cody. He was rather forgettable to me tonight. Of course all those unrehearsed teens who brought their own signs, loved him. I jest. The show is SO desperate for the younger viewers. Poor Witney. She looked so sad when CAI basically called her out for being short. Has the show decided this partnership won’t keep Cody on the show? It sure looks like this could be the storyboarding for a permanent switch. I’m getting the feeling Cody has a lot of teenage brat in him.
Danica. Amazing how giggly Danica disappeared after so many people talked about hating it. Hate the fake rivalry stuff the show is pushing down our throats. Danica seems faking and that disappoints me. I was really looking forward to this pairing.
Meryl. I love her. I wish Maks would quit his usually choreography of running on to the stage and messing about. Maks needs to pick his fights more carefully. Meryl seemed to know she messed up a bit but darn that was fun and the lifts looked amazing to me. She is fearless and Maks really is having a hard time keeping up with her.
Amy. Is she the most well- adjusted woman in the world? What an amazing attitude and I really enjoy her dancing. She knows how to put her personality into it. She’s a natural entertainer. Derek is an amazing choreographer and seems to be enjoying this experience.
Candace. She seems to be a natural in some ways, although I’m a bit afraid last week might be her best week . The style seemed to fit her more athletic approach. I agree tonight was more contemporary than rumba. I don’t know if the show called her out on it because they wanted to put Mark in his place or because they wanted to tell Candace she better start embracing the dance styles. I really do respect her faith but her way of talking about it is beginning to creep into the “I’m a good Christian and I’m more moral than you” category now.
Diana. Not the world’s greatest dancer but she seemed to love the show so much; I hated to see her go. I would have rather had her stay another week, rather than Billy Dee. She had a lot more content. She had a classy exit speech.
NeNe. Bigger than life. One of the two couples who might have vaguely asked for the dance style. Tony’s choreography continues to be so boring. NeNe seemed annoyed by her scores. CAI was probably an idiot for using this week to talk about NeNe’s arms. Tony must have a very short fuse.
@Cidra – “I think I’m still hungover from last night’s trainwreck of a show and it’s giving me a jaundiced view of the dances.”
You said it Cids! Normally I am so excited for the show and literally can’t wait a whole week to watch it again.
I was so disappointed with the show last night when Diana was eliminated before she even had a chance to perform. WTH! I know she did get to perform her dance, and thank goodness she spoke up. How disrespectful to everyone, the viewers, and the couples. At that point, I channel surfed thoughout the rest of the show and went back later and finished watching it. The producers are going to keep messing with this show until even the die-hard DWTS fans have had enough.
I really liked Candace last week, but she bugged me with the Rumba. It seemed that she thought that she wasn’t only dancing the Rumba with Mark, but with Matthew, Luke and John, too.
Never thought I’d be saying this, but Drew is my second favorite contestant this season (behind Meryl). To me, he’s been the most endearing of any male comedian that’s been on the show.
Amy… personally, I didn’t like this routine, and I didn’t really like her Cha-Cha-Cha either. But I’m not gonna go saying she was overmarked – just like the judges, I have an opinion.
Meryl is still my favorite by far, and I’ve loved both of her dances… I just hope Maks’ jokey comments about ‘Len being the important judge’ doesn’t throw away any votes from them. I love Maks, though, so I’m not holding it against him… it just showed yesterday that they sometimes have completely opposite personalities.
Thanks, Sandy. You hit the nail on the head when you said the way TPTB conducted last night’s show was “disrespectful to everyone, the viewers, and the couples.”
I dragged up the energy to watch a few of George’s OTRC interviews. Both Derek and Sharna expressed discomfort over the way things had been done on the show. They were “pc” about it, but you could tell they were not comfortable. George seemed kind of disgusted with the whole thing as well.
Maybe things will be closer to normal next Monday. My biggest fear is they’ll waste far too much air time on switch-up nonsense. As far as I’m concerned, 10 minutes at the end of the show should be more than sufficient. Line up the 9 remaining couples. Rearrange them into their new (and please just 1-week) partnerships, and be done with it.
Hmm, I’d have Meryl and Maks at the top. Swing is allowed to get a little messy, and they didn’t lose timing THAT much, just right before a lift that I saw. I also thought Meryl was WAY more into the character of the dance than Charlie, who just has too limited of a range to successfully pull of the expression Sharna was going for. She should have stayed more in his wheelhouse IMO. Amy and Derek were fine but not on the same level as Meryl and Maks. I just wish Maks hadn’t choreographed the stupid intro, it made their routine seem even shorter than these short dances already are.
I hated the show for the most part, what a letdown after last week. Last week, I was like WOW WHY DID I EVER QUIT WATCHING THIS IS GR8. This week I’m like oh this is why. It felt like a mess and made it hard to enjoy the show. I can’t believe I’m saying this but I actually miss the results show, even though it was 80% irritating filler.
Personally the show is really losing its luster for me. I have been watching it since it started but over the past several years with all the different changes, it is just not as enjoyable as it was. I watch it for the dancing, not all the gimmicks and I know I am really going to dislike the switch, it just does not seem fair but that is JMO.
I see Billy and I think, really do you need the money that badly that you would put yourself through this, you don’t look happy at all. And more than anything I hated the way they did the elimination, I know that Diana did not have the fan base but she had the spirit and she is what this show is supposed to be about. Would she ever get better, probably not but dang, she was a joy to see for the very short time she was there.
I for one am already tired of the Candance vs. Danica pre-teen stuff, seriously show they were 11 and 13 years old, they probably did not even remember they went on a “so-called” date with Jeremy, but the show wants us to think they are in this battle, seriously it is so dumb and they must think we are dumb to fall for it. And the same with the Charlie vs. Meryl stuff, who really cares except TPTB.
I’m with you there Nancy regarding the show losing it’s appeal. I’m not ready to jump ship yet, but too many shows like last night and I will be. I felt like I was watching a dance competition that was put on by the producers of Fear Factor and Rock Of Love. It felt icky. A person shouldn’t feel icky while watching DWTS.
You can almost smell the flop sweat in the producers booth. Desperation is never attractive.
Charlie – captivating and he is adorable, think there is a lot more to come from him.
Meryl – liked this better than the Cha Cha , but there were some timing issues , I cant believe i’m saying that the judges were right
Amy – I adore her and love her partnership with Derek, the only thing I will say is I wish they would move around the floor more, they need to find a way to utilise the space more . I am looking forward to see what Derek has up his sleeve for next week 🙂
Danica – she is not as good as I think she thinks she is, she is strange and this complete 180 in her emotions , one minute giggly then the next crying is really grating, she reminds me of Elizabeth only imo not as good .
James – A vast improvement and I like his connection with Peta, he could be the dark horse they keep talking about .
Cody – Not keen on him mainly his attitude, he needs to listen to the pro and not think he knows everything, that’s my problem tho with Whitney, not enough experience on the show to deal with Cody in the way that Cheryl or Karina could have done lets say.
Nene – like her attitude she just needs to improve her technique and own her dance 🙂
Drew – A lovely smile and hes working hard and Cheryl is working well with him.
Candace – loved her last week, this week I did not like the choreography or her technique, but I still prefer her to Danica by a mile , if they insist on this stupid rivalry of something that happended 20 plus years ago.
Sorry to see Sean and Diane leave. I will really miss seeing Karina , she is one of the best female chorographers and dancers on the show and when not there she is missed.
oh Billy dee- love emma and his connection but he needs to move more he is nowhere near Bills level last season .
I feel like I was very underwhelmed last night. Not by the dances just how everything went down.
What they did to Diana was so disrespectful because she worked hard all week on her dance (even though it wasn’t necessarily the best Cha Cha) she still deserved to showcase it. Her charisma leaving last night made me respect her so much because she just wanted to dance and seemed like she enjoyed doing it. Even watching her on GMA, her spirit is so wonderful and I wish we got to see more of her.
Now my rankings —
1) Charlie & Sharna – I loved what he said about developing his character to portray in the dance. I honestly think based on the comptetition thus far, they’re the couple to beat.
2) Amy & Derek – I did see the little turn mess-up but it was so minor. I just love watching her dance, she’s such a strong inspiration to have on the show. I honestly liked her swing (choreography wise) better than Meryl’s
3) Meryl & Maks – Oh gosh, she is SO tiny, Maks can just toss her around. I did like the number and her athleticism was awesome but I wish they took a little bit of the lifts out. To what the judges saw about the off-timing, I did see that too but again, it’s so minor with the dance being that fast. Oh and Maks’ snide comment about Len being the important judge made me roll my eyes. I hope he behaves with her, she seems like such a genuine and sweet person.
4)Danica & Val – For someone with dance experience, I thought she would be a little bit better than she is. Either way, I think she needs to be a little sharper on her turns/arm movement before transitioning but she’s going to be here for awhile.
5) James & Peta – It was a steamy salsa but this pair seems like Brant 2.0. I was annoyed at Carrie-Ann’s comments about James joining the “sexy club” or whatever because this is about dancing not looks. Yes he is a good-looking guy but who cares? It’s not going to get him to the end but then again, it’s Carrie-Ann. Are we that surprised?
6) Cody & Witney – I like these two. I don’t think the Tango was necessarily his dance but he’s improving. Again, Carrie-Ann’s comment about hoping Cody gets a taller partner is so disrespectful to Witney. Did she see Jacoby and Karina in season 16? or even Maks and Meryl this season? I felt bad for Witney.
7) Candace & Mark – I loved what Candace said in her package about being sexy isn’t necessarily about taking your clothes off (coughPetacough) but I did agree that the rumba was a little contemporary. It isn’t Candace’s fault by no means but it wasn’t my favourite of the night. She is a classy lady and I respect her for that. Dancing doesn’t necessarily have to be sexual.
8) Drew & Cheryl – I love these two as a pairing but I can’t remember their dance. Maybe it was because I was annoyed about the comments/double elimination to pay attention.
9) NeNe & Tony – She did better on the jive than I thought she would. It’s refreshing to see her dance because she authentically looks like she enjoys it. Still meh about Tony.
10) Billy Dee & Emma – These two are so adorable. Is he the best dancer? No. Should he have probably gone home last night? Maybe. Either way, I just love seeing Emma with her partners and he seems like he’s just loving it (especially with the troupe girls last night) You go Billy Dee!
Like I said before, I’m not impressed with last night and it put a sour taste in my mouth. Am I being a little dramatic or negative? Maybe but still. The way the treated the double eviction was horrible. They could have at least let the first 6 dance and do an elimination between that group and then last 6 dance and do the final elimination between them.
I was at the live show last night so a few observations. They make the audience stand for each couple as they dance and as they exit so no one is really getting a “standing O” – they all get a standing O. I was about 5 rows back so could only see the couples from the waist up, other than Amy & Derek who danced on the little platform.
This is in no particular order:
Love Amy & Derek – really liked her hairdo & outfit, although wasn’t crazy about the song. She seems so energetic & smiling even when not performing. Derek jumps around a lot before his routine as did Mark.
Charlie & Sharna – I have a little crush on Charlie. He’s so cute and is very slender in person. I thought their tango was the best of the night.
As soon as Billy Dee was called safe, I knew it would be Diana and Sean. Yes, so rude to eliminate her the way they did. I’m glad she got to do her dance – looked great in her red dress.
Was really sorry to see Sean & Karina go – I think he would have turned into a good dancer and we would have seen more personality. Would have loved to hear his conversation with Conrad Green!
Billy Dee – I do have a soft spot for Billy Dee, as he was the first celebrity I saw when I moved to L.A. circa 1973, however, ready for him to go. I thought their routine was really cute and I see why Emma had the other 2 dancers there to guide him down the stairs. I think this show is too strenuous for him.
Max & Meryl – enjoyed their routine
Danica and Val – didn’t like the whole crying bit. Please just admit you’ve taken lessons before. Erin made the comment to Candace that she’s never had a dance lesson before. Wonder if she will ask Danica that question?
Candace and Mark – Candace is another person so slender – I liked her dress. During the interview when she mentioned her religion, the audience roared & applauded (not me) – but when I watched it at home I didn’t notice it. I enjoyed their dance but I can see that it wasn’t a typical rumba.
Peta and James – I don’t know James from his band or show but I thought he did a good job.
Drew and Cheryl – I like Drew so enjoyed their dance.
Cody and Whitney – Cody has horrible posture. I noticed that last week as well. He dances all hunched over. I don’t think it’s because Whitney is too short – I think he’s just a lanky guy. Maybe Carrie Ann was trying to tell his fans to vote for a taller partner for the switch – who knows what she’s thinking. Not a fan of his dancing.
Erin – I think she’s doing a good job. I like Brooke and was sorry to see her go. Erin’s voice is a little annoying but she’s OK.
Now I have to figure out how to tweet so I can vote for the switch!
Jen#14: ROTFL over your comment:”It seemed that she (Candace) thought that she wasn’t only dancing the Rumba with Mark, but with Matthew, Luke and John, too.” I haven’t laughed that hard in a while, thank you!!!
Jane, Thanks for sharing your point of view as a member of the live audience. It would bug the crap out of me to be forced to stand up for each couple. So silly and it makes it hard for people to see the dancing. Of course, I guess a lot of folks just want to be in the same room with the celebs and pros. Me, I’d just as soon watch from the comfort of my home.
So many people are spelling Danicas name wrong and it’s driving me insane for some reason. I have question when people spam their tweets with only one couple say #dwtsmerylval 10x in one tweet, do those count individually or as one?
I finally got to watch the show. Man, are they *trying* to kill the show??? I agree with what has been said about how they treated Diana, and I’m bummed that both Diana & Henry and Sean & Karina were eliminated. Couldn’t one of the couples going home have been NeNe and Tony instead?
I find I’m not as invested this season as I’ve been other seasons – maybe because the manipulations and tawdriness are increasing, and people who love the show (like Diana) aren’t treated well by TPTB. Tom, of course, does his best – I’m not blaming him.
Jury is still out on Erin for me. However, I’m not liking many of the questions she’s asking – but they may not be her choice, so…
Some random comments – loved Charlie & Sharna and Amy & Derek. NeNe’s costume was *not* flattering to her, and she really didn’t do the jive – and Tony (of course) acts like they’re getting shafted by the scores. While Meryl & Maks were fun, the dance felt like it was mostly lifts, and not enough dancing. Of the two swing dances, I thought that Amy & Derek had (despite not moving around the floor much) more variety in their dancing, and more actual dancing. If some of those contemporaries last week were a bit lift heavy, so was M&M’s swing. Danica & Val were rather forgettable. Cheryl looked *great*. I thought Sean & Karina had more actual salsa than James & Peta, even though James was the better dancer. The great thing about Julianne was that she knew how to be the boss – I don’t think Witney’s learned that yet. And NeNe’s shoes (especially given the situation with Candace) were just wrong.
In one interview, Candace said she wanted to do Viennese waltz – I’m wondering if she picked the music, and TPTB decided that they would give her rumba (possibly specifically because of her views, and so it would cause drama) – because honestly, “Say Something” would make a better V. waltz than rumba.
@Trenta – I would caution against using the same hashtag multiple times in a single tweet – not sure what the magic number is, but Twitter does tend to filter out tweets with multiple uses of the same hashtag as spam. I think you’re ok to use multiple different hashtags in a single tweet, though – so tweeting “#DWTSMerylDerek #DWTSCandaceVal #DWTSNeNeTony #DWTSAmyMark” would be ok, but “#DWTSCandaceVal” ten times in one tweet will probably get thrown out.
The family always picks the family – to their detriment every single time. What they need to remember is that it’s not about THEM, it’s about keeping their celeb in the contest.
Thanks Court, I haven’t been doing that but seen lots of others doing it.
Is anyone can tell my why on ABC, the season premiere of Dancing with the Stars scored a 2.5 adults 18-49 rating, down 19 percent from a 3.2 for last spring’s premiere on March 18, 2013 and ting with fall 2012 as the show’s lowest rated season premiere ever.
I think with the switch-up putting Candace with Derek would be great, out of all the pros I think he would respect her religion & work with her. As someone said having Candace with Val, they sure would look beautiful together but he is to to sexy to be with her, can’t see him being buttoned up. Candace is my favorite
Hey all – I’ve given a lot of thought to this and IMO, I’m really sickened by TPTB that keep promoting those stupid manufactured rivalries. Really, what age demographic are TPTB trying to appeal to here?! Would that be the silly teenagers? Who really cares what Candace is doing/looking like while Danica is getting her scores or dancing?! How many times did the camera switch to the “rival” while the opposite “rival” was on?! Did anyone else get really sick of that?! I think it’s a huge turn-off to the fan base! I think most people are a lot smarter than what TPTB are feeding us!
OK, I’ve said my peace! There’s still a lot I’m enjoying about the show!
Looking back over the entire evening, I believe the most phrases I yelled at the screen was, “Cameraman, show the fully body dance!”. I don’t recall in seasons past so many instances of getting facial close-ups during a dance. Highly annoying. And during Diana and Henry’s final dance, we got audience faces. Very odd.
My thoughts about the dances pretty much match most of you. I think Charlie was the best of the night, Amy and Meryl pretty much tied for me. Unhappy with Carrie Ann already, the comment about Whitney’s height, and the over-the-top silly teenage mess about how sexy she thinks James is. She is supposed to be professional to some degree, but she sure gets silly around handsome men. I don’t mind fun, but to let it effect the scoring based on your sexual attraction to someone, is … sigh, enough already.
Didn’t like NeNe’s shoes. Don’t care for Tony, and haven’t for several seasons now. I’m going to miss seeing Henry. I was so happy for him to get a chance. Maybe next year.
I also saw Sean on GMA, and was very proud of him to tell-all about the argument with Conrad Greene. I doubt he is the first to object to some of that manipulative stuff, but he is the first to tell it like he did. Although I remember D.L. Hughley and David Allen Grier being pretty vocal about it, too, just not so specific perhaps.
I’ll continue to watch this show, but I agree the changes are not all good. First, fix the camera work. It is really awful.
Here are my opinions.
Drew/Cheryl: I definitely think that he will be the Bill of this season. And I do mean both Bills. He has the longevity and the legendaryness of Bill N., but the endearing qualities and the genuine love for what he is doing that Bill E. has. So yeah. He’s obviously not going to be the best dancers but he is just so like able!
Danica/Val: I definitely agree with what others have said, and with what the Afterbuzz team said – she is better at the harder things. I honestly skipped this dance – Danica just doesn’t really interest me. She really kind of annoys me. And hat breakdown? If that continues, she will not last long.
Billy/Emma: Still painful to watch him. I mean, what can you do? He is clearly having problems, and honestly, I think that it would be easier for him if he wasn’t on the show, it would just be better. But I honestly respect Emma SO much for trying so hard with all of her partners. And also for trying to make him feel better… with other girls. GOOD WORK EMMA!
Meryl/Maks: I really liked this dance. Especially the part after the dance where Meryl dragged Maks to the judges table. She is just so awesome and I really just want to be best friends with her. Ok. Anyway, I liked all the lifts that she did. That was cool. I liked how she is stretching Maks to his limits. And yeah. Considering all the twitter craziness, the odds of Derek competing with her next week are high.
Diana/Henry: This was just cruel on all accounts. She definitely made improvements, and I think she could have done better had she continued. However, I do think it was VERY likely that she would have gotten eliminated because of her low dance ability and low fan base. But it was not handled very well.
Now a side note. I personally think that there was a plan to do a double elimination this week. The reason I think so is that the switch-up was already revealed, so the surprise wouldn’t have been how to vote. Having said that, it was NOT handled well. At all. Period.
Candace/Mark: My thoughts were tainted by an amazing contemporary piece from SYTYCD by Amy and Robert this season. The song was bad for a rumba. It didn’t have the right rhythm or anything, but I really appreciate how well she held her place and her point of view. It just wasn’t amazing.
Amy/Derek: She is an inspiration. She did so well! I know that she doesn’t want to be compared to the oers any differently, but it just kind of keeps getting stuck in my head. Derek has done such a good job with costuming so that we don’t focus on her legs more than necessary. They both have a lot of work to do, but I think that this will be a successful pairing all around!
James/Peta: Brant redux. Carrie Ann, calm yourself down around him! This is about dancing, not hotness… oh wait. Never mind. Anyway, I definitely think he did better, but he also still has a lot of room for improvement. I actually think he could do really well with Witney. Hmmm… @Court, what’s the tracking look like for#DWTSJamesWitney?
Charlie/Sharna: Also really good. He truly is the one to beat. I think that the judges nailed him really hard for the hold, and that was just annoying. Yeah. There is really not much that I have to say!
Nene/Tony: Still annoying. Still not great. Still skipping her dances.
Sean/Karina: As much as he said that his elimination had to do with his fight with Conrad, I still think there was supposed to be a double elim this week anyway. Last week, I said that he would have done better if he had submitted to the process a bit more, and I still agree with that. I think he did a lot better than last week, because he started to open up more. Not bad. I think he could have gone kinda far if he had gone on to next week.
Cody/Witney: OMG! All the shade on Witney is annoying her. She really needs to assert herself more with both Cody and the Judges. I think that she still needs some time to develop as a pro. As she goes on, she will improve. I have faith in her. Anyway, I also think Cody needs to start submitting to the process a bit more. He needs to listen to Witney more and let her boss him around. The dance was really cool – I am a sucker for cool lights. And yeah. There is still room to grow.
I must be in the minority with Erin, because I think she is way better than Brooke was. She had interesting questions, and no two were the same(at least they weren’t “how do you feel?” “How was that?” “What did you think of the judge’s score/comment?”) Is she a whole lot better, not really, but the show doesn’t need a co-host, so no one will be great in that role; however, Erin did ask some creative questions, like trying to see what Maks really felt about the scores(and we know he had something he could have said, but is playing nice and biting his tongue). Then again, that’s only my little opinion. To each her own(or his own).
1. Meryl and Maks: I still don’t like the whole idea of the ice dancers/figure skaters, but I’ll digress. This dance was one of the best, if not the best of the night. Who knew Maks could choreograph something like that?! *side note, who replaced Maks with this nice sweet holds his tongue impersonator?*
2. James and Peta: I actually liked this dance, but I also like the star. He has the right amount of humour to play off the constant “hot guy must be shirtless” idea without being cocky or seeming to be too frumpy. Plus his dance was pretty decent.
3. Drew and Cheryl: Not as good as I would have hoped for, but its only week two so I’ll contend that it was good.
4. Candance and Mark: Overall a good dance. I think, given all things that factor into the dance (attitude, costume, song, pro-star relationship, emotions, choreography, etc.) this was an okay rumba. She held back a little, but I do know, from background research(aka a quick google/bing search and reading the articles to see sources) that she is one who does hold rather strongly to the belief that PDA is for a spouse only(and there are ways in movies to uphold that. Either with spousal permission or in some cases switching the actor for the spouse for that shot.) so I think it held her back a little. She has a point, though, and I’ll be devil’s advocate here, that rumba itself is not meant to be sexual, insomuch as it is a sensual dance. It is a slow sensual dance. I don’t know if I’m allowed to make my comparison, so I won’t unless the admins so I can and then I will(don’t wanna get in trouble here) but technically speaking rumba is meant to be less sexual than lambada. Lambada is a sexual dance, but rumba is a sensual dance. That said, this was a little more contemporary, and a little less rumba.
5. Danica and Val: Holey smocks the girl can do pretty well when she is focused on the dance, and not acting like an over-excited two year old at a new disney movie. (Just saying, in week one she was more excited than I was meeting Val at Ballroom with a twist, or my 4 year old is when anything train related is on tv. and that’s pretty excited if you’ve seen a kid overly happy for things) As for her dance, not bad, but could be better. I think Val is still playing it safe with some choreography and needs to pull a Maks and just wow with it.
6. Charlie and Sharna: Same as with Meryl on the figure skater/ice dancer but nonetheless, his dance was good but it was not my favourite. For someone who has experience I would have expected more from him. Might just be me but I thought he could do better, even for week 2.
7. Amy and Derek: I know she has a bit of a disadvantage opposed to the others, but she stil seems stiff when dancing. It almost seems as if she cannot get the spirit of the dances, she is trying, but she just lacks the enthusiasm for the dances.
8. Cody and Whitney: Not a very good tango, but I do respect Whitney for at least attempting to keep it within a tango realm, and to the rules of the dance(even if her star was acting rather Cafone(bull-headed, obstinate)
9. Billy Dee and Emma: I love the pro, and star, but he is unfortunately the weak link this time. Some might be his age, but he was rather “walkish” this time.
10. Nene and Tony: I can not give a response, as I skipped that dance… on purpose…